Challenge

Week 5 Challenge

Given Date:-

BASIC DESIGN DATA

C/C of expansion gap (Left Span) 13.3 m
C/C of bearing (Left Span) 12.3 m
Girder overhang beyond bearing (Left Span) 0.35 m
Distance of bearing to expansion gap (Left span) 0.5 m
C/C of expansion gap (Right Span) 13.3 m
C/C of bearing (Right Span) 12.3 m
Girder overhang beyond bearing (Left Span) 0.35 m
Distance of bearing to expansion gap (Right span) 0.5 m
Carriageway width 11 m
Total width 12 m
No of longitudinal girders 4  
C/c spacing of longitudinal girders 3  
Crash Barrier Width (Left side) 0.5 m
Crash Barrier Width (Right side) 0.5 m
CG of crash barrier 0.37 m
Wearing Coat Thickness 0.07 m
Depth of superstructure (Left Span)  1.32 m
Depth of superstructure (Right Span) 1.32 m
CG of superstructure from bottom (Left Span)  0.88 m
CG of superstructure from bottom (Right Span)  0.88 m
Height of crash barrier 0.8 m
Bearing thickness (Max)  0.07 m
Height of pedestal 0.25 m
 Expansion joint 0.04 m

Consider salient level as per pier height

The height of the Pier is 5 M

Salient Levels             
         
Finished Road Level   FRL :-  224.984 m
Bearing Level (Avg)                                   BRL :-  223.327 m
Pier Cap Top Level                                     CTL :-  223.012  
Footing top Level       FTL :-  217.262 m
Footing bottom Level   FBL :-  216.262 m
Lowest Bed Level LBL :-  219.047 m
Maximum Scour Level MSL :-  218.262 m
Highest Flood Level HFL :-  221.974 m
Lowest Water Level                                   LWL :-  219.047 m
Founding Level (Actual)                             FL :-  216.262  
Founding Level (Design)                           FL   216.262  
Water Current Data        
         
Maxim mean velocity   :-  0.98 m/s
Constant "K" for the pier in transverse dia   :-  0.66  
Constant "K" for pier in longitudinal dia.   :-  1.5  
% of Uplift Considered   :-  100%  
         
Material Data          
           
For Pier cap, pier and Footing          
Grade of concrete                                    fck :-            M 35  
Design strength of concrete                      fcd     15.6333333 Mpa
           
Modulus of Elasticity of steel                              Es :-    210000  
Modulus of Elasticity of concrete   Ec :-       
Mean tensile strength of concrete            fctm :-    2.8  
           
Grade of steel fyk :-            Fe 500  
Design strength of steel Fyd     434.782609 Mpa
Density of concrete (RCC & PCC)   Conc_dens :-    2.5 t/m3
Density of weearing course   :-    2.2 t/m3
Coefficient of Thermal Expansion   :-    12000000  
Shrinkage Strain For Concrete   :-    20000  
           
Soil Data          
           
Density of soil   :-    2 t/m3
Submerged Density of soil   :-    1 t/m3
Type of founding strata   :-    Sand  
Type of soil   :-    Medium soil  
HFL CASE          
Net safe bearing capacity at founding level    :-    25 t/m3
Gross Bearing capacity       33  
Net safe SBS seicmic case        31.25  
Gross SBS seicmic case       33.25  
LWL CASE          
Net safe bearing capacity at founding level   :-    25  t/m3
Gross Bearing capacity       32.916  
Net safe SBS seicmic case       31.25  
Gross SBS seicmic case       33.25  
Partial Safety Factors      
       
For Loads      
Ultimate Limit State (For Verification Of Structural Strength)      
Load Basic Comb Seismic
Comb
 
Dead Load 1.35 1.35  
SIDL (except surfacing) 1.35 1.35  
SIDL (surfacing) 1.75 1.75  
Live load and associated
loads (Leading)
1.5 0.2  
Live load and associated
loads (Accompanying)
1.15 0.2  
Water Current 1 1  
Buoyancy 0.15 0.15  
Hydrodynamic Effect - 1  
Wind (Leading) 1.5 -  
Wind (Accompanying) 0.9 -  
Seismic Effect (During
service)
- 1.5  
Seismic Effect (During
construction)
- 0.75  
       
Serviceability Limit State        
Load Rare Comb Quasi-
permanent
Comb
 
Dead Load 1 1  
SIDL (except surfacing) 1 1  
SIDL (surfacing) 1.2 1  
Live load and associated
loads (Leading)
1 -  
Live load and associated
loads (Accompanying)
0.75 0  
Water Current 1 -  
Buoyancy 0.15 0.15  
Thermal Load (Leading) 1.0 -  
Thermal Load
(Accompanying)
0.6 0.5  
Wind (Leading) 1.0 -  
Wind (Accompanying) 0.6 0  
       
For Material      
       
Material Basic Comb Seismic
Comb
 
Concrete 1.5 1.5  
Reinforcing steel 1.15 1.15  
Load Data          
           
Dead Load          
Left Span          
Total weight of superstructure   = 199.00 t  
Right Span          
Total weight of superstructure   = 199.00 t  
           
           
SIDL          
Load Intensity due to wearing course   = 0.22    
Self weight of crash barrier   = 0.00    
           
FPLL          
Maximum intensity of footpath live load   = 500.00 kg/m2  
           
Live Load          
Both Span Loaded          
1 Lane 70R- Wheeled          
Load in Left span   = 41.80 t  
Load in Right span   = 34.80 t  
           
1 Lane Class A          
Load in Left span   = 9.50 t  
Load in Right span   = 25.20 t  
           
One Span Loaded          
1 Lane 70R- Wheeled          
Load in right span   = 61.00 t  
           
1 Lane Class A          
Load in left span   = 0.00 t  
Load in right span   = 28.80 t  
           
%reduction   = 90.00 %  
 Fraction of live load remaining in seismc case    = 1.00    
Factor by which seismic force should be increase for fdn design      1.35    
           
Wind Load Data          
Basic Wind Speed   = 50.00 m/s  
Type of tarrain   = plain terrain  
           
           
  For DL+SIDL For LL      
Gust Factor, G 2.0 2.0      
Drag Coeficient, CD 1.3 1.2      
Lift Coeficient, CL 0.75 -      
Parameter for wind forces on substructure        
For Cap        
Gust Factor, G   = 2.00  
         
t/b   = 4.59  
         
Height/Breadth   = 0.34  
Drag Coefficient, CD   = 1.20  
         
For Shaft        
Gust Factor, G   = 2.00  
Height / Breadth   =

13.04.

 
Drag Cpefficient, CD   = 1.20  

Type of Substructure   = RCC semi circular pier with pier cap
Number of pier shaft   = 1.00      
Transerse eccentricity of substructure with footing/cap   = 0.00 m    
Pedestal        
Length   = 0.80 m
Width   = 0.80 m
Height   = 0.25 m
Nos   = 0.00  
         
Pier Cap        
Rectangular Part        
Length (T-T)   = 10.10 m
Length (L-L)   = 2.20 m
Height   = 0.25 m
         
Trapoizodal Part        
Length (T-T)   = 8.50 m
Length (T-L)   = 0.60 m
Height   = 0.50 m
         
Pier Shaft        
Dimension along traffic   = 0.70 m
Dimension perpendicular to traffic   = 8.50 m
         
Foundation Data        
Type of foundation     Open  
         
Width of footing (L-D)   = 6.5 m
Length of footing (T-D)   = 9.4 m
Thickness of footing at top   = 1 m
Thickness of footing at end   = 0.3  
         
Clear Cover        
Pier Cap   = 50 mm
Pier Shaft   = 50 mm
Footing   = 75 mm
         
Other Data        
Seismic Zone   = III  
Important Factor   = 1.2  
response Reducion Factor for substructure   = 1.5  
Temp Veriation   = 50 o/c

DEAD LOAD CALCULATION FROM SUPERSTRUCTURE

Dead Laod Of Superstructure        
Left Span        
         
Total weight of superstructure (left span), R1   = 199 t
Reaction from left span   = 99.5 t
         
Right Span        
         
Total weight of superstructure (Right span), R1   = 199 t
Reaction from Right span   = 99.5 t
         
Total reaction on pier   = 199 t
Longitudinal movement   = 0 t-m
SIDL (Crash barrier, railing, foothpath) - Excluding wearing course        
         
Left span        
         
Crash  barrier weight   = 26.6 t
Railing weight   = 0 t
Footpath / service weight   = 0 t
         
Right span        
         
Crash  barrier weight   = 26.6 t
Railing weight   = 0 t
Footpath / service weight   = 0 t
         
Total reaction on pier (SIDL excluding w/c)   = 26.6  
SIDL ( Wearing course)        
         
load intensity ue to wearing course   = 0.22 t/m2
         
Left span        
DL of wearing course   = 22.8228  
         
Right span        
DL of wearing course   = 22.8228  
         
Total Reaction on pier (SIDL/ w/c)     22.8228  
Summary of Load from Superstructure            
Bearing Level            
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t-m t-m
DL 199.0 199.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
SIDL (excluding w/c) 26.6 26.6 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
SIDL  w/c) 22.8 22.8 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
             
Pier bottom Level            
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t-m t-m
DL 199.0 199.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
SIDL (excluding w/c) 26.6 26.6 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
SIDL  w/c) 22.8 22.8 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
             
Footing Bottom level            
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t-m t-m
DL 199.0 199.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
SIDL (excluding w/c) 26.6 26.6 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
SIDL  w/c) 22.8 22.8 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0
One Span dislodged condition            
             
Dead Load Of Superstructure            
Vertical load on pier = 99.5 t      
Longitudinal Movement = 49.75 t- m      
Transverse Movement            
             
SIDL (Crash barrier, railing, foothpath) - Excluding wearing course            
Vertical load on pier = 13.3 t      
Longitudinal Movement = 6.65 t- m      
Transverse Movement =          
             
SIDL ( Wearing course)            
Vertical load on pier = 11.4114 t      
Longitudinal Movement = 5.71 t- m      
Transverse Movement =          
             
Bearing Level            
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t-m t-m
DL 99.5 99.5 49.8 0.0 0.0 0.0
SIDL (excluding w/c) 13.3 13.3 6.7 0.0 0.0 0.0
SIDL  w/c) 11.4 11.4 5.7 0.0 0.0 0.0
             
Pier bottom Level            
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t-m t-m
DL 99.5 99.5 49.8 0.0 0.0 0.0
SIDL (excluding w/c) 13.3 13.3 6.7 0.0 0.0 0.0
SIDL  w/c) 11.4 11.4 5.7 0.0 0.0 0.0
             
Footing Bottom level            
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t-m  
DL 99.5 99.5 49.8 0.0 0.0 0.0
SIDL (excluding w/c) 13.3 13.3 6.7 0.0 0.0 0.0
SIDL  w/c) 11.4 11.4 5.7 0.0 0.0 0.0

LIVE LOAD CALCULATION (NORMAL CASE)

Following Live Load cases are consider         
1. 1 lane 70-R Wheeled        
2. 1 lane Class A        
3. 3 lane Class A        
4. 1 Lane 70R- Wheeled + 1 Lane Class A        
         
DL + SIDL reaction from left span   = 148.9228 t
         
DL + SIDL reaction from Right span   = 148.9228 t

Reaction Calculation :- 

1) Class 70 R Wheel vehical 

2) 1 Lane Class A

BOTH SPAN LOADED

1)  1 lane 70 R- Wheeled          
           
Live Load Reaction          
Rb (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 48.35 t  
Rc (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 48.5 t  
           
Vertical force on pier      96.85    
Longitudinal moment     0.075    
           
Total braking force at bearing level       10 t
Total Horizontal force (Longtudinal)   HL = 10 t
Total Horizontal force (Transverse)   HT = 0 t
           
           
           
Transverse Movement (MT)     = 276.0225 t-m
           
2)  1 lane Class A          
           
Live Load Reaction          
Rb (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 31.5 t  
Rc (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 11.9 t  
           
Vertical force on pier      43.4    
Longitudinal moment     9.1875    
           
Total braking force at bearing level       5.5 t
Total Horizontal force (Longtudinal)   HL = 5.5 t
Total Horizontal force (Transverse)   HT = 0 t
           
           
           
Transverse Movement (MT)     = 181.05 t-m
           
3)  3 lane Class A          
           
Live Load Reaction          
Rb (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 106.3 t  
10 % reduction of (3*31.5)          
Rc (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 40.1 t  
10 % reduction (3*11.9)          
           
Vertical force on pier      146.4    
Longitudinal moment     33.5    
           
Total braking force at bearing level       6.9 t
Total Horizontal force (Longtudinal)   HL = 6.9 t
Total Horizontal force (Transverse)   HT = 0 t
           
           
           
Transverse Movement (MT)     = 102.5 t-m
           
4)  1 lane 70R + 1 lane Class A          
           
Live Load Reaction          
Rb (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 94.2 t  
10 % reduction of (52.3+31.5)          
Rc (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 62.3 t  
10 % reduction (43.5+11.9)          
           
Vertical force on pier      156.5    
Longitudinal moment     16    
           
Total braking force at bearing level       11.4 t
Total Horizontal force (Longtudinal)   HL = 11.4 t
Total Horizontal force (Transverse)   HT = 0 t
           
           
           
Transverse Movement (MT)     = 203.2 t-m
           

ONE SPAN LOADED DISLODGE 

1)  1 lane 70 R- Wheeled          
           
Load on lefft span   0      
           
Load on right span   76      
           
Live Load Reaction          
Rb (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 0 t  
Rc (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 76.3 t  
           
Vertical force on pier      76.3    
Longitudinal moment     38.1    
           
Total braking force at bearing level       10 t
Total Horizontal force (Longtudinal)   HL = 10 t
Total Horizontal force (Transverse)   HT = 0 t
           
           
           
Transverse Movement (MT)     = 221.5 t-m
           
2)  1 lane Class A          
           
Load on lefft span   0 t    
           
Load on right span   36 t    
           
Live Load Reaction          
Rb (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 0 t  
Rc (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 0 t  
           
Vertical force on pier      36    
Longitudinal moment     18    
           
Total braking force at bearing level       5.5 t
Total Horizontal force (Longtudinal)   HL = 5.5 t
Total Horizontal force (Transverse)   HT = 0 t
           
           
           
Transverse Movement (MT)     = 151.2 t-m
           
3)  3 lane Class A          
           
Live Load Reaction          
Rb (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 0 t  
Ra (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 0    
Rc (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 121.5 t  
Rc (Include impact factor of 25 %)   = 44.6    
           
Vertical force on pier      121.5    
Longitudinal moment     60.8    
           
Total braking force at bearing level       6.9 t
Total Horizontal force (Longtudinal)   HL = 6.9 t
Total Horizontal force (Transverse)   HT = 0 t
           
           
           
Transverse Movement (MT)     = 85.1 t-m
           
Summary            
Both Span Loaded            
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t-m t-m
1 lane 70R-W 96.8 96.8 0.1 276.2 10.0 0.0
1 lane Class A 43.4 43.4 9.8 182.2 5.5 0.0
3 lane Classs A 146.4 146.4 33.1 102.5 11.4 0.0
1 lane 70R-W + 1 lane Class A 156.5 156.5 16 203.2 11.4 0
One  Span Loaded            
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t-m t-m
1 lane 70R-W 76.3 76.3 38.1 221.5 10.0 0.0
1 lane Class A 36.0 36.0 18.0 151.2 5.5 0.0
3 lane Classs A 121.5 121.5 60.8 85.1 6.9 0.0
1 lane 70R-W + 1 lane Class A 126.3 126.3 63.1 167.3 11.4 0
Final Summary            
Normal Case            
Bering Level            
  Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t-m t-m
LL1 156.5 156.5 48.5 203.2 11.4 0.0
LL2 126.3 126.3 95.4 167.3 11.4 0.0
LL3 95.8 95.8 32.9 278.2 10.0 0.0
             
             
Pier bottom level            
  Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t-m t-m
LL1 156.5 156.5 176.0 203.2 11.4 0.0
LL2 126.3 126.3 223.1 167.3 11.4 0.0
LL3 95.8 95.8 144.9 278.2 10.0 0.0
             
             
Footing bottom level            
  Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t-m t-m
LL1 156.5 156.5 187.3 203.2 11.4 0.0
LL2 126.3 126.3 234.5 167.3 11.4 0.0
LL3 95.8 95.8 154.9 278.2 10.0 0.0

CALCALATION OF FORCES DUE TO WATER CURRENT (HFL CASE)

Max. Mean velocity of current = 0.98
Constant "K" for circular pier in transverse direction = 0.66
Constant "K" for circular pier in longitudinal direction = 1.5
Constant "K" for circular cap = 1.5
HFL = 221.974 m
Pier Bottom Level = 217.262 m
Maximun Scour Level = 218.262 m
Founding Level = 216.262 m
Scour Depth below HFL = 3.712 m
Maximum intensity of pressure = 52KV2  
  = 65.9 kg/m2
  = 0.07 t/m2
Water Current in Transverce Direction      
Force on pier :      
       
Submerged height of pier = 3.712 m
Intensity of pressure at pier bottom level = 0 t/m
Diameter of circular pier = 0.3 m
Force on pier in transverse direction = 0.04 t
acting at RL   220.73 m
Transverse movement due to force on pier at pier bottom = 0.14  T-M
Water Current in 20 degree from Transverse Direction      
Force on pier      
       
Force on pier in transverse direction = 0.04 t
acting at RL = 220.73 m
Transverse moment due to force on pier at pier bottom = 0.065892 t-m
Dia of circular pier  = 0.3 m
Force on pier in longitudinal direction = 0.02 t
acting at RL = 220.73 m
Longitudinal movement due to force on pier at pier bottom = 0.06936 t-m
Summary of force Due to Water Current (At Pier Bottom)        
             
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t t
Water Current (0 degree) 0 0 0 0.14 0 0.2
Water Current (20 degree) 0 0 0.07 0.07 0.02 0.2
             
             
Summary of force Due to Water Current (At Footing Bottom Level)        
             
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t t
Water Current (0 degree) 0 0 0 0.16 0 0.2
Water Current (20 degree) 0 0 0.07 0.14 0.1 0.2

CALCULATION OF LOADS AT PIER BOTTOM LEVEL

Normal Case       
Calculation Of Self Weight      
Pedestal      
Length = 0.8 m
Weidth = 0.8 m
Height = 0.25 m
Nos. = 0  
Total Weight of pedestial = 1.6 t
Pier Cap      
Rectangular part       
Length = 10.1 m
Width = 2.2 m
Height = 0.25 m
Volume = 5.555 m3
Weight = 13.8875 t
Trapezoidal Part      
Length (Top) = 10.1 m
Width (Top) = 2.2 m
Length (Bottom) = 8.5 m
Width (Bottom) = 0.6 m
Height = 0.5 m
Top plan area  = 22.2 m2
Bottom plan area = 5.1 m2
volume = 6.33 m3
weight = 15.8 t
Total weight of pier cap = 29.7 t
Pier shaft      
Area of Cross section of rectangular = 5.95 m2
Height = 5 m
Nos. = 1  
Area of Cross section of semi circular part = 0.192 m2
Height = 10.131 m
Nos. = 2  
       
weight = 79.175 t
LWL Case       
Total Weight of Substructure = 109.275  t
Summary of force at pier bottom Level
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t t
Substructure Weight 109.275 109.275 0 0 0 0
Buoyancy on substructure -58.6 -58.6 0 0 0 0

CALCULATION OF LOADS AT FOOTING BOTTOM LEVEL

Calculation of weight of soil on footimg        
LWL Case        
Bed Level = 219.047 m  
FDN LVL   216.262    
Average Height of footing    0.65    
Volume of concrete   39.715 m3  
Total Volume   171.75    
Volume of earth = 131.855  m3  
         
         
         
Weight of Earth = 263.71  t  
Weight of Footing   99.2875  t  
         
HFL Case with maximum scour        
Volume of earth  =  131.855  m3  
Weight of earth =  131.855  t  
Summary of force at pier bottom Level
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t t
Substructure Weight 109.275 109.275 0 0 0 0
Weight of soil on footing 263.71 263.71 0 0 0 0
Weight of footing 99.3 99.3 0 0 0 0
Buoyancy on substructure -58.6 -58.6 0 0 0 0
Buoyancy on Footing -39.7 -39.7 0 0 0 0

CALCULATION OF WIND FORCES

Basic Wind Speed  = 50 m/s
Type of terrain = Plain terrain  
Type of Superstructure = RCC Girder and Dec  
Type of substructure = RCC semi circular pier with pier Cap  

Calculation wind forces on superstructure.

Left Span 

Length of superstructure in L-L direction (Square) = 13.3 m
Length of superstructure in L-L direction (Square) = 13.3 m
Length of superstructure in L-L direction (Square) = 12 m
Total dept of superstructure (include Cras barrier) = 2.22 m
       
Average height of exposes surface from ground level = 5.065 m
Vz = 42.13 m/s
Pz = 1064.5 N/m2
Wind Forces On DL + SIDL      
Gust factor = 2  
Drag coefficient = 1.3  
Exposed solid area                                             A1                                                 = 29.526 m2
Force in transverse direction                               FT                       = 8.20 t
acting at RL = 224.507 m
Force in longitudinal direction                                FL                              = 2.05 t
acting at RL = 224.507 m
PlanArea                                                               A3 = 159.6 m2
Liftcoefficient                                                         CL = 0.75  
       
Forceinveertical  direction                                      FV = -25.5 t

Right Span

Length of superstructure in L-L direction (Square) = 13.3 m
Length of superstructure in L-L direction (Square) = 13.3 m
Length of superstructure in L-L direction (Square) = 12 m
Total dept of superstructure (include Cras barrier) = 2.22 m
       
Average height of exposes surface from ground level = 9.13 m
       
Vz = 42.12121212 m/s
Pz = 1064.5 N/m2
       
Wind Forces On DL + SIDL      
Gust factor = 2  
Drag coefficient = 1.3  
       
Exposed solid area                                                      A1 = 29.526 m2
Force in transverse direction                                        FT = 8.20 t
                                                              acting at RL = 224.507 m
       
Force in longitudinal direction                                       FL = 2.05 t
                                                              acting at RL = 224.507 m
       
Plan Area                                                              A3 = 159.6 m2
Lift coefficient                                                       CL = 0.75  
       
Force in veertical direction                                                FV = -25.5 t
Total Wind forces at bearing level from superstructure      
             
Both Span present       One Span present    
HL wind  = 2.05   HL wind  = 1.025
HT wind = 8.20   HT wind = 4.1
P wind = -25.5   P wind = -12.75
Forces at Pier shaft bottom level            
Both Span present       Both Span present    
P wind = -25.5   P wind = -12.75
HL wind  = 2   HL wind  = 1
HT wind = 8.20   HT wind = 4.1
ML due to HL = 12.134   ML due to HL = 6.067
ML due to P = 0   ML due to P = 0
MT = 49.7494   MT = 24.8747
Fores at Foundation bottom level            
Both Span present       Both Span present    
P wind = -25.5   P wind = -12.75
HL wind  = 2.05   HL wind  = 1.025
HT wind = 8.20   HT wind = 4.1
ML due to HL = 14.48325   ML due to HL = 7.241625
ML due to P = 0   ML due to P = 0
MT = 57.933   MT = 28.9665

Calculation wind force on substructure.

Average height of exposed surface from the ground level = 3.65 m
Vz = 42.1 m/s
Pz = 1064.5 N/m2
Exposed solid area                                                              A1 = 1.25 m2
Gust factor = 2  
Width of Cap (skew)                                                                      b = 2.25 m
Length of Cap (skew)                                                                     t = 10.1 m
t/b = 4.49  
Height /  Breadth = 0.33  
Drag coefficient = 1.2  
Force in transverse direction                                                    FT = 0.139 t
                                                                                         acting at RL = 222.702 m
Forces at Pier shaft bottom level due to wind forces on pier cap       
HL wind = 0 t
HT wind  = 1 t
ML = 0 t-m
MT = 4.712 t-m
       
       
Forces at Footing bottom level due to wind forces on pier cap       
HL wind = 0 t
HT wind  = 1 t
ML = 0 t-m
MT = 5.712 t-m
Pier Shaft      
Projected area in (Exposed Area)  
       
Average height of exposed surface from the ground level = 4 m
Vz = 50 m/s
Pz = 1064.5 N/m2
Exposed solid area  LWL case                                                         A1 = 2.8 m2
Gust factor = 2  
t/b =    
Height /  Breadth = 5.714285714  
Drag coefficient = 1.2  
Force in transverse direction                                                    FT = 7.153 t
                                                                                         acting at RL = 217.074 m
Forces at Pier shaft bottom level due to wind forces on pier shaft       
HL wind = 0 t
HT wind  = 6.1 t
ML = 0 t-m
MT = 36.9965 t-m
       
       
Forces at Footing bottom level due to wind forces on pier shaft      
HL wind = 0 t
HT wind  = 6.1 t
ML = 0 t-m
MT = 43.0965 t-m
Summary Of forces due to wind on Superstructure + Substructure
           
Both span present    
At pier Bottom Level    
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t t t t
25.5 -25.5 12.134 91.4579 2 15.30
           
At pier Footing Level    
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t t t t
25.5 -25.5 14.48325 106.7415 2 15.30
           
           
One Span Dislodged     
At pier Bottom Level    
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t t t t
12.75 -12.75 6.067 66.5832 1 11.20
           
At pier Footing Level    
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t t t t
12.75 -12.75 7.241625 77.775 1 11.20

LOAD COMBINATION (LIMIT STATE)

Combination Of Base Pressure      
Normal Case                
                   
                   
Both Span present                
LWL (Low Water Level) WITHOUT SCOUR                
Maximum Reaction case (P)                
                   
Load Item  Unfactored Forces      
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT      
t t t-m t-m t t      
DL (superstructure) 199.0 199.0 0 0 0 0      
SIDL (Excluding W/C)  26.6 26.6 0 0 0 0      
SIDL (w/c) 22.8 22.8 0 0 0 0      
LL1 156.5 156.5 187.3 203.2 11.4        
Sustructure Weight  109.275 109.275 0 0 0 0      
Weight of soil on footing  263.71 263.71 0 0 0 0      
Weight of footing 99.3 99.3 0 0 0 0      
Wind Load 25.5 -25.5 12.134 91.4579 2 15.30      
Total for unfactored load 902.7 851.7 199.4 294.7 13.4 15.3      
                   
                   
Maximum Longitudinal Movement case (ML)            
Load Item  Unfactored Forces      
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT      
t t t-m t-m t t      
DL (superstructure) 199.0 199.0 0 0 0 0      
SIDL (Excluding W/C)  26.6 26.6 0 0 0 0      
SIDL (w/c) 22.8 22.8 0 0 0 0      
LL2 126.3 126.3 234.5 167.3 11.4 0.0      
Sustructure Weight  109.275 109.275 0 0 0 0      
Weight of soil on footing  263.71 263.71 0 0 0 0      
Weight of footing 99.3 99.3 0 0 0 0      
Wind Load 25.5 -25.5 12.134 91.4579 2 15.30      
Total for unfactored load 872.5 821.5 246.6 258.8 13.4 15.3      
                   
                   
Maximum Transverse Case            
Load Item  Unfactored Forces      
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT      
t t t-m t-m t t      
DL (superstructure) 199.0 199.0 0 0 0 0      
SIDL (Excluding W/C)  26.6 26.6 0 0 0 0      
SIDL (w/c) 22.8 22.8 0 0 0 0      
LL3 95.8 95.8 154.9 278.2 10.0 0.0      
Sustructure Weight  109.275 109.275 0 0 0 0      
Weight of soil on footing  263.71 263.71 0 0 0 0      
Weight of footing 99.3 99.3 0 0 0 0      
Wind Load 25.5 -25.5 12.134 91.4579 2 15.30      
Total for unfactored load 842.0 791.0 167.0 369.7 12.0 15.3      
                   
                   
One Span Dislodge Condition              
Load Item  Unfactored Forces      
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT      
t t t-m t-m t t      
DL (superstructure) 99.5 99.5 49.8 0 0 0      
SIDL (Excluding W/C)  13.3 13.3 6.7 0 0 0      
SIDL (w/c) 11.4 11.4 5.7 0 0 0      
Sustructure Weight  109.275 109.275 0 0 0 0      
Weight of soil on footing  263.71 263.71 0 0 0 0      
Weight of footing 99.3 99.3 0 0 0 0      
Wind Load 12.75 -12.75 6.067 66.5832 1 11.20      
Total for unfactored load 609.2 583.7 68.3 66.6 1.0 11.2      
                   
                   
SUMMARY OF LOAD CASES FOR NORMAL CASE          
                   
LWL Without Scour              
Both Span Present Condition              
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT      
t t t-m t-m t t      
N1 902.7 851.7 199.4 294.7 13.4 15.3      
N2 872.5 821.5 246.6 258.8 13.4 15.3      
N3 842.0 791.0 167.0 369.7 12.0 15.3      
One Span Dislodged Condition              
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT      
t t t-m t-m t t      
N4 609.2 583.7 68.3 66.6 1.0 11.2      
                   
                   
                   
                   
Area Of foundation A = 61.1 m2 6.5 9.4 6    
Section module in Transverse direction ZT = 95.723333 m3          
Section modulus in Long direction ZL   66.191667 m3          
                   
                   
LWL (Lower Water Level) WITHOUT SCOUR          
Load Item Pmax Pmin ML MT P/A + ML/ZL
+ MT/ZT
P/A + ML/ZL
- MT/ZT
P/A - ML/ZL
+ MT/ZT
P/A - ML/ZL
- MT/ZT
Check
t t t-m t-m
N1 902.69 851.69 199.43 294.66 20.87 14.71 14.84 8.68 OK
N2 872.49 821.49 246.63 258.76 20.71 15.30 13.26 7.85 OK
N3 841.99 790.99 167.03 369.66 20.17 12.44 15.12 7.40 OK
N4 609.2 583.7 68.3 66.6 1.00 11.20 9.64 8.24 OK
Combination Of Base Pressure
Basic Combination        
             
             
Both Span present (LWL, Low Water Level Case)      
Maximum Reaction Case P                    
Load Item  Partial
Safety
Factor
Unfactored Forces Factored Forces
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t t t t t-m t-m t t
DL (superstructure) 1.35 199.0 199.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 268.7 268.7 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
SIDL (Excluding W/C)  1.35 26.6 26.6 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 35.9 35.9 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
SIDL (w/c) 1.75 22.8 22.8 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 39.9 39.9 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
LL1 (Leading) 1.5 156.5 156.5 187.3 203.2 11.4 0 234.8 234.8 281.0 304.8 17.1 0
LL1 (Accompanying) 1.15 156.5 156.5 187.3 203.2 11.4 0 180.0 180.0 215.4 233.7 13.1 0
Thermal Load (Accompanying) 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Sustructure Weight  1.35 109.275 109.275 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 147.5 147.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Weight of soil on footing  1.35 263.71 263.71 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 356.0 356.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Weight of footing 1.35 99.3 99.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 134.1 134.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Wind Load (Leading) 1.5 25.5 -25.5 12.134 91.4579 2 15.30 38.3 -38.3 18.2 137.2 3.0 22.95
Wind Load (Accompanying) 0.9 25.5 -25.5 12.134 91.4579 2 15.30 23.0 -23.0 10.9 82.3 1.8 13.77
Total           LL Leading  1255.0 1178.5 299.2 442.0 20.1 23.0
            LL Accompanying 1185.0 1139.06975 226.3 315.99211 14.9 13.77
Maximum Longitudinal Movement Case (ML)                    
Load Item  Partial
Safety
Factor
Unfactored Forces Factored Forces
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t t t t t-m t-m t t
DL (superstructure) 1.35 199.0 199.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 268.7 268.7 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
SIDL (Excluding W/C)  1.35 26.6 26.6 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 35.9 35.9 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
SIDL (w/c) 1.75 22.8 22.8 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 39.9 39.9 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
LL2 (Leading) 1.5 126.3 126.3 234.5 167.3 11.4 0.0 189.5 189.5 351.8 251.0 17.1 0
LL2 (Accompanying) 1.15 126.3 126.3 234.5 167.3 11.4 0.0 145.2 145.2 269.7 192.4 13.1 0
Thermal Load (Accompanying) 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Sustructure Weight  1.35 109.275 109.275 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 147.5 147.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Weight of soil on footing  1.35 263.71 263.71 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 356.0 356.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Weight of footing 1.35 99.3 99.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 134.1 134.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Wind Load (Leading) 1.5 25.5 -25.5 12.134 91.4579 2 15.30 38.3 -38.3 18.2 137.2 3.0 22.95
Wind Load (Accompanying) 0.9 25.5 -25.5 12.134 91.4579 2 15.30 23.0 -23.0 10.9 82.3 1.8 13.77
Total           LL Leading  1209.7 1133.2 370.0 388.1 20.1 23.0
            LL Accompanying 1150.2 1104.33975 280.6 274.70711 14.9 13.77
Maximum Transverse Movement Case (MT)                    
Load Item  Partial
Safety
Factor
Unfactored Forces Factored Forces
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t t t t t-m t-m t t
DL (superstructure) 1.35 199.0 199.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 268.7 268.7 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
SIDL (Excluding W/C)  1.35 26.6 26.6 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 35.9 35.9 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
SIDL (w/c) 1.75 22.8 22.8 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 39.9 39.9 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
LL3 (Leading) 1.5 95.8 95.8 154.9 278.2 10.0 0.0 143.7 143.7 232.4 417.3 15.0 0
LL3 (Accompanying) 1.15 95.8 95.8 154.9 278.2 10.0 0.0 110.2 110.2 178.1 319.9 11.5 0
Thermal Load (Accompanying) 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Sustructure Weight  1.35 109.275 109.275 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 147.5 147.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Weight of soil on footing  1.35 263.71 263.71 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 356.0 356.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Weight of footing 1.35 99.3 99.3 0.0 0.0 0.0 0 134.1 134.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Wind Load (Leading) 1.5 25.5 -25.5 12.134 91.4579 2 15.30 38.3 -38.3 18.2 137.2 3.0 22.95
Wind Load (Accompanying) 0.9 25.5 -25.5 12.134 91.4579 2 15.30 23.0 -23.0 10.9 82.3 1.8 13.77
Total           LL Leading  1164.0 1087.5 250.6 554.5 18.0 23.0
            LL Accompanying 1115.2 1069.26475 189.1 402.24211 13.3 13.77
One Span Dislodged Condition                    
                           
Maximum Transverse Movement Case (MT)                    
Load Item  Partial
Safety
Factor
Unfactored Forces Factored Forces
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t t t t t-m t-m t t
DL (superstructure) 1.35 99.5 99.5 49.8 0 0 0 134.3 134.3 67.2 0.0 0.0 0
SIDL (Excluding W/C)  1.35 13.3 13.3 6.7 0 0 0 18.0 18.0 9.0 0.0 0.0 0
SIDL (w/c) 1.75 11.4 11.4 5.7 0 0 0 20.0 20.0 10.0 0.0 0.0 0
LL3 (Leading) 1.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
LL3 (Accompanying) 1.15 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Thermal Load (Accompanying) 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Sustructure Weight  1.35 109.275 109.275 0 0 0 0 147.5 147.5 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Weight of soil on footing  1.35 263.71 263.71 0 0 0 0 356.0 356.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Weight of footing 1.35 99.3 99.3 0 0 0 0 134.1 134.1 0.0 0.0 0.0 0
Wind Load (Leading) 1.5 12.75 -12.75 6.067 66.5832 1 11.20 19.1 -19.1 9.1 99.9 1.5 16.8
Wind Load (Accompanying) 0.9 12.75 -12.75 12.5 126.1 1 11.20 11.5 -11.5 11.3 113.5 0.9 10.08
Total           LL Leading  828.9 790.7 95.4 99.9 1.5 16.8
            LL Accompanying 821.3 798.33975 97.5 113.49 0.9 10.08
SUMMARY OF LOAD CASES FOR BASIC COMNINATION (LWL CASE)    
                 
Both Span present condition (LWL Case)        
                 
Load Case No. Live Load
Case
LL
Leading / Accomp
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT
t t t-m t-m t t
(C-1)1 LL 1 Case LL Leading 1255.0 1178.5 299.2 442.0 20.1 23.0
(C-1)2 LL Accompanying 1185.0 1139.1 226.3 316.0 14.9 13.8
(C-1)3 LL 2 Case LL Leading 1209.7 1133.2 370.0 388.1 20.1 23.0
(C-1)4 LL Accompanying 1150.2 1104.3 280.6 274.7 14.9 13.8
(C-1)5 LL 3 Case LL Leading 1164.0 1087.5 250.6 554.5 18.0 23.0
(C-1)6 LL Accompanying 1115.2 1069.3 189.1 402.2 13.3 13.8
                 
                 
One Span Dislodge condition (LWL Case)        
Load Case No. LL
Leading / Accomp
Pmax Pmin ML MT HL HT  
t t t-m t-m t t  
(C - 1) 19 LL Leading 828.9 790.7 95.4 99.9 1.5 16.8  
(C - 1) 20 LL Accompanying 821.3 798.3 97.5 113.5 0.9 10.1  
Area Of foundation A = 61.1 m2
Section module in Transverse direction ZT = 95.723333 m3
Section modulus in Long direction ZL   66.191667 m3
      61.1  
      95.73  
C            Combination for Design of Foundation   66.2  
C            Basic Combination   
Both Span present condition (LWL Case)                    
Load Case No. Force / Movement For Pmax For Pmin
Pmax Pmin ML MT  σmax  σ1  σmin  σ2  σmax  σ1  σmin  σ2
t t t-m t-m t/m2 t/m2 t/m2 t/m2 t/m2 t/m2 t/m2 t/m2
(C-1)1 1255.04 1178.54 299.15 441.99 29.68 20.44 11.40 20.64 28.43 19.19 10.15 19.39
(C-1)2 1184.97 1139.07 226.32 315.99 26.11 19.51 12.67 19.28 20.38 10.83 3.42 12.97
(C-1)3 1209.74 1133.24 369.95 388.14 29.44 21.33 10.16 18.27 27.34 14.63 6.90 19.61
(C-1)4 1150.24 1104.34 280.60 274.71 25.93 20.19 9.95 17.46 25.18 19.44 10.97 16.71
(C-1)5 1163.99 1087.49 250.55 554.49 28.63 17.04 9.47 21.06 27.38 15.79 8.22 19.81
(C-1)6 1115.16 1069.26 189.06 402.24 25.31 16.91 11.19 19.60 24.56 16.15 10.44 18.85
One Span Dislodged condition (LWL Case)                    
Load Case No. Force / Movement For Pmax For Pmin
Pmax Pmin ML MT  σmax  σ1  σmin  σ2  σmax  σ1  σmin  σ2
t t t-m t-m t/m2 t/m2 t/m2 t/m2 t/m2 t/m2 t/m2 t/m2
(C - 1) 19 828.94 790.69 95.35 99.87 16.05 13.96 11.08 13.17 15.42 13.34 10.46 12.54
(C - 1) 20 821.29 798.34 97.50 113.49 11.89 8.46 5.27 8.70 11.65 8.22 5.03 8.46
Critical Cases For Design      
         
ULS ( Combination 1)  Gross Pressure (t/m2)
   σmax  σ1  σmin  σ2
  29.68 20.44 11.40 20.64
ULTIMATE LIMIT STATE        
               
Grade of Concrete fck = 35 N/mm2
               
        fcd = 15.63333  
               
Grade of steel fy = 500 N/mm2
        fyd = 434.7826 N/mm2
               
               
Minimum strain in steel reinforcement = 0.002071  
        Es = 210000  

DESIGN OF FOOTING SLAB (TRANSVERSE DIRECTION ) - ULS

Length   = 8.5
Height of soil at footing edge   = 1
Critical Cases For Design            
                 
Gross Pressure (t/m2)   Net Pressure (t/m2)
 σmax  σ1  σmin  σ2   P1 P2 P3 P4
29.68 20.44 11.40 20.64   22.48 13.25 4.21 13.44
Design Parameter    
fck = 35 Mpa
fcd = 15.6 Mpa
fyk = 500 Mpa
fyd = 434.8 Mpa
Rlim = 5.8 Mpa
Clear Cover = 75 mm

  Volume       
                   
  A1   = 116.76 t/m      
                   
  A2   = 113.8723 t/m      
                   
  Volume   = 51.89058 t      
                   
  Lever arm   = 0.224061 m      
                   
  Design Movement (Mu) = 11.62667 t-m      
                   
  Overall depth at face = 1 m      
                   
  Section shape at critical section is shown in figure
  The section is converted into equivalent rectangle for chencking movemnt capicity
                   
  Equivalent width of rectangulare section, b = 1.425 m  
                   
  drequired  = 118.6059 mm  
                   
  dprovide = 925 mm  
                   
  R = 0.095    
                   
  Ast, requied  = 288.8354 mm2  
                   
  Ast, limiting = 23663.09 mm2 OK
                   
  Ast, required = 202.6915 mm2 mm2
                   
  Minimum As, requried per meter width  = 1456 mm2/m  
                   
Governing Ast, required per meter in central bandwidth = 1456 mm2/m  
                   
                   
Provision of reinforcement in remaining width        
Bar Dia   16 mm   0      
Spacing c/c   125 mm   125      
                   
  Ast = 1608.5 mm2/m OK
                   
  Percentage of steel provide  = 0.173892 %  
                   
  Maximum Ast per m width                                   Ast,max = 23125 mm2/m  
DESIGN OF FOOTING (LONGITUDINAL DIRECTION) - ULS
                       
                       
Length   = 0.7        
Height of soil at footing edge   = 1        
                       
                       
                       
Critical Cases For Design                  
                       
Gross Pressure (t/m2)   Net Pressure (t/m2)      
 σmax  σ1  σmin  σ2   P1 P2 P3 P4      
29.68 20.44 11.40 20.64   22.48 13.25 4.21 13.44      
                       
                       
Design Parameter                
fck = 35 Mpa            
fcd = 15.6 Mpa            
fyk = 500 Mpa            
fyd = 434.8 Mpa            
Rlim = 5.8 Mpa            
Clear Cover = 75 mm            

  Volume         
                     
  A1   = 167.93 t/m        
                     
  A2   = 130.039 t/m        
                     
  Volume   = 430.8837 t        
                     
  Lever arm   = 1.388373 m        
                     
  Design Movement (Mu) = 598.2271 t-m        
                     
  Overall depth at face = 1 m        
                     
  Section shape at critical section is shown in figure  
  The section is converted into equivalent rectangle for chencking movemnt capicity  
                     
  Equivalent width of rectangulare section, b = 8.6125 m    
                     
  drequired  = 346.0624078 mm    
                     
  dprovide = 925 mm    
                     
  R = 0.812      
                     
  Ast, requied  = 1745.680909 mm2    
                     
  Ast, limiting = 143016.3873 mm2 OK  
                     
  Ast, required = 202.6915424 mm2 mm2  
                     
  Minimum As, requried per meter width  = 1456 mm2/m    
                     
Governing Ast, required per meter in central bandwidth = 1456 mm2/m    
                     
                     
Provision of reinforcement in remaining width          
Bar Dia   25 mm   25        
Spacing c/c   100 mm   100        
                     
  Ast = 1608.5 mm2/m OK  
                     
  Percentage of steel provide  = 0.173891892 %    
                     
  Maximum Ast per m width                                   Ast,max = 23125 mm2/m    

      Volume             
                   
      A1     = 168.85 t/m  
                   
      A2     = 130.04 t/m  
                   
      Volume     = 294.32 t  
                   
  Design shear force  = 294.32 t  
  Design shear force per meter  = 31.31 t  
                   
  Overall depth of section at critical section        
                   
                   
  Section shape at critical section is shown in figure
  The section is converted into equivalent rectangle for chencking movemnt capicity
                   
  Equivalent width of rectanguar section, b = 9.47625 m  
                   
  Tensile Reinforcement  Ast = 9817.5 mm2/m  
  Width of beam bw = 1000 mm  
  Effective depth d = 701.7 mm  
                   
          Ac = 701700 mm2  
                   
          Ned = 0    
                   
          k = 1.45    
                   
          Vmin = 0.24    
                   
          σcp = 3.12    
                   
          Pl = 0.013991022    
                   
                   
  Top reinforcement         
  Minimum percentage of steel = 0.146 %  
  Area of reinforcement at top = 673.4 mm2/m  
  Provide 12mm dia @150 mm c/c in both direction        
  Area of reinforcement at top = 753.98 mm2/m Ok

2) what is difference between free and fix pier and how it impacts the foundation size.

Also add the calculation of loading in both the cases.

Ans :-

Base on the type of forces bridge pier as classified in free anf fixed piers  

Fixed pier 

The pier supporting a fixing bearing are called fixed piers support. Fixed bearing and subjected both to transverse and longitudinal forces.

Free Pier

The pier supporting a free bearing free pier are called as free pier support. Free piers support free bearings and transfer only axial forces from the bearing to the foundations.

  • For multispan bridges, the number of fixed and free piers depend on the the length of bridge, size of pier and magnitude of long & trans forces superstructure can be subjected to. For regular multispan continuous bridges under 200-300m one fixed pier is provided.
  • Horizontal force is not consider in free bearing support and all forces is consider in fixed pier hence the size of footing is more in fixed bearing support as compair to free bearing.
Your portfolio, next

Ship work like this
in your own course.

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.