AIM :
To Comparative study of different storey buildings for Seismic forces
INTRODUCTION :
Introduction:-
The emergence of technology gives rise to newer challenges. The new challenges are the result of human desire for achieving more and more and this results in never-ending thoughts to build something enormous every day. The newer technologies are the outcome of our desire. To fulfill those desires, we humans tend to innovate newer inventions and discoveries. That’s called development. A big picture of our desirable thoughts. But also there lies one more area that is leading the way towards a newer world. Designing is that area through which the initiation of large innovations and discoveries begins. This design can be related to any field of engineering. But right now as are dealing with ETABS software so our main focus would on designing as a civil engineer. To learn this software, online ETABS courses are available widely on the internet which should be tried at least once by every civil engineering aspirant.
What is ETABS software?
ETABS being Extended 3D analysis of Building Systems is a design and analytic software used for designing and mathematically analyze all the physical and theoretical aspects of structures and buildings. The building could be a skyscraper or multi-story house. It’s an advanced level software used more widely for multi-story buildings. It is considered a highly advanced tool for civil engineers in designing and structural analysis. With the help of advanced but user-friendly tools, It’s easy to design any complex buildings at higher efficiency.
SEISMIC ANALYSIS :
Seismic analysis is a tool for the estimation of structural response in the process of designing earthquake resistant structures and/or retrofitting vulnerable existing structures. In principle, the problem is difficult because the structural response to strong earthquakes is dynamic, nonlinear and random.
PROCEDURE :
First we create the 10 different type of building design like as,
- BUILDING A
-
BUILDING B
- BUILDING C
4. BUILDING D
5. BUILDING E
6. BUILDING F
7. BUILDING G
8. BUILDING H
9. BUILDING I
10. BUILDING J
1.) BUILDING A :
STEP 1:
- Open the etab software
- Open the new model at the left top corners
- After click the new model there open the model initialization dialouge box
- In the box we can see a 3 option and then select the last option
- Set the unit as " METRIC SI " and set the steel section data base as " indian " and set the code as 800:2007 for 3rd option. finally set the code 456:2000 for last option



- After finishing the previous process then open new model quick template opened automatically
- we can set the grid dimension as custom and also the story dimension
- Next we can set the number of storys and height of the story in x grid data
- And also same the process in y grid data and then ok
- And we give the name for the story as base, plint , story1, story2
- And set the height of the plinth as 1.5m and other all as 3m
- Then set the all story, similar to story 1 except plinth
- Finally click ok



STEP 2:
- In there we can saw the grids and story are created above the picture
- Next we go to the define option and select the material properties
- Then there open a define material box and select the add new material option
- And select the region "INDIAN" , material type "concrete", standard "INDIAN", grade "M30"
- then click ok



- After here opening the material property data box
- Set the material name like M30
- Then material type "Concrete"
- Others are automatically update with use code given
- Finally click ok
- Again click the add new material
- again set add new material properties
- Here we can set the matrial properties as "rebar"
- And then click ok

_1648569784.png)
STEP 3:
- Next go the define option and select the section properties and go to the frame section
- Select the concrete rectangle and click ok
- And set the material name as (B300 X 400) and material "M30"
- Go to the modify show rebar
- And set the design type M3 beam and give the rebar material as HYSD 415 for both
- And then click ok
_1648569854.png)
_1648569944.png)
_1648570002.png)
_1648570084.png)
_1648570129.png)
- Next we can open the same concrete rectangle and select the column in here
- And set the material name as (C800 X 800) and material "M30"
- Go to the modify show rebar
- And set the rebar as HYSD415 for both
- Finally click ok
_1648570171.png)
_1648570205.png)
STEP 4:
- Go to the define tab and select the section properties and then select the slab section
- After there open a slab properties box
- and click modify option and then set properties name "slab 150"
- Give the slab material " M30"
- And modeling type " membrane"
- Give the thickness of slab as 150mm
- Finally click ok
_1648570266.png)
_1648570301.png)
_1648570339.png)
- Go to the define and select the load patterns
- set or make the loads like dead, live, wall, EQX, EQY
- Give the IS code value for EXQ, EXY
- Taken the both load and set the (DIRECTION AND ECCENTRICITY)
- EXQ - only select the x-dirction
- EXY - only select the y-dirction
- And set the seismic zone factor for per code as per the rule of code book (0.16)
- And set the site type as (II)
- This process is same for both the EQX, EQY
- Here wall load is super dead load
_1648570688.png)
_1648570729.png)
_1648570760.png)
STEP 5:
- Again go to the define option
- And select the load cases
- After opening the load cases dialouge box check once
- And then click ok
- Taken the define option and select the mass source
- After opening the mass source dialouge box
- Just give a modify option to modify it
- Just select only the specify load pattern and other then unselect it
- And give the load patterns as dead load, live load, wall load
- Give the value of the dead load and wall load as (1)
- give the value of live load as (0.25)
- Then click ok
_1648570814.png)
_1648570844.png)
_1648570873.png)
STEP 6:
- Again go to the define option and select the load combination
- After opening the load combination dialouge box
- Just select the concrete frame design
- And select "converet to user combination" option
- Then click ok
- After that we can see the combination of load are automatically placed with help of code designs
- Let now we can arrage the materials and loads on the design
- go to the quick draw column option in the left to corner
- After clicking the box will appear in left bottom corner
- there we want to set the properties as we alredy maked column
- And go the plan view and and placed the coloumn on the grid . Is shown in the below image
- Just use the replicate option to make the multiple or copy paste the column to all the grid
_1648570931.png)
_1648570976.png)
_1648571004.png)
- Use the quick draw beam option in the left corner
- After clicking the box will appear in left bottom corner
- there we want to set the properties as we alredy maked beam (B300 x 400)
- And go the plan view and and placed the coloumn on the grid . Is shown in the below image
- Just use the replicate option to make the multiple or copy paste the beam to all the grid
- Select the quick draw floor option to draw the slab
- select all stories
- and select the alredy create slab150 in the properties
- And just pick in the story
- the all slab are create image as given below
_1648571063.png)
_1648571107.png)
_1648571146.png)
_1648571208.png)
STEP 7:
- Go to the select tab
- then pick the properties and select the freame sections
- go to the select by frame property dialouge box
- Select the beams and click ok
- the selected beams are shown there in below image
_1648571255.png)
_1648571296.png)
_1648571337.png)
_1648571375.png)
- open the selected plan views
- select the story 1 option
- And then select the similar story option
- Go to the assign tab select the frame load
- And assign the distributed load
- Select the load pattern name as "wall" (sdl)
- give the load value of 10 KN/m
- Here loads are assigned image as given below
- loads are assigned for all the floors
_1648571422.png)
_1648571449.png)
_1648571473.png)
_1648571512.png)
STEP 8:
- Go to the select tab and pick the select option
- click the properties option and pick the slab section
- In there open a dialouge box for select by slab property
- select the slab 150
- the slab selected image as given below
- Go to the assign tab and select the shell load
- And select the uniform
- Then there will open the (shell load assignment) dialouge box
- give the load pattern name as (live load)
- And give the load value as 3 kn/m2
- Finally then click ok
_1648571560.png)
_1648571585.png)
_1648571610.png)
- The load as been assigned in the shell as been showed below the image
- Go to the assign tab
- Then select the shell and pick the diaphragms
- tHere automatically open the shell assignment dialouge box
- In the dialouge box select the (d1) option
- the diaphragms as placed at the center of the building
- After finishing the all loads aasignment
- just go to the run analysis option as shown below
- After click the run analysis option they asked a save file option
- just save the file and run the analysis
- After finishing the analysis
- the deformation of building as been showned in the screen and its shown in below the image
- Go to the model exploser tab
- pick the tabel option
- and pick the analysis results
- click the structural outputs
- and then click the model information
- finally we saw the tabels from the model information
- pick the tables. they shown the model periods frequencies and we taken the value in there
_1648571702.png)
_1648571664.png)
_1648571734.png)
_1648571769.png)
2.) BUILDING B :
STEP 1:
- Go to the file option and go to the save as option
- And saved the name as etab 2 A) but. I can rename it finally building B
- Go to the edit option
- And go to the edit stories and grid system
- Click the modify option
- After go to the add storey and click keep editing story height
_1648575514.png)
_1648575546.png)
_1648575574.png)
_1648575599.png)
- After pick the add story
- Just give the number of added stories (3)
- And then added story image as given below
- Pick the display shell load assign option on the tool bar
- And then apply
- load as been applied 3 kn as shown in below image
_1648575651.png)
_1648575681.png)
_1648575887.png)
_1648575708.png)
STEP 2:
- Go to the display frame load assigns on the top tool bar
- And give the wall (sdl) load and click ok
- the load as been assigned and the image as given below
- And go to the select option
- pick the select and then properties
- click on the slab section
- select the slab 150
- after select the slab, go to the assign tab
- select the shell and pick the diaphragms
- pick the d1 and then click ok
- the diaphragms as placed on the building image as given below
- Finally pick the run analysis option on the tool bar
- Then deformed shape buildings are shown below the image
_1648575918.png)
_1648575953.png)
_1648575989.png)
_1648576036.png)
_1648576174.png)
_1648576134.png)
_1648576206.png)
_1648608850.png)
_1648576236.png)
3.) BUILDING C :
STEP 1:
- Go to the file option and go to the save as option
- And saved the name as etab 2 b). but I can rename it finally building C
- Go to the define option
- select the section properties and select the frame section
- Next frame properties dialouge box can be opened
- pick the c400x400 and modify the size as 550 x 300 and then click ok
- The column size as been changed image as given below
_1648576404.png)
_1648576433.png)
_1648576460.png)
_1648576494.png)
_1648576528.png)
STEP 2:
- Go to the select tab in the top tool bar
- And select the select option and go to the properties
- And pick the frame section
- then there will open the select properties dialouge box and select the column size 550x300
- Next go to the assign option on the top tool bar
- go to the frame and select the local axes
- The frame assignment dialouge box as been opened
- And select the angel and set the value 90
_1648576563.png)
_1648576605.png)
_1648576648.png)
_1648576684.png)
_1648576717.png)
STEP 3:
- pick the select and then properties
- click on the slab section
- select the slab 150
- after select the slab, go to the assign tab
- select the shell and pick the diaphragms
- pick the d1 and then click ok
- the diaphragms as placed on the building image as given below
- Finally pick the run analysis option on the tool bar
- Then deformed shape buildings are shown below the image
_1648576750.png)
_1648576787.png)
_1648576818.png)
_1648576851.png)
_1648608850.png)
_1648576919.png)
4.) BUILDING D :
STEP 1:
- Go to the file option and go to the save as option
- And saved the name as etab 2 C). but I can rename it finally building D
- Go to the define option
- select the section properties and select the frame section
- Next frame properties dialouge box can be opened
- pick the C550 x 300 and then click ok
- The column size as been changed image as given below
_1648607340.png)
_1648607374.png)
_1648607426.png)
- Go to the select tab in the top tool bar
- And select the select option and go to the properties
- And pick the frame section
- then there will open the select properties dialouge box and select the column size 550x300
- Next go to the assign option on the top tool bar
- go to the frame and select the local axes
- The frame assignment dialouge box as been opened
- And select the angel and set the value 0
-
_1648607445.png)
_1648607490.png)
_1648607469.png)
STEP 2:
- pick the select and then properties
- click on the slab section
- select the slab 150
- after select the slab, go to the assign tab
- select the shell and pick the diaphragms
- pick the d1 and then click ok
- the diaphragms as placed on the building image as given below
- Finally pick the run analysis option on the tool bar
- Then deformed shape buildings are shown below the image
_1648607583.png)
_1648607615.png)
_1648607634.png)
_1648608850.png)
_1648607655.png)
5.) BUILDING E :
STEP 1:
- Go to the file option and go to the save as option
- And saved the name as etab 2 D). but I can rename it finally building E
- Go to the edit option
- And go to the edit stories and grid system
- Click the modify option
- After go to the add storey and click keep editing story height
- After pick the add story
- Just give the extend the added stories to (5)
- And then added story image as given below
- Pick the display shell load assign option on the tool bar
- And then apply
- load as been applied 3 kn as shown in below image
- And go to the frame loads and set wall and click ok
_1648608939.png)
_1648608977.png)
_1648612481.png)
_1648612503.png)
_1648612519.png)
_1648612541.png)
_1648612565.png)
STEP 2:
- Go to the define option on the tool bar
- select the section properties
- pick the frame section and select the rectangle concrete
- And set the column C600x600
- And also select the another concrete size as c400x400
- and set the rebar material as HYSD415
_1648612584.png)
_1648612624.png)
_1648612607.png)
_1648612641.png)
_1648612665.png)
STEP 3:
- Go to the view and select the set view option
- And unselect the beam and floors then click apply
- Again go to the view and select set building view limits
- And the dialouge as been opened
- select the bottom story 6 to top story story 10
- Select all the columns
- And go the assign select the frame and pick the section properties
- select the column C400x400
_1648612710.png)
_1648612732.png)
_1648612780.png)
_1648612758.png)
_1648612814.png)
_1648612863.png)
_1648612890.png)
_1648612909.png)
STEP 4:
- The columns are placed image as given below
- go to the set building view limits
- Set the bottom story to base
- Go to the view and set view option and select beam and floor then click apply
- pick the select and then properties
- click on the slab section
- select the slab 150
- after select the slab, go to the assign tab
- select the shell and pick the diaphragms
- pick the d1 and then click ok
- the diaphragms as placed on the building image as given below
- Finally pick the run analysis option on the tool bar
- Then deformed shape buildings are shown below the image
_1648612934.png)
_1648612958.png)
_1648612983.png)
_1648613015.png)
_1648613033.png)
_1648613053.png)
_1648613076.png)
_1648613100.png)
_1648613122.png)
_1648608850.png)
_1648613143.png)
6.) BUILDING F :
STEP 1:
- Go to the file option and go to the save as option
- And saved the name as etab 2 E) but. I can rename it finally building F
- Go to the view and select the set view option
- And unselect the beam and floors then click apply
- Again go to the view and select set building view limits
- And the dialouge as been opened
- select the bottom story 6 to top story story 10
- Select all the columns
- And go the assign select the frame and pick the section properties
- select the column C600X600
_1648613303.png)
_1648613391.png)
_1648613410.png)
_1648613431.png)
_1648613461.png)
_1648613479.png)
_1648613498.png)
_1648613521.png)
- The columns are placed
- Again go to the set building view limits
- Set the bottom story to base
- Go to the view and set view option and select beam and floor then click apply
_1648613543.png)
_1648613566.png)
_1648613584.png)
_1648613601.png)
_1648613618.png)
STEP 2 :
- pick the select and then properties
- click on the slab section
- select the slab 150
- after select the slab, go to the assign tab
- select the shell and pick the diaphragms
- pick the d1 and then click ok
- the diaphragms as placed on the building image as given below
- Finally pick the run analysis option on the tool bar
- Then deformed shape buildings are shown below the image
_1648613646.png)
_1648613669.png)
_1648613695.png)
_1648613712.png)
_1648608850.png)
_1648613737.png)
7.) BUILDING G :
STEP :1
- Go to the file option and go to the save as option
- And saved the name as etab 2 F) but. I can rename it finally building G
- Go to the edit option
- And go to the edit stories and grid system
- Click the modify option
- After go to the add storey and click keep editing story height
- Add and extend the story to 15 total 25 stories
_1648614287.png)
_1648614311.png)
_1648614329.png)
_1648614346.png)
- Go to the sheel load option and set the live load and apply
- Go to the display frame load assigns on the top tool bar
- And give the wall (sdl) load and click ok
- the load as been assigned and the image as given below
- go to the define and select section properties
- pick the frame section
- select the rectangle concrete and make c800x800
_1648614361.png)
_1648614379.png)
_1648614419.png)
_1648614399.png)
- Go to the view and select the set view option
- And unselect the beam and floors then click apply
- Again go to the view and select set building view limits
- And the dialouge as been opened
- select the bottom story 21 to top story story 25
- Select all the columns
- And go the assign select the frame and pick the section properties
- select the column C400x400
_1648614438.png)
_1648614482.png)
_1648614511.png)
_1648614532.png)
_1648614557.png)
- Again go to the view and select set building view limits
- And the dialouge as been opened
- select the bottom story 6 to top story story 10
- Select all the columns
- And go the assign select the frame and pick the section properties
- select the column C600x600
- Already bottom stories column are fixed in c800x800
_1648614577.png)
_1648614602.png)
_1648614619.png)
_1648614636.png)
_1648614655.png)
_1648614673.png)
STEP 2:
- pick the select and then properties
- click on the slab section
- select the slab 150
- after select the slab, go to the assign tab
- select the shell and pick the diaphragms
- pick the d1 and then click ok
- the diaphragms as placed on the building image as given below
- Finally pick the run analysis option on the tool bar
- Then deformed shape buildings are shown below the image
_1648614695.png)
_1648614714.png)
_1648614734.png)
_1648614750.png)
_1648614766.png)
_1648614785.png)
_1648614844.png)
8.) BUILDING H :
STEP :1
- Go to the file option and go to the save as option
- And saved the name as etab 2 G) but. I can rename it finally building H
- Go to the view and select the set view option
- Select all the columns
- And go the assign select the frame and pick the section properties
- select the column C800x800
- Again go to the view and select set building view limits
- And select the beam and floors then click apply
_1648614950.png)
_1648614971.png)
_1648614990.png)
_1648615017.png)
_1648615044.png)
_1648615065.png)
STEP 2:
- pick the select and then properties
- click on the slab section
- select the slab 150
- after select the slab, go to the assign tab
- select the shell and pick the diaphragms
- pick the d1 and then click ok
- the diaphragms as placed on the building image as given below
- Finally pick the run analysis option on the tool bar
- Then deformed shape buildings are shown below the image
_1648615083.png)
_1648615103.png)
_1648615123.png)
_1648615142.png)
_1648608850.png)
_1648615164.png)
9.) BUILDING I :
STEP :1
- Go to the file option and go to the save as option
- And saved the name as etab 2 H) but. I can rename it finally building I
- pick the select and then properties
- click on the slab section
- select the slab 150
- Go to the assign shell load uniform
- give the load pattern name (live)
- load 3.3
_1648615249.png)
_1648615284.png)
_1648615307.png)
_1648615367.png)
_1648615348.png)
STEP 2:
- pick the select and then properties
- click on the slab section
- select the slab 150
- after select the slab, go to the assign tab
- select the shell and pick the diaphragms
- pick the d1 and then click ok
- the diaphragms as placed on the building image as given below
- Finally pick the run analysis option on the tool bar
- Then deformed shape buildings are shown below the image
_1648615392.png)
_1648615416.png)
_1648608850.png)
_1648615435.png)
10.) BUILDING J :
STEP :1
- Go to the file option and go to the save as option
- And saved the name as etab 2 I) but. I can rename it finally building J
- pick the select and then properties
- click on the slab section
- select the slab 150
- Go to the assign shell load uniform
- give the load pattern name (live)
- load 3.6
_1648615518.png)
_1648615539.png)
_1648615556.png)
_1648615574.png)
_1648615596.png)
STEP 2:
- pick the select and then properties
- click on the slab section
- select the slab 150
- after select the slab, go to the assign tab
- select the shell and pick the diaphragms
- pick the d1 and then click ok
- the diaphragms as placed on the building image as given below
- Finally pick the run analysis option on the tool bar
- Then deformed shape buildings are shown below the image
_1648615614.png)
_1648615641.png)
_1648608850.png)
_1648615663.png)
______________________X_____________________________X_______________________________X________________________
RESULTS :
1. BUILDING A :

2. BUILDING B

3. BUILDING C

4. BUILDING D

5. BUILDING E

6. BUILDING F

7. BUILDING G

8. BUILDING H

9. BUILDING I

10. BUILDING J

______________________X_____________________________X_______________________________X______________________
ANSWER 1 :
-
CRITERIA |
MODEL |
ANALYSIS RESULT |
CONCLUTION |
Effect of stiffness on time period |
Building-E
(10 storey with varying colunv size)
|
1.73 s |
The building E and F are same at the Effect of stiffness on time period
The building G and H are some points different in the Effect of stiffness on time period
|
Building-F
(10 storey with varying colunv size)
|
1.73 s |
Effect of stiffness on time period |
Building-G
(25 storey with varying colunv size)
|
4.17 s |
Building-H
(25 storey with varying colunv size)
|
4.41 s |
ANSWER 2 :
-
CRITERIA |
MODEL |
ANALYSIS RESULT |
CONCLUTION |
Effect of stiffness on time period
|
Building-H
(25 storey with 3KN/sq.m imposed load)
|
1.73 s |
The building h and i are same but j can be majorly points different in the Effect of stiffness on time period |
Building-I
(25 storey with 3.3 KN/sq.m imposed load)
|
1.73 s |
Building-J
(25 storey with 3.6 KN/sq.m imposed load)
|
4.17 s |
ANSWER 3 :
-
CRITERIA |
MODEL |
ANALYSIS RESULT |
CONCLUTION |
Effect of building height on time period
|
Building-A
(2 storey)
|
0.5 s |
all the building A,B,F,H are differntly placed in the Effect of building height on time period
|
Building-B
(5 storey )
|
1.03 s |
Building-F
(10 storey )
|
1.73 s |
Building-H
(25 storey )
|
4.41 s |
ANSWER 4 :
-
CRITERIA |
MODEL |
ANALYSIS RESULT |
CONCLUTION |
Effect of column orientation on time period
|
Building-H
(All floors column size 400x400)
|
1.03 s |
The building H,I,J are some major different in the Effect of column orientation on time period |
Building-I
(All floors column size 550x300) oriented in X-direction
|
1.145 s |
Building-J
(All floors column size 300x550) oriented in Y-direction
|
4.12 s |
ANSWER 5 :
BUILDING B :
- Open the building b
- Go to the section properties and open the frame section data
- and select the properties stiffness modifaction factor
- Give the value of moment of inertia 2 axis = 0.1
- At the same give the value of moment of inertia 3 axis = 0.1
- finally click the apply and ok
- go to the run analysis option and then click ok
- Go to the tabels and open the analysis results and open the structural outputs
- then open the model information
- finally open the tabel : model periods and frequency
- finally check the result





_1648608850.png)


-
CRITERIA |
MODEL |
CASE |
ANALYSIS RESULT |
CONCLUTION |
Effect of flexural stiffness of structural elements on mode shapes
|
Building-B
|
Flexural stiffeness of beam close to nil (zero inertia)
|
2.62 s |
In the building B the Flexural stiffeness of beam close to nil (zero inertia) is 2.62 |
Full flexural stiffeness of beam (zero inertia) |
1.03 s |
ANSWER 6 :
BUILDING H :
- Open the building H
- Go to the section properties and open the frame section data
- and select the properties stiffness modifaction factor
- Give the value cross section axial area = 0.1
- finally click the apply and ok
- go to the run analysis option and then click ok
- Go to the tabels and open the analysis results and open the structural outputs
- then open the model information
- finally open the tabel : model periods and frequency
- finally check the result
_1648628627.png)
_1648628707.png)
_1648628731.png)
_1648628751.png)
_1648628776.png)
_1648628800.png)
-
CRITERIA |
MODEL |
CASE |
ANALYSIS RESULT |
CONCLUTION |
Effect of axial stiffness of vertical members on mode shapes
|
Building-H
|
Axial cross section for column is close to nil (Zero axial area)
|
5.99 s |
In the building H Axial cross section for column is close to nil (Zero axial area) is 5.99 |
Full axial section for column (regular) |
4.41 s |
ANSWER 7 :
BUILDING B :
- Open the building B
- Go to the plan view and select the plan base column
- select the assign and go to the joint and restraint
- select the first fixed support option and then click ok
- Go to the tabels and open the analysis results and open the structural outputs
- then open the model information
- finally open the tabel : model periods and frequency
- finally check the result
_1648632838.png)
_1648632864.png)
_1648632880.png)
_1648632909.png)
_1648632937.png)
_1648608850.png)
_1648632956.png)
-
CRITERIA |
MODEL |
CASE |
ANALYSIS RESULT |
CONCLUTION |
Effect of degree of fixity at column base on mode shapes
|
Building-B
|
Column support pinned (regular)
|
1.03 s |
In the building B Effect of degree of fixity at column base on mode shapes are different in Column support pinned (regular)
|
Column support fixed |
0.941 s |