← Previous lessonFree lesson 2 of 3 · lesson 2 of 42Next lesson →

Unlock all 42 lessons of Automotive BIW Design and Development Part 2 using NXCADFull course ₹40,000 · paid

Price & syllabus
Free lesson · 20 min · no payment

Rear Door Case Study: Aluminium Cast vs Steel Deep Drawn

A free lesson from Skill-Lync's Automotive BIW Design and Development Part 2 using NXCAD course, on Grow by Skill-Lync · Last updated 16 Nov 2026 · Session: “Week 1 Backdoor Session 2”

What will you learn in this free Automotive BIW Design and Development Part 2 using NXCAD lesson?

The instructor compares a rear door inner panel made as an aluminium casting with a steel deep drawn version, covering lost luggage space, rear visibility and weight. The lesson also covers the CAE load cases with 9 mm torsion and 1.5 mm bending targets, gas stay types and assembly sequence.

  • How material change shifts cross sections and visibility
  • Weight difference between cast aluminium and steel panels
  • Torsion, bending, abuse, dent and endurance load cases
  • Gas stay types by hinge and mounting position

What comes after lesson 2?

The next free lesson is lesson 3, “Planning the Rear Door Model and Building Its Flange in NXCAD” (25 min). Later in Skill-Lync's Automotive BIW Design and Development Part 2 using NXCAD course (paid): lesson 4, Week 2 Backdoor Session 1; lesson 5, Week 2 Backdoor Session 2; lesson 6, Week 2 Backdoor Session 3. The full course has 42 lessons (23 h 41 min of video); see the course overview or its price and syllabus.

Lesson transcript

Machine transcript of the lesson audio (lightly cleaned). Technical terms may contain errors; the video is the reference.

Now that we've understood the basics and the basic considerations while designing a rear door, let us now get into this case study. So what are we going to learn? So we're going to convert a backdoor inner panel from an aluminium cast part to a steel deep drawn part. And we're going to see why and we're going to see what are the advantages and disadvantages of doing that. Now, what are the considerations and what is the main intention of doing this? As you can see, the intention that what we have to understand is we are going to look at the various losses in the luggage area, the loss in the rear view visibility and also the weight change from converting a part from aluminium to steel.

So what are the basic considerations? What are we going to keep and what are we going to change? So here it is mentioned that the parting is going to be maintained the same because it is with respect to the styling. Now, the thickness is going to be changed to 0.75 mm because the material is being changed from aluminium to steel. The gap and fluxes are going to be maintained the same. Also, the large mounting surface is going to be changed in the X direction. It is going to be reduced to 6 mm and the Z direction is going to increase by 3 mm.

And the inner thickness is going to be 0.75 mm. So that was mentioned earlier. Yes. And the critical mounting areas like the handle mounting and the gas team mounting are going to be the same. So considering all these in mind, now let us see what are the major changes and how they affect the design when we convert a part or component, say the rear door assembly from aluminium to steel. Yes, as we already mentioned, there are a lot of sections, right? We took eight sections in the previous video.

So we look at those sections and we'll compare aluminium and steel concepts. So here you can see that green color is always aluminium and blue is always going to be steel. Here at this latch and striker position cross section, what is the change that we see? It is moving by 6.8 mm inside when we convert from aluminium to steel. So this is in this cross section. This is the change that has taken place in this cross section. Next, we'll move to the locks in luggage area.

So here you have various cross sections, B, A, B and C. So here you have C, A and B. So A is the lower, B is the upper and C is the cross section that we take above the rear lamp. So what is the result that we see? We see a loss of 4.5 mm in the X direction and 5.1 in the Z direction. That is the blue color, that is the steel part is being offset by a particular value. And is this value considerable? We'll see very soon.

Yeah. And in this section C, there is no loss. Now this is the gas threat minimum distance. That is a cross section taken at the reinforcement where which is provided for the gas day. As you can see, the green is the aluminium cast part and the blue is the steel drawn part. So here it says that it is approximately is the same and the minimum clearance that has to be there for the aluminium part, aluminium cast part that is 4 mm can be neglected while we consider for the steel section.

Next, we'll move on to the loss in the rear view. So here we have again we have three sections. You can see them here A, B, C and D. That's four sections. So the A is the first low most corner and B is the upper corner and C is section that is above the gas day reinforcement. Yes. As you can see, results are loss of 12.2 mm. Why do we have such a huge value here? So here if you see, there is a loss of 12.2 mm.

This is nothing but the place that is here. So here this flange comes into contact with the windshield. Also, if it is a steel part, we're going to have, you know, an excess of 12 mm that is 15 mm for spot welding. So here you can see a loss of 11 mm when we consider normal spot weld flange. So we can actually reduce this loss by, you know, 7 mm and you can reduce it to 4 mm when we use laser bracing. Because as we already mentioned in the previous video, spot welding requires a minimum of 15 mm flange and laser bracing requires just 7 mm.

Now, here there is a loss of 14.2 mm in section AA. The same happens here. But here we don't have the windshield. Just the steel drawn part and the aluminum cast part are shown here for your difference. Next, so here in the section DD, that is the section taken at the wiper motor embossed region and the reinforcement region. There is no loss and we converted from an aluminum cast part to steel drawn part. Now, please don't get me wrong. I will go back to the slide.

So when I said we are going to convert it from aluminum cast part to steel deep drawn part, that doesn't necessarily mean that aluminum cannot be deep drawn. So whenever we have an aluminum, you know, entire assembly of aluminum, that is the rear door assembly of aluminum. That means that the inner panel is going to be made of aluminum and it is going to be cast. Let's say the outer panel. The outer panel can be aluminum, but it can be deep drawn. Because the outer panel is relatively simple when compared to the inner panel.

The inner panel has a lot of intricate and complex curves and embosses. So that's why we use casting for that. So now let's get to the basic difference between casting and deep drawn since we've talked more about casting and deep drawn parts. Now, can aluminum be easily cast? Yes, it can be easily cast. So why are we casting aluminum? So when we cast aluminum, local thickness at a particular region can be vary. What does this mean? This means that we can reduce the number of parts that we use.

In the case of steel that we saw earlier, the number of parts is going to be a lot more. That is the reinforcements. There are a lot of reinforcements. There are a lot of embosses for the reinforcements to accommodate. So when I convert that to aluminum, I can just have one single piece. I can neglect all the reinforcements. And instead of the reinforcements, there can be just one part wherein the thickness is compensating for the absence of the reinforcements. So this is what I've been meaning to tell you.

So when we have just one panel of this particular shape, okay, so this is going to be aluminum. And this is going to be steel. So when this is going to be my cross section of my flange, which we saw earlier, in case of steel, we need an extra reinforcement. Right? And also an emboss here. So this reinforcement is going to be 2 mm approximately. But in this case, when it is aluminum, this aluminum, this thickness alone can be increased. Okay, I'm just exaggerating the value here.

So instead of this reinforcement, that is an additional part, I can just increase the thickness of aluminum. And I can make it 2 or 3 or 4 mm based on whatever is necessary. In spite of this aluminum having varying local thicknesses at varying various parts and various positions, let's say we have an aluminum sheet metal component that is, you know, throughout it is like 4 mm thickness. And we have a steel that is just 0.75 mm, 0.75 or 0.7 mm thick. So what does this mean?

The aluminum sheet metal part will be much less heavier when compared to the steel in spite of having this 4 mm thickness. So this literally gets to my main point, that is, aluminum has a highest strength to weight ratio. And also aluminum is much, because the weight of aluminum is much lesser when compared to steel. And the weight of aluminum is higher for its extra weight that we give it. Let's go in depth to understand the weight difference between a rear door in aluminum and steel.

We'll see the weight difference between the two materials. So here, as you can see, the commodity and the weight are being mentioned for aluminum cast and steel concept. Steel is going to be deep drawn here. So, in case of aluminum, the inner panel back to just one single component instead of these many components here, it is just 5.65 kgs. If we look at this, the inner panel without all the additional reinforcements and small, small parts, it is going to be 4.8. When I consider all of these together, we see a major difference of 4.65 kgs.

That is approximately 5 kgs. 5 kgs is not a really small deal. It is a very big deal when it comes to cost, when it comes to manufacturing. So, when I say cost, it includes the raw material cost, the entire cost of machining, the cost of procuring it, the cost of storing it, and also the entire weight of the vehicle. So, when it comes to premium cars, what companies right now are focusing on is moving to advanced materials like aluminum because it has a highest strength to weight ratio.

And then they are moving on to magnesium alloys and then to reinforced carbon fiber. So, these are all advanced materials and this is our analysis of how we convert apart from aluminum to steel or steel to aluminum and vice versa. So, we have seen the advantages and disadvantages of each material and also the weight difference. Now, there are various tests that are going to be carried out on the rear dow that we design. And only after it passes through all the CAE tests will it be a design success.

So, what are the various tests that are going to be performed? They are the basic torsion and bending test. Let us first look at the target that we have to achieve. So, during torsion, the maximum bending displacement, it should not be more than 9 mm. It is not mentioned here. It should not be more than 9 mm. And in bending, it should not be more than 1.5 mm. So, what happens if the results, that is the displacement results are more than 9 mm or 1.5 mm, they get rejected and the design has to be changed.

Now, let us take a closer look at both the testing. This is an actual rear door. This is being mounted on a jig fixture. So, first test setup is going to be for the backdoor torsion test. Here we have the displacement values. Back to this. Here we have the rear door. This is the Lachen striker hole that we saw in our design that is being reciprocated here. These are the actual hinges of the door and they are being mounted. The door is going to be pivoted about this hinge only. Now, as you can see for torsion, since it is a torsion test, now as you can see, the forces are in the opposite direction as shown here. And then the displacement at various points are noted down. And if this displacement increases, that is, if it goes beyond 9mm, then it is a failure case. When a particular design satisfies all these points and it is less than 9mm, will the design be a successful design? Then we have the test setup for the back door bending criteria. It is a bending. So this is how the jig fixture looks. In case of bending, the forces are going to be in the same direction. That is the downward direction in this case. We also have the storage ball. It is going to be mounted over this ball. And the force is being introduced by a hook.

That is the bending is being simulated by using a hook here. So what was our target criteria? That the displacement values at each point should be less than 1.5mm. When it increases, when it goes beyond 1.5, then it is failure case. So now let us take a look, an in-depth look at the various general analysis that are being carried out on a rear door. So we have the bend test and also the torsion test as shown here. In the bend test, the forces are going to be in the same direction and the torsion test, they're going to be in the opposite direction.

And these are the fixtures, the points where the rear door is going to be fixed. So here we have an abuse case. So what exactly is an abuse case? You know, since this being a rear door, some people may lean onto it, some may misuse it, some may slam the door. So for this purpose, the rear door is going to be fixed at one end and the force is going to be applied at the other end in the opposite direction. This will be repeated vice versa. That is the force will be here and the fixture will be here.

Also, we have the dent test. This is to analyze the durability of the outer panel at a particular place. So as you can see, there is a probe here. This is going to exert a force at a local area and once the force is exerted, the displacement is going to be seen. There should be no displacement and the outer panel should actually come back to its original position. So if this happens, then it passes the test as it is a failure model. You also have the assembly load case. So what exactly is the assembly load case?

When assembling the rear door, there can be a lot of forces that are going to be exerted on it. What happens if the load is too much? So this is going to be analyzed. Next, we have the endurance test. So what exactly is the endurance? The difference between a race and an endurance is endurance is something that happens over a long period of time. A part or a component that is being designed has to withstand a lot of forces for a longer period of time. So this is going to be simulated here. So let us compare the hood and the rear door. The likeliness of the hood being opened is like once or twice a month. Only when there is a problem with the engine or when the radiator water is going to be replaced or refilled, the hood is going to be opened.

But in case of a rear door, let's say a common commuter who commutes every day is going to use his boot space. He's going to have his suitcases in there. So he'll open and close the door every single day. There is a possibility of that happening. So in that case, the radar should not malfunction or it should not deteriorate from its original quality of the design intended purpose. So for this exact purpose, this test is going to be done on the rear door. This actually shows how the forces are being resolved in various directions in all the cases, you know, the bend test, the torsion and the abuse cases in the close and the open case.

Now, in all the four things, are you able to see the common place where there is too much of force? What do I mean by too much of force? The red spots. That is the latching striker reinforcement and the emboss region. So in this region, as we already mentioned in the previous video, this is going to be attacked and this is going to be the major place where all the forces are going to be exerted. So what exactly is our intention? It is to resolve the forces and spread them towards the end or towards the other flanges over here and outside the body of the rear door.

So this will be our design intention and this will be given as a feedback from the CA team to the designer to either make changes to the embosses or to make embosses accordingly. Next, we'll be looking at the various types of gas tape based on their positions and also how they work. Now, let us get to the gas tape part. You know what a gas tape is. It is used to keep the either the hood or the rear door in its open position. That is, it is going to, you know, a force in the opposing direction such that the entire weight of the hood is being supported and stays in its open position.

Now, let's look at the various types of gas tape. We've already looked at the design of gas tape, the design aspects of gas tape in the hood. We also mentioned and I'll reiterate that a gas tape is something that is being manufactured by other manufacturers and major players and even minor players in the, you know, passenger vehicle segment. Don't design new gas days for every single model that they release. They just make use of gases that is globally available in the market because that will cost them much less.

Now, getting back to the types of gas days. So we have spindle case one and spindle case two. So here, this is the actual gas tape and this, let's say this an electronic state. It's not gas. So here it is gas tape because we are using pneumatic and here we use electrical power here. So one is being mounted to the body side and the other we see as we see it is mounted on the roof. So based on that we have classified it as two major groups. So here S one and two for every S one and two, we have ultimately four. So that makes eight, right?

So let's say for spindle case one, we have two types that is the hinge mounting outer and the hinge mounting inner. So what does this mean? If you take certain cars like one example that I know, the Mardy Omni has its hinges on the outer side that is on top of the roof. And most of the cars like 99% of them have hinges on the inner side because nowadays it has become an aesthetic element. So it is being hidden under the roof or under the, you know, bird in cases of sedan class. So we have two types, a hinge mounting outer and the hinge mounting inner.

Now for these two types, we have the gas tape body mounting and the gas tape back door mounting. So for each of these types, there are two types that is the gas day is either being mounted on the body side or on the back door itself. So this is for spindle case one and for spindle case two, we have the same again. So that makes eight. Now let us look at the various analysis carried out on the eight types based on the gas day mounting. So when we actually slam the rear door or close it, this is how the forces are going to be transmitted throughout. So in every case, as you can see, it follows the V or the Y direction.

So this gives us an ultimate reason as to why we use the V or the Y emboss. And also, as you can see, the forces are being transmitted towards the gas day and the emboss reinforcements. So the bigger the reinforcements, the better the strength there. That is what we will infer from these images. Now, moving on to the assembly sequence here, we'll show you, you would have guessed it by now. The basic simple assembly sequence is that first the inner panel is mounted. Then we'll have all the reinforcements integrated into them one by one. We'll have these components, the hinges, latin striker mounted, and then we'll move on to the outer upper and the outer lower.

The outer upper and the outer lower will be braced together and they will be hemmed around the inner panel. That is first they will be hemmed and then they will be braced together. Yes. Next, let us look at the assembly sequence for aluminium. So for aluminium parts, as you can see, it is just one complete inner panel and no reinforcements. So just the inner panel and the outer panel. The outer panel may be or may be not be separated into pieces. That is the outer rubber and the outer lower.

So here, the various parts of the rear door assembly for the Audi A6 and the Audi Q5 are being shown here. As you can see, they are 2008 with the same material as aluminium. They were advanced even at 2008. We're still in 2020 and we'll see a lot of cars with steel. Yes. So they used aluminium and their rear door weight was around 10.9. That is approximately 11 kgs. And in 2011, that is just three years of benchmarking, they could achieve around 9 kgs. That is a reduction of 2 kgs in all. That is a very big achievement in terms of BIW design.

So that's it for this video guys. In this video, we looked at the various important cross sections, the cross sections that we talked about for the ceiling flange. We saw the various embosses in the NSCAD module and we also saw the various reinforcements, their functionality and their purposes. We also looked at the joining methods such as hemming and brazing. And then in the PPT, we saw how a design is going to be transitioned from aluminium to steel, the advantages and disadvantages of having aluminium or steel.

And then we saw the various CAE load test cases and their results and how the design is going to be tested for success or failure based on those values. And then finally, we saw the gas day, their types based on the hinge position. And also we saw a small example for benchmarking and the entire assembly sequence of a rear door. Thank you guys. We'll meet you in the next one.

Want the rest of Automotive BIW Design and Development Part 2 using NXCAD?

Get the full course syllabus and fees.

The full course is paid (₹40,000). We'll send the syllabus and call you back within one working day.

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Full course · paid

Unlock the full Automotive BIW Design and Development Part 2 using NXCAD course

The remaining 39 lessons, mentor-reviewed projects and a certificate come with the paid course (₹40,000). Leave your details: we'll send the syllabus and fees and call you back.

Get the syllabus and fees

A counsellor calls you back within one working day.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Grow by Skill-Lync · free lesson

Start watching

Free, no payment. Leave your details once and every free lesson on Grow plays straight away. A Skill-Lync counsellor may call you about the full Automotive BIW Design and Development Part 2 using NXCAD course.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Talk to a career counsellor

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.