Vehicle benchmarking calculator: weighted matrix, Pugh, running cost and part level
Vehicle benchmarking compares a car with its rivals on measured numbers, at two levels: the whole product (price, power, mileage, space, safety) and its parts (material, thickness, mass). Drop every car that misses a must-have first, score the rest on weighted attributes, then check how far a weight has to move before the winner changes.
This page is for the Week 4 "Benchmarking" challenge in Skill-Lync's BIW Design and Development Part 1 course: pick a car for D.S. Pughazhyendhii, a family of five in Bangalore with a monthly 500 km drive to Madurai and an ₹8-10 lakh on-road budget. Skill-Lync read 574 public reports on it: 0 use weights of their own, 1 gives a running cost in rupees and 0 work out a break-even. The fourth tab checks your report.
Specs from Tata, Hyundai, Maruti Suzuki, Kia and Mahindra brochures · NIST SP 811 · CBIC GST notifications · checked against a separate script (6,778 checks at build) · Updated 22 Nov 2026
Type your on-road quote in the price row (prices change by city and week, so none is preloaded). Blank cells are values the brochure doesn't print: fill them and the row joins the score. Gates are must-haves: a car that fails one is dropped before any scoring.
| Car | Gates | Score | Rank | Min-max score | Min-max rank | Rows won |
|---|
What flips the winner
Move one attribute's share to p and rescale every other share in proportion, so they still add to 100%. The table gives the nearest share, up and down, at which another car ties the winner; past it, that car wins.
| Attribute | Share now | Raise to | Lower to |
|---|
Pugh matrix
Power units
Power-to-weight, specific output, range
| Car | Power | kW/t | PS/t | Nm/t | kW per litre | Range | Stops on the leg |
|---|
From the matrix in tab 1 (power, torque, kerb weight, engine capacity, tank and certified mileage rows). No brochure read here prints a kerb weight, so type it to get the per-tonne columns. 75 kg a person is the EU type-approval figure (Regulation 1230/2012) and the driver mass in AIS-137; check whether your kerb weight already includes a driver.
Running cost and break-even
Example inputs, made up: 30 km a day, 22 days, 17 and 22 km/l and a ₹1,30,000 premium are not any real car's figures. Type your two variants' certified mileage, the on-road price gap from your quotes and your city's fuel price. Bengaluru's price differs from Delhi's (state VAT) and wasn't on an official page on 22 Nov 2026; Indian Oil gives it by SMS.
Sub-4-metre GST bracket
| Match the benchmark on | Keeps constant | Your thickness | Mass vs benchmark | Panel mass |
|---|
Benchmark panel: . First-order flat-plate formulas: same shape, no change in geometry, no forming, joining or cost. Dent resistance depends on the formed panel's curvature and the yield after paint bake, which these don't model.
| Material | E (GPa) | Density (kg/m³) | Yield (MPa) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mild steel (DC04 deep-drawing) | 210 | 7,800 | 210 (Rp0.2 max, SSAB Form 04) | E: WorldAutoSteel AHSS Insights, "Elastic Modulus" (210 GPa, the common value for steel); density: SSAB (7,800 kg/m³, the same for all carbon steels); yield: SSAB Form 04 (meets DC04, EN 10130) |
| Dual-phase steel CR500Y800T-DP | 210 | 7,800 | 500 (Rp0.2 min, SSAB Docol 800DP) | E and density as mild steel (SSAB: carbon steels share density and modulus); yield: SSAB Docol 800DP, CR500Y800T-DP, Rp0.2 500-650 MPa |
| Aluminium 5182-O | 69.6 | 2,650 | 130 | AZoM, Aluminium 5182 (UNS A95182), 5182-O: 2.65 g/cm³, 69.6 GPa, yield 130 MPa |
| Aluminium 6061 (6xxx) | 68.9 | 2,700 | 276 (typical, temper not stated) | AZoM, Aluminium 6061: 2.7 g/cm³, 68.9 GPa, yield 276 MPa (temper not stated; usual T6 values) |
| Magnesium AZ31B-O | 45 | 1,770 | 150 (typical) | AZoM, Magnesium AZ31B-O (UNS M11311): 1.77 g/cc, 45 GPa, yield 150 MPa |
The example table is made up. You can also fill the rows by hand.
| Car | Price (₹ lakh) | Price type | Power | Unit | Mileage | Mileage type | Fuel | Kerb (kg) |
|---|
In 574 public reports read, as of 22 Nov 2026: 0 use weights of their own, 28 mix bhp and PS, 31 mix on-road and ex-showroom prices, 63 give kerb weight and 44 do any part-level comparison.
What is vehicle benchmarking?
Vehicle benchmarking is measuring your car, or one of its parts, against the best of its rivals so you can set targets. It has two levels. At product level you compare whole cars on price, performance, economy, space and safety. At part level you compare one part, such as a hood, a door or a B-pillar, on its material, thickness and mass.
A spec table is where benchmarking starts, not where it ends. The challenge reports Skill-Lync read stop at the table and pick a car by feel: Tata Nexon in 168 of the 370 reports with a clear pick, and 188 of those 370 give safety or an NCAP rating as the reason. The matrix above turns the same table into a decision you can defend: gates, weights, scores and a sensitivity check.
The example uses five real petrol cars with the values their makers print: Tata Nexon 1.2 turbo petrol MT, Hyundai Venue HX 2 1.2 MPi MT, Maruti Suzuki Brezza LXi 1.5 MT, Kia Sonet HTE 1.2 MT, Mahindra XUV 3XO MX1 1.2 TCMPFi MT. Most brochures read for this page don't print a certified mileage or a kerb weight, and none prints the price you will pay, so those rows start blank. With them blank the example scores on 6 rows and XUV 3XO comes first. That is a property of the rows that are filled, not a recommendation.
How do you make a weighted decision matrix for cars?
Four steps, in this order.
- Gates first. Drop every car that fails a must-have: on-road price above ₹10 lakh, fewer than 5 seats. Gates come before scoring for two reasons. A car outside the budget must not win on points. And if it stayed in, its values would set the "best" that every other car is scored against.
- Normalise. Turn each attribute into a 0 to 1 score so kW and litres can be added. Ratio to best divides by the best value; min-max stretches the worst to 0 and the best to 1.
- Weight. Give each attribute points; the page turns them into shares of 100%.
- Add and test. The weighted sum ranks the cars. Then ask how much a weight must change to change the winner.
The two normalisations can rank cars differently. Ratio to best keeps proportions: 170 Nm against 200 Nm scores 0.85. Min-max makes the same 30 Nm gap the full range of the row if those are the two ends, so a small spread counts as much as a big one. If every car has the same value (all five example cars have 6 airbags), the row can't separate them: the page gives every car full marks there, so it changes no rank. Pick one method before you look at the result, and say which.
Rank order centroid weights (Barron and Barrett, 1996) are a fair start when you can only say which attribute matters more, not by how much. For the attribute ranked i of n:
The "Weights from rank order" button keeps your order and replaces the numbers with these.
Why these weights for D.S. Pughazhyendhii's family?
The challenge fixes the gates: ₹8-10 lakh on-road and room for five. The weights are judgement. Below is one reasonable set, the preset in the matrix. Change any of them; the sensitivity table shows which changes matter.
| Attribute | Better | Weight | Why (example reasoning) |
|---|---|---|---|
| On-road price | lower | 20 + gate ≤ 10 | The brief is ₹8-10 lakh on-road: above 10 is out (the gate); inside it, cheaper is better. |
| Certified fuel efficiency | higher | 20 | About 1,000 km a month to Madurai and back plus the office commute: fuel is the biggest running cost. |
| Airbags | higher | 15 | A five-year-old and two elderly parents ride in it. |
| Boot space | higher | 10 | Luggage for five people on a 500 km trip. |
| Wheelbase | higher | 10 | A stand-in for rear-seat room for three adults; sit in the car to check. |
| Max torque | higher | 8 | Five people and luggage on the highway. |
| Max power | higher | 5 | Overtaking on the highway; less important than torque for this use. |
| Fuel tank | higher | 5 | Fewer fuel stops on the 500 km leg. |
| Ground clearance | higher | 4 | Speed breakers and bad patches in the city. |
| Overall length | lower | 3 | A shorter car is easier to park in a crowded city. |
| Seats | higher | 0 + gate ≥ 5 | Five people: a must-have, not a score. |
How much does a weight have to change to flip the winner?
Change one attribute's share, Wk, to a new value p. To keep the shares adding to 100%, scale every other share by the same factor:
Then each car's score is a straight line in p:
The current winner A loses its place where another car B's line crosses it:
The page solves this for every car and keeps the nearest crossing above and below the current share. If no crossing lies between 0 and 100%, no share of that attribute alone can change the winner. In the example, torque's share is 17.4%: no share up to 100% changes the winner, and lowering it to 2.8% hands the lead to Nexon. A pick that flips when a weight moves by a few points is a close call. Say so in the report.
What is a Pugh matrix, and how is it different?
Stuart Pugh's concept selection picks one option as the datum and marks every other option +, 0 or − against it on each criterion. It needs no exact numbers, which is why design teams use it early. The cost is that +1 means "better" whether the gap is 2 Nm or 50 Nm, so a band decides when a gap is too small to count. The matrix tab prints the Pugh view of the same table, with the plain count and a weighted count. With the Nexon as datum in the example, the Venue scores 1 +, 2 − and 5 same.
Is car power in PS, bhp or kW?
The brochures read for this page print kW, and some add PS in brackets: Hyundai prints the Venue at "61 kW (83 PS)" and Maruti Suzuki the Brezza at "75.8 kW (103.05 PS)". Tata, Kia and Mahindra print kW only. Car portals print "bhp". The two horsepowers differ (NIST SP 811):
61 kW is 82.9 PS and 81.8 hp. CarWale lists the Venue HX 2 at "82 bhp @ 6000 rpm" (read 22 Nov 2026), which is the 61 kW written in mechanical hp. So a table that quotes one car in PS from the brochure and another in bhp from a portal is off by about 1.4%: small, but it can reverse a close row. 28 of the 574 reports mix the two. Use kW.
Power-to-weight needs a kerb weight, which only 63 reports give:
How far does a car go on a full tank?
Tank times certified fuel efficiency, times your own real-world share. The Brezza brochure prints a 48 L tank and 21.09 km/l for the LXi manual, "as certified by test agency under Rule 115 of CMVR 1989":
At the certified figure that covers the 500 km Bangalore-Madurai leg with no fuel stop. The certified figure is a laboratory number: in India the Type I test runs the Modified Indian Driving Cycle (MIDC) on a chassis dynamometer, by the AIS-137 (Part 3) procedure that CMVR rule 115F points to. Road figures are usually lower. One ICCT study of three 2015 cars measured 20 to 25% lower fuel economy on the road; that is three cars, not a rule, so the page's default stays at 100%. Set the real-world share in tab 2 to your own measured km/l divided by the certified one. Only 13 of 574 reports work out a range.
Is diesel cheaper than petrol for 1,000 km a month?
Per kilometre, a diesel usually burns less money; it also costs more to buy. The break-even is the price premium divided by the saving:
14 reports copy "Diesel variant which helps to save fuel costs" word for word (1, 2), and 0 of 574 work out a break-even. Tab 2 does it with your quotes: the family's 1,000 km a month of Madurai trips plus the commute, each variant's certified mileage, and today's fuel price (Indian Oil's Delhi build-up for 1 Nov 2026 is ₹102.12 petrol and ₹95.2 diesel a litre; Bengaluru's is different). The answer is in years and in kilometres, so it can be held against how long the family will keep the car.
Why are so many Indian compact SUVs 3,995 mm long?
Because GST treats a car up to 4,000 mm long as a small car, if its engine is small too: petrol, LPG or CNG up to 1,200 cc, diesel up to 1,500 cc. From 22 Sep 2025 small cars pay 18% GST and every other motor car 40%, with no compensation cess (Notification 9/2025-Central Tax (Rate), Schedule II S. Nos. 534-535, Schedule III item 5); electric cars pay 5%. Before that, all cars paid 28% GST plus a cess of 1% for small petrol cars and 3% for small diesel cars, against 17%, 20% or 22% for bigger cars (2017 compensation cess notifications). So makers stop at 3,990 to 3,995 mm.
The length alone isn't enough. A 3,995 mm car with a 1,462 cc petrol engine, like the Brezza here, is over the 1,200 cc petrol limit, so it falls in the 40% bracket. 70 of the 574 reports mention the sub-4 m rule.
| Car (example) | Length (mm) | Engine (cc) | Bracket from 22 Sep 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tata Nexon 1.2 turbo petrol MT | 3995 | 1199 | Small car: petrol, LPG or CNG, up to 1,200 cc and up to 4,000 mm (Schedule II, S. No. 534): 18% |
| Hyundai Venue HX 2 1.2 MPi MT | 3995 | 1197 | Small car: petrol, LPG or CNG, up to 1,200 cc and up to 4,000 mm (Schedule II, S. No. 534): 18% |
| Maruti Suzuki Brezza LXi 1.5 MT | 3995 | 1462 | Other motor car (Schedule III, item 5): 40% |
| Kia Sonet HTE 1.2 MT | 3995 | 1197 | Small car: petrol, LPG or CNG, up to 1,200 cc and up to 4,000 mm (Schedule II, S. No. 534): 18% |
| Mahindra XUV 3XO MX1 1.2 TCMPFi MT | 3990 | not printed | — |
Rates as notified, read 22 Nov 2026. Hybrids have their own entries with the same 1,200 cc / 1,500 cc / 4,000 mm limits (S. Nos. 538-539). The XUV 3XO brochure prints "1.2 L", not a cc figure, so its row isn't placed. The notification says the specification is "determined as per the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988".
How thick must an aluminium panel be to match a steel one?
It depends on what it has to match. For a flat plate in bending, stiffness goes with E t³; in-plane (membrane) stiffness with E t; bending strength with σy t². Keep the one that matters constant and solve for the new thickness (Ashby's material-index logic):
For a 0.7 mm steel hood outer against aluminium 6061 (6xxx), with the moduli in the table in tab 3:
So the aluminium panel is about 45% thicker and 50% lighter at the same bending stiffness. Matching in-plane stiffness instead needs 2.13 mm, and the aluminium panel is then 6% heavier; matching bending strength needs 0.61 mm. That is the part-level benchmarking the course asks for, and only 44 of 574 reports do any of it (example).
First-order only: same flat geometry, no change in curvature or beads, no forming, joining, corrosion or cost. A real switch to aluminium changes the part's shape too.
What did 574 student benchmarking reports do?
Skill-Lync fetched 700 of the 2,442 public "Benchmarking" reports at random and read the 574 with real text (report dates 26 Feb 2019 to 21 Oct 2024). Each row counts reports, not mentions.
| What the report does | Reports of 574 |
|---|---|
| Use weights of their own, or a weighted score | 0 |
| Show a score table (both copied from a car portal) | 2 |
| Give a running cost in rupees | 1 |
| Work out a diesel vs petrol break-even or payback | 0 |
| Copy "Diesel variant which helps to save fuel costs" word for word | 14 |
| Work out range on a full tank (tank × mileage) | 13 |
| Give kerb weight | 63 |
| Give power-to-weight | 17 |
| Quote power in "bhp" | 249 |
| Quote power in PS | 52 |
| Mix bhp and PS in one report | 28 |
| Quote on-road prices | 357 |
| Quote ex-showroom prices | 48 |
| Use both price types | 31 |
| Name ARAI or certified mileage | 226 |
| Give city or real-world mileage | 54 |
| Mention NCAP (Global NCAP by name: 107) | 291 |
| Do any part-level comparison (material, thickness, "part level") | 44 |
| Mention the sub-4 m rule | 70 |
- A pick, not a decision. 370 reports name a clear final car. The Nexon is 168 of them (45%), and 188 give safety or NCAP stars as the reason. No report weighs safety against anything else with numbers.
- Costs without numbers. 1 report gives a running cost in rupees, although the case is about 1,000 km a month of highway driving.
- One level of two. Several reports say benchmarking has a product and a part level, and 44 do any part-level work.
Counts as of 22 Nov 2026, n = 574, from the text of each report, hits read by hand (Skill-Lync's own data, a starting point, not a grade). Tables posted as images aren't counted.
What this page does not cover
- Prices. No price is preloaded: on-road prices change by city, variant and week. Type your quotes.
- Crash ratings. No star rating is preloaded. Global NCAP's ratings since 2022 use a different protocol from its 2014-2021 ones, and Bharat NCAP is a separate programme, so stars from different protocols can't be compared. Add a row with the rating, programme and year for each car.
- Specs that brochures don't print. Certified mileage for four of the five cars, kerb weight for all five, and ground clearance for four are not in the documents read; the cells are blank for you to fill from an official source.
- The Nexon's current brochure. Tata's car site couldn't be read on 22 Nov 2026, so the Nexon values come from Tata's own 14 Sep 2023 launch spec sheet. Check them against the current brochure.
- Real panels. The part-level formulas are for flat plates. Formed panels, beads, curvature and joining change the answer.
Benchmarking is the first step of a BIW programme: it sets the targets every part is designed to. It is week 4 of Skill-Lync's BIW Design and Development Part 1 course, followed by the hood, fender and door design.
Frequently asked questions
What is benchmarking in the automotive industry?
Comparing your car, or one of its parts, with the best competitors on measured numbers. Product-level benchmarking compares whole cars: price, power, mileage, space, safety. Part-level benchmarking compares parts: a hood's material, thickness and mass. The aim is a target for your design, not a list of specs copied from a portal.
How do you make a weighted decision matrix for cars?
List the attributes, mark each higher- or lower-is-better, and drop any car that misses a must-have such as the budget. Turn each value into a 0 to 1 score, give each attribute a weight, and add up weight times score. Then test how far a weight must move before the winner changes.
What is the difference between PS and bhp?
PS is metric horsepower, 735.49875 W; mechanical horsepower (hp) is 745.69987 W, so 1 PS is 0.9863 hp. Indian brochures print kW, some with PS. Hyundai prints the Venue at 61 kW (83 PS). 61 kW is 81.8 hp, and CarWale lists the same car at "82 bhp": the portal figure is mechanical hp.
Is a diesel car cheaper to run than petrol?
Per kilometre often yes, but it costs more to buy. Divide the price premium by the monthly fuel saving to get the months to break even, and by the saving per km to get the kilometres. At low monthly kilometres it can take years. Use your own on-road quotes, certified mileage and today's fuel price.
What is a Pugh matrix?
A concept-selection table from Stuart Pugh. Pick one option as the datum. Mark every other option better (+), same (0) or worse (−) than the datum on each criterion, then count. It needs no exact numbers, which makes it quick, but it hides how much better. A tolerance band decides when a small difference counts as same.
Why are so many Indian compact SUVs just under 4 metres?
Because GST treats a car up to 4,000 mm long with a petrol, LPG or CNG engine up to 1,200 cc, or a diesel up to 1,500 cc, as a small car. Since 22 September 2025 small cars pay 18% GST and other cars 40%. Makers stop at 3,990 to 3,995 mm, but a bigger engine still means 40%.
Related on Skill-Lync
- Automotive benchmarking: the four types, teardown and a worked example
- What is body in white (BIW)?
- Gas strut calculator: hood and tailgate struts
- Bend allowance calculator: sheet metal flat lengths
- Gradeability calculator: what a car's torque and gearing climb
- BIW design courses and automotive design courses
- Student project: Benchmarking (product and part level)
- All free engineering tools
Sources
- Tata Motors product note and spec sheet, 14 Sep 2023, read 22 Nov 2026: Nexon brochure or spec sheet. Tata's launch spec sheet, not a current per-variant brochure (cars.tatamotors.com could not be read on 22 Nov 2026: its certificate had expired). Ground clearance printed as 'best in segment ground clearance of 208mm', laden or unladen not stated.
- Hyundai Venue brochure (Apr 2026), read 22 Nov 2026: Venue brochure or spec sheet. Power printed as '61 kW (83 PS) @ 6 000 r/min'. Boot 375 litres 'as per VDA 215 method'.
- Maruti Suzuki New Brezza brochure (Jul 2026), read 22 Nov 2026: Brezza brochure or spec sheet. Power printed as '75.8 kW (103.05 PS) @ 6000 rpm'. Fuel efficiency 'LXi/VXi MT 21.09 km/l', 'as certified by test agency under Rule 115 of CMVR 1989'.
- Kia Sonet brochure (Mar 2026) and kia.com/in specs page, read 22 Nov 2026: Sonet brochure or spec sheet. Power printed as 'Max. Power (kW/ RPM) 61/ 6 000', kW only. Boot 385 l, VDA method (specs page https://www.kia.com/in/our-vehicles/sonet/specs.html).
- Mahindra XUV 3XO brochure (Oct 2026), p. 28, read 22 Nov 2026: XUV 3XO brochure or spec sheet. Capacity printed as '1.2 L' (no cc). Power '82 kW @ 5000 r/min'. Boot '364', 'as per ISO V215'. Length 3990 mm.
- Indian Oil price build-up of petrol and diesel at Delhi, effective 01-Nov-26 (linked from iocl.com/petrol-diesel-price): petrol, diesel.
- CarWale, Hyundai Venue HX 2 specifications page, read 22 Nov 2026: "82 bhp @ 6000 rpm" (for the PS vs bhp comparison only).
- B. N. Taylor and A. Thompson, NIST Special Publication 811 (2008), Guide for the Use of the International System of Units, Appendix B.9: horsepower (550 ft·lbf/s) = 745.699 87 W, horsepower (metric) = 735.498 75 W.
- Notification No. 9/2025-State Tax (Rate), Maharashtra, 17 Sep 2025 (the state copy of 9/2025-Central Tax (Rate)), PDF: Schedule II S. Nos. 534, 535, 538, 539 (small cars and small hybrids, 9% + 9%), Schedule III items 5-7 (other cars, 20% + 20%), Schedule I S. No. 441 (electric vehicles, 2.5% + 2.5%). GST Council, FAQ on the 56th GST Council decisions (3 Sep 2025), Q1, Q26, Q27: in force 22 Sep 2025, small cars 28% to 18%, larger cars 40% without cess.
- Notification No. 1/2017-Compensation Cess (Rate), 28 Jun 2017, S. Nos. 50 and 51 (small petrol, LPG, CNG cars 1%; small diesel cars 3%), and No. 5/2017-Compensation Cess (Rate), 11 Sep 2017, S. Nos. 52, 52A, 52B (17%, 20%, 22%), CBIC copies via the Internet Archive.
- ARAI, AIS-137 (Part 3), Type I test on the Modified Indian Driving Cycle (MIDC), Chapter 19 (fuel consumption of M1 vehicles, CMVR rule 115F, G.S.R. 954(E), 4 Oct 2016), clauses 2.1-2.2 (unladen mass without the 75 kg driver; reference mass = unladen + 150 kg). EU Regulation 1230/2012, Art. 2(20) and Annex I Part A 2.6.2.1: 75 kg for the driver and for each passenger.
- ICCT, "Laboratory and on-road emission testing of in-use passenger vehicles in India": fuel economy 20 to 25% lower on the road than the type-approval value for three model-year-2015 cars tested by ICAT.
- Materials: WorldAutoSteel, AHSS Insights, Elastic Modulus ("The common value for the slope of steel is 210 GPa"; it varies with direction and prestrain); SSAB, "Innovative design with high-strength steel" (2015): all carbon steels have "the same density (7,800 kg/m3)" and Young's modulus (SSAB uses 200 GPa); SSAB Form 04 and Docol 800DP product pages (yield); AZoM data sheets for 5182-O, 6061 and AZ31B-O.
- Plate indices: B. Thijsse, TU Delft OpenCourseWare Materiaalkunde 1 (after Ashby), chapter 5 slide 20 (light stiff panel, index E^1/3/ρ) and chapter 7 slide 18 (light strong panel, σy^1/2/ρ).
- Rank order centroid formula as printed in M. A. Hatefi, "An Improved Rank Order Centroid Method (IROC)", Informatica 34(2), 2023, Eq. (2).
- Global NCAP fact sheets: Tata Nexon 2018 (5 stars adult, 16.06 of 17 points) and 2024 under the 2022 assessment protocols (5 stars adult, 32.22 of 34 points).
- F. H. Barron and B. E. Barrett, "Decision quality using ranked attribute weights", Management Science 42(11), 1996: rank order centroid weights.
- S. Pugh, Total Design (1991): concept selection against a datum.
- Skill-Lync, 574 public Week 4 Benchmarking reports read 22 Nov 2026. scripts/verify/benchmarking.py redoes every number with exact fractions, a brute-force weight sweep and a root finder, 399 cases; the page checks itself against it at build time (6,778 checks).