Structural Analysis in ANSYS: Guide to Choosing the Right Simulation Method

Structural analysis is a crucial component of engineering design that helps ensure the safety, reliability, and performance of structures and mechanical components. ANSYS is a powerful simulation software that offers various methods for structural analysis. 

However, choosing the right simulation method can be challenging as each method has its strengths and limitations. This blog post will guide you through the structural analysis methods available in ANSYS and help you choose the best method for your simulation needs. 

Types of Structural Analysis in ANSYS 

ANSYS provides a range of features for performing different types of structural analysis, including linear static analysis, nonlinear analysis, modal analysis, and transient dynamic analysis. Let's discuss the types of structural analysis in detail.

• Linear Static Analysis

Linear static analysis is a commonly used method in ANSYS for simulating the behavior of a structure under a static load. This method assumes that the behavior of the structure is linear, which means that the relationship between the applied load and the resulting deformation is linear. The structure is subjected to a known load in this method, and the resulting stress and deformation are calculated. Linear static analysis suits structures that experience loads within their linear elastic range.

Linear static analysis is a quick and straightforward method that provides accurate results for simple geometries. It is ideal for analyzing structures such as beams, trusses, and frames under constant loads. However, it may not be suitable for complex geometries, non-linear materials, and dynamic loads.

• Nonlinear Analysis

Nonlinear analysis is a more advanced ANSYS method that can simulate a structure's behavior under non-linear conditions, such as large deformations, plasticity, and contact. In this method, the relationship between the applied load and the resulting deformation is non-linear, which means that the structure's behavior changes as the load increases. Nonlinear analysis is suitable for structures that experience large deformations or non-linear materials. Nonlinear analysis is a complex method that requires more computational resources and expertise. It is ideal for analyzing complex geometries and structures under extreme conditions, such as impact and crash simulations. The nonlinear analysis provides more accurate results than linear static analysis but requires careful attention to detail in the simulation setup.

• Modal Analysis

Modal analysis is a method in ANSYS that can determine a structure's natural frequencies and modes of vibration. It can be used to identify the structural modes that are most susceptible to failure due to resonance. In this method, the structure is subjected to a small harmonic load, and the resulting vibration is measured. Modal analysis suits structures that experience dynamic loads, such as bridges, wind turbines, and aircraft.

Modal analysis is a useful method for identifying a structure's natural frequencies and modes, which can help engineers design structures to avoid resonance. It is also used to design damping systems that can reduce the effects of vibration. However, the modal analysis does not consider the effects of nonlinear behavior or large deformations, so it is unsuitable for simulating structures under extreme conditions.

• Transient Dynamic Analysis

Transient dynamic analysis is a method in ANSYS that can simulate the behavior of a structure under time-varying loads, such as impact, explosion, or seismic events. It considers the effects of inertia, damping, and nonlinear behavior in the simulation. In this method, the structure is subjected to a time-varying load, and the resulting stress and deformation are calculated over time. Transient dynamic analysis is suitable for structures that experience high-speed impact or vibration, such as automotive crash simulations, earthquake simulations, and blast simulations.

Transient dynamic analysis is a complex method that requires more computational resources and expertise. It provides accurate results for structures under extreme conditions but requires careful attention to detail in the simulation setup.

Choosing the right method for structural analysis in ANSYS

Choosing the right method for structural analysis in ANSYS can be challenging. Here are some key considerations to help you select the appropriate method for your analysis.

• Identify the type of analysis needed

ANSYS offers various structural analyses, including linear static, nonlinear static, dynamic, and fatigue analyses. Each of these analyses has its specific requirements, and selecting the wrong method can lead to inaccurate results.

• Consider the complexity of the model

The complexity of the model is another critical factor to consider when selecting the appropriate analysis method in ANSYS. For simple models, linear static analysis may be sufficient. However, for more complex models, nonlinear static or dynamic analyses may be required to accurately predict the behavior of the structure under different loading conditions.

• Evaluate the material properties

The material properties of the structure being analyzed are also essential considerations when choosing the right method in ANSYS. For example, a nonlinear analysis may be necessary if the material exhibits nonlinear behavior. Additionally, the material properties' accuracy can affect the analysis results' validity.

• Determine the boundary conditions

Boundary conditions are the constraints applied to the model during the analysis. They can significantly impact the analysis results, and therefore, they need to be carefully considered when selecting the appropriate method in ANSYS. For example, a dynamic analysis with appropriate boundary conditions would be necessary if the structure is subjected to dynamic loads.

• Consider computational resources

The model's complexity and the type of analysis selected can impact the computational resources required to perform the analysis. Therefore, it is essential to consider the available computational resources when selecting the appropriate method in ANSYS.

Skill-Lync’s course on Structural Analysis in ANSYS can help you advance your career by equipping you with the skills, knowledge, and practical experience needed to succeed in the domain of structural analysis. You can book a demo class with us to learn more.