Lesson finished
Up next: Load Path from Slab to Soil and Behaviour of Slabs and Beams
Unlock all 68 lessons of Structural Analysis and Design of Composite Structures using ETABSFull course ₹40,000 · paid
Cost of Going Tall and the Loads Acting on Buildings
A free lesson from Skill-Lync's Structural Analysis and Design of Composite Structures using ETABS course, on Grow by Skill-Lync · Last updated 16 Nov 2026 · Session: “Cost Implications and Load Types in Structural Design”
What will you learn in this free Structural Analysis and Design of Composite Structures using ETABS lesson?
The instructor shows how unit cost rises faster than height once wind and earthquake loads are included, then separates dead, live and environmental loads. The lesson contrasts wind as a direct pressure on the facade with seismic force induced by mass, and ends with internal axial and bending forces and pin, fixed and roller supports.
- Why cost rises steeply with number of storeys
- Dead, live and environmental load categories
- Wind as direct force, seismic as inertial force
- Pin, fixed and roller support restraints
What comes after lesson 2?
The next free lesson is lesson 3, “Load Path from Slab to Soil and Behaviour of Slabs and Beams” (22 min). Later in Skill-Lync's Structural Analysis and Design of Composite Structures using ETABS course (paid): lesson 4, Column and Shear Wall Functions in Structural Design; lesson 5, Structural Systems in Composite Tall Structures; lesson 6, Braced Frame Behavior. The full course has 68 lessons (29 h 11 min of video); see the course overview or its price and syllabus.
Lesson transcript
Machine transcript of the lesson audio (lightly cleaned). Technical terms may contain errors; the video is the reference.
Now, if you speak about the cost implications, just to give you an idea that we all say that tall buildings are the way which we should be constructing. But we all should understand that as we go tall, the cost is not linear increase. That's quite a quadratic increase in the way the cost incurs onto the client basically. So, just to give that idea to you, this is unit cost index and number of stories on the x-axis. So, as you move from 10 story to 50 story and from 50 to 100, you can see the baseline over there, the solid line that shows the ideal structure insulated from wind and earthquake.
So, if our structure is only governed by gravity, it would have increase in the cost from 1 to 1.01, 0 to somewhere 2 or 3 percent. When we move from 10 story to 50 story and from 50 to 100, it can go from 1 to 1.2 or 1.3. So, only 30 percent rise can be expected. But the usual scenario is, there is no structure which is insulated from wind and earthquake. And as we go tall, wind definitely governs the design. And if our structure is within the high seismic region, seismic also tend to govern some of the other elements.
So, the premium which needs to be paid for resisting those loads is significantly higher. You can see the dotted line. And just to give you an idea, like for a 10 story building, the unit cost is just 1. But for the 50 story building, if you want to design it for the gravity plus lateral system, the unit cost is close to 2. So, that's a 100 percent increase in the cost index. So, the cost will be double. And if we shift from 50 to 100, then 2 costs increase to 4.5.
So, again, a double close to more than double. So, 150 percent increase in the rate from 50 to 100. And that's just because as we go tall, we have to resist the wind loads and the earthquake loads, which are of huge magnitude. And thereby the cost. So, it's not always easier to construct tall buildings. But with the respect of land as a scarce element, we definitely don't have any other option rather than to go as a tall. But here we can clearly see that to estimate the behavior of a building and to estimate in the right way, the behavior of building in response to wind and earthquake should be very studied in very detail.
Because they are the ones which are governing the cost and the sizes basically. So, we should be very careful in the design of wind and earthquake. And gravity also is governing. But to the certain extent, rather wind and earthquake definitely go on the design. So, with this background in the picture, now we will consider more on the loads on structure. So, what are the different loads which you get on the structure? So, if you think of the first is its own weight, self weight of the structure.
Now, there can be dead loads on over and above that. So, one is the self weight of the structural elements from beams to slabs to columns, footings. So, everything is a self weight of it due to the force of gravity. So, building has to resist its own force, own weight firstly. Also, there are some permanent forces. Permanent by mean is they are relatively constant for the life of the structure. So, those are also considered as a dead load. So, just to give you an idea, the floor finishes, which is the tiling and the finishing for the walls and all are included under the self weight.
Because you won't be changing the finishes every one or two years or 10 years or 15 years. So, they will definitely be permanent, relatively permanent. And that's why those also forms as a part of dead load. So, whichever loads on the structure you can think of, which would be relatively constant throughout the portion of the life would be considered as a dead load. And the next one is a live load. Now, those wherein there is a fair bit of variability. And those are all mobile like person working on the floor of a structure.
So, a person is a live mobile force. He would be there today, he may not be there tomorrow. So, he is a variable load, right? So, weight of all the people on the structure comes under the live load part of it. There are also temporary fixtures. If you see, we have some furniture which are temporary in a bit. Storage items are temporary in a bit. So, all those wherein which are not permanent are considered as a live load. And because their variability is different than that of dead load, we consider them separately.
And we thereby have some separate factors during the calculation of the total load. So, both this loads, the dead and the light, they are based on the force of gravity light. Gravity is the key force why we have that load on the structure. And that's why they are always located in the gravity direction, which is the minus Z direction. Right? So, these two are the loads, which is the comes from the gravity component. And then the environmental load. Now, that's a separate load based on where the structure is located, on which type of region it's located.
What are the different occurrence of? Is it a rain? Is it a snow? Is it a temperature change? Is it in the earthquake zone region, in the high wind zone region? So, all this forms a part of a environmental load. So, load which is imposed on the structure by the environment. Now, we are not imparting that environment imparts some load on the structure. Again, this is quite a variable load. So, you may say that it can be considered as a live load. But no, live loads are definitely the ones wherein the gravity is the direction of the load.
Whereas, in the environmental load, there is no certain directions. So, just to speak about that. If you see, wind direction is not always constant. It is a lateral force. Direction keeps on changing across the year time. Right? So, some day we have wind coming from north. Some time we have it coming from the southeast. So, it keeps on changing. Similarly, rains are very variable. Like, we have maximum rains in the month of July, August. But then we don't have any rains in the month of December.
Earthquakes are quite random. Temperature changes. Now, this temperature changes is quite significant bit in India as well. Like, we have close to 40-45 degree temperature in the month of summers. Wherein we have close to negative 5 degree in winter months. So, that's a quite huge temperature change. And your structure has to resist all this. So, for the temperature change, there is induced load in the structure. And that, the structure has to resist. Now, all these environmental loads are variable. And with different probabilities, basically. The probability of wind is different.
Probability of rain is different than that of earthquake. And that of temperature. So, all these have different variables. Wind would be maximum at some point of a day. And at that point, we may not have the maximum earthquake occurring as well. Or else, maximum rain occurring as well. So, the probabilities of each items are different. And that's why we have a separate set of load combinations when we identify and assess them. Then we, basically, these forces are not always vertical or the gravity. They are mostly lateral forces.
And they can be in positive and negative sense. As in, from x direction. If you take x direction positive. Then there can be chances that sometime the wind can be in the negative x as well. Or if we talk about positive y. Then there can be chances where the wind will be negative y. So, these are all reversible loads. Again, not a constant ones. So, these are covered under the environmental load. Again, the lateral loads and the gravity loads. So, first two falls under the gravity.
Third one are the lateral loads. So, just to give you a brief about wind and seismic. Because these are the two key lateral loads occurring in the building. And as you already saw in the previous slides. These are the ones which govern the cost of the tall buildings. So, we should be very accurate in their assessment of wind and seismic. And how they govern the design of the elements. Now, wind, wind wind load coming from the pressure difference created. Due to the motion particles basically. That's why they have wind as a load.
And that depends basically on location. So, if we are constructing a structure which is close to a seashore. The wind loads will be significantly higher. But if you are constructing a structure far away from the seashore. Your wind loads may be lower. Now, so, wind loads are very dynamic. In the sense that there are many factors associated with their value basically. To derive their value. And the factors can be like wind speed. Terrain. Also depend on the terrain. Wherein our structure is. Topography of the location.
So, just to give an highlight. That if our structure is at the top of the rock. Definitely we attract a lot many loads. And. And. And. Same thing, if our structure is at the foothills of a hill, foothills of a Himalayas or somewhere, then the loads would be significantly lesser. And as a generic sense, force increases with the height. So if you see a typical structure, if you see the wind load increases as the height of the structure increases. And that's not a linear increase basically. So the force increases, if you see this is the force.
So this is not a linear way. This is a 7th power law basically. So as we go tall from, this is at the 2 meter height and this is the 4 meter. Then here if the wind load is acting as X, here it won't be 2X, rather it will be somewhere 3X. And similarly, this would be somewhere 10X and this will be 20X. So this is how the wind load increases basically by the 7th power law. And that's the reason when we go tall, the loads at the top stories are significantly higher.
And that's the reason why there are certain restrictions to the height that we are not able to construct a building which is like 3 kilometer tall or 4 kilometer tall. And that's that's one of the reason why we are not because the loads of the wind when we go high is significantly higher. Now, there is a difference also in the way which wind acts. All of us understand, right? So wind acts on the exterior surface of a building. There is no way that the wind acts only on the top part and not acts at the bottom or some way.
So it acts uniformly, but acts on the exterior part of a surface uniform in a way. It acts uniformly across the same height, but as we go on in increasing height, the value increases basically. So the excitation is an applied pressure or the force on the facade. So from facade, the load gets transferred to the structure. So basically it acts on the main exterior frames and then the exterior frames transfer it to the floor diaphragms and that's how the load is resisted by the building. So if you see over here in the direction, there are some gravity loads, there are some wind loads, environmental loads, and this is the load flow load path of a building.
And thereby the loads, lateral loads and the gravity loads are transferred to the foundation of a structure. So this is regarding the wind part of it. Now we will go to the seismic part of it. And there is one significant change in the way how wind operates on a building and how the seismic operates on a building. So seismic, as you say, earthquake load. So earthquake is a phenomenon which occurs due to the movement of tectonic plates, right? So when the tectonic plates move relative to one another, there is release of energy.
And that release of energy when it travels through the ground media generates an acceleration at the base of the structure. So if you can see, this is an acceleration time history of the ground basically that has been generated due to the motion of two tectonic plates. And once that motion takes place, our structure, which is lying on that ground, basically all structures are supported on the ground. So because the ground moves, our structure also moves. Now, if you have observed, and it's also obvious that if the ground motion, the ground acceleration is UG, the structural acceleration won't be UG.
So it won't move with the same acceleration. It moves at some other acceleration, which is not that of a structure. It moves at slightly higher acceleration, that of ground. So when there is an earthquake, our structure definitely, I'll just say the behavior of how the earthquake force are induced. So whenever there is a movement in the ground, so whenever ground gets displaced, our structure, because it's at rest. So as per the Newton's law, any body at rest would try to remain at rest, right? So when the ground moves, the structure tries to remain at rest, but because the ground has moved, the structure has to move.
That's the induced force which is created in the structure. Now, because of that ground acceleration, right? So anything which has mass, any item which has mass would be subjected to an acceleration because of the inertia impact. And that mass into that inertial acceleration would produce an inertial force in the structure. So there is no direct force. Now, if I compare between the wind and the seismic, the wind being the direct force, you can see that force is getting applied on the exterior portion of a structure.
Seismic is not like it applies on the exterior of the portion. It is basically a virtue of mass. So anything which has a mass would definitely tend to have a force in it. That's a pseudo force or a seismic force. So any element, like if we have all elements have a mass, right? All elements in terms of concrete, we are making up of concrete or steel. Everything has a mass in it. So the slab element would try to deform itself and through that, there will be an inertial force in the slab element and that would result in a seismic force in that slab element.
Similarly, there will be inertia of a column which will be different and due to that inertia, there will be a force in the column. Similarly, that in the beam, that in the wall, everything will have a force. So it's not a direct force, but it's an induced force, induced force in terms of inertia, right? So if we talk about the earthquake, there are a lot, many parameters associated with the estimation of the earthquake force as well. So as we saw in the wind, the location of the structure, the wind speed, terrain, height, all these were criteria in the estimation of the wind load.
Similarly, for the seismic, we have criteria such as focus of earthquake, like distance from the focus, where the earthquake has occurred, shaking intensity, the ground conditions, the mass and stiffness distribution in the structure. So all this would be the governing parameters for estimation of the earthquake load. Now, this excitation is an applied displacement base and the force will be distributed along the interior and the exterior of the lateral load resisting elements. So as I said, the force will be not direct force. We are not directly pushing a structure.
We are just moving the base and the force is induced in the structure because of its inertia. As the building always wants to remain stable, there would be an inertial force created to resist that. So this is how the seismic action takes place. And this is an equation of motion. So you would have studied MU double dot, that is mass into the acceleration. Again, if you see mass into acceleration is a force plus 2 xi omega MU dot. Again, that is coming from the damping of the structure plus M omega square U is coming from the stiffness part of it.
And then we come to a final external force, which is MU double dot G. It's the ground acceleration into mass, the ground force. So we will be studying this in detail in the next or the upcoming lectures. So don't worry on that front. But again, as I said, earthquake forces are not a direct force. They are induced due to the mass effect in it. So once we get a hold of the gravity forces and the lateral forces, now we understand what do we mean by gravity forces and lateral forces.
So these are the external forces, right? These are now we have internal forces. So external forces are coming through an external agency. External agency can be a wind, can be a seismic, can be a gravity, can be a live load from us. So all these are external sources. Now to resist the external forces, building has to give some internal restraints, right? So through the internal forces, building restrained or the member restraints the external forces. This is how the philosophy of equilibrium comes into the picture. Whatever is the external load would be resisted by the internal reactions, right?
If somebody gets pushed, he would definitely fall because of the internal responses of the structure. So this is how the external and the internal forces takes place. Now we will just look at the internal forces which are developed in the building due to the external forces. Now, the first is a compression force. Again, the direction of it is along the axis of the member. Axis will be something which is center line of this member along the direction of the member. That's the internal compression force. Both direction towards one another trying to compress a member, right?
Trying to push a member from both the sides. So if we try to push a duster between two hands, we can see that the duster will be in a compression force. So that's an internal force, right? Similarly, there is a tension force. So if we try to pull a duster from two of its ends, the duster will be subjected to a tensile force. Again, both these forces are along the longitudinal axis of the member, right? So there is a third force, which is the torque. Now the torque is the opposing forces applied at two different points.
So if we try to twist this member, twist a duster, if we apply couple, clockwise couple on the left, or the top of the member and anti-clockwise couple at the bottom of the member, we will be able to get a torque generated in the member. That's the reason we have the torque as a third force, internal force. So as I said, there is an axial force and a bending moment. So axial force are those which acts along the axis of the member. So you can see the compression force and the tensile force, the acts along the direction of the member, and these are the axial forces.
Whereas we have the bending moment. So the bending moment is the one which is acting along the axis at a certain distance. So along this y-axis is acting, but it is not acting at the center, it's acting at some distance. Now bending is, now because of this force being subjected at a certain distance, there is a bending effect in the member. So if you can see how your arm gets bent when somebody pushes your arm in one direction, this is how you can understand how the bending takes place in the members.
So if we have a force, which is passing through the centroidal axis, then definitely there is no way it causes a bending in a structure, right? But if it is applied at some other distance, which is not passing through the centroidal axis, then it creates a bending in that structure. So basically there are two types of forces, the axial forces acting along the members, along the internal axis, and the bending forces basically cause due to the forces acting at some other distance to the centroidal axis of the member, basically.
These are the two basic ways in which we have the internal forces, the axial force and the bending force. Both of them resist the external forces, right? So internal at all times would be equal to external to maintain the equilibrium, right? Our structure has to maintain an equilibrium. It cannot move or it cannot, if somebody pushes it, it's like moving away and away. It has to resist it. There would be some displacements, but again at the end it has to come to rest. And that's why we say that internal forces generated inside the structure would always be equal and opposite to the external forces.
Now we will speak more about the connections which are involved in the structure, different type of connections or the support conditions we will figure out in our day-to-day use in the structures. So the first one is the pin-jointed structure. Next is the fixed-jointed and the third is the roller joints. Now we don't have only these three types of connections, but we have not many other different types of connections as well. These are the basic connections to understand the behavior of a structure. So that's why we are taking first these three.
And then as we move forward into the coursework, we will see two different types of connections involved. So just to start with the first very basic one, which is the pin-jointed connections. So a pin-jointed connections would be somewhat like you can see in the example, the one which resist the vertical and the horizontal translation. So the vertical and the horizontal translation is resisted, but the rotation is allowed. So the member can rotate about this point. Again, if the rotation is allowed, that means there will be no movement at that point, right?
Because now there is no restraint to the movement because movement is the action which tries to rotate that member, right? Due to that movement, there will be some rotation. And if rotation is free, that means there is no movement. So a movement would be zero at that joint, wherever we have a pin-jointed, but we would have definitely the vertical and the horizontal translation restricted, basically. Now we have the fixed joint. So in pin, we had the restraints of vertical and horizontal. Similarly, in fixed, we have the vertical and horizontal restraint.
Over and above that, we have the restriction on the rotations as well. So now your member won't be rotating at the joint. There will be some restrained joint and there is no allowance, basically no allowance allowed in this type of connection. That means if we are connecting two members, now if you're connecting a beam and column and keeping it as a fixed joint, there will be all six degrees of freedom which are restrained, basically. The vertical, the horizontal, the rotation in all three directions will be restrained, basically.
And then we have a roller joint. In the roller joint, you can see over here, we have some rollers below the support. And that roller allows the horizontal movement of this beam which is kept on this roller. So the beam can move in the horizontal direction, which is the X direction. But it is restrained along the Y direction. So the roller creates a restraint along the Y direction. It is a vertical direction. But it's free to move along the X direction. So that's one type of a support.
Here at the support, the rotation is also allowed. So there won't be a movement at the roller joint. There won't be a movement at the pin joint. But there will be definitely a movement at the fixed joint. Because fixed joints doesn't allow the rotation. So wherever there is a restriction of any action, there is tend to be an internal reaction, right? So wherever there is a restriction, we have an internal force. That's internal force is called a movement. So we have a movement in fixed joints.
We don't have any movements in the pin joint or the roller joint. I hope this will be clear. So now we have a comprehensive idea about the connections involved. Now we will go through things which we have learned in this session. And we will have a brief about what all things we understood during the course of this one hour. So if you just go to the first slide and just brief back. So we started with the introduction wherein we took a fair idea about how the current demography of India is.
What are the opportunities considering the population growth and the population density? The need for the high rises, the rural population shifting towards the urban and thereby the urban population requiring the need for tall buildings, total structures. And we took out the understood the CTVUH criterias for the definition of tall buildings. The three criteria is the height related to the context, the proportion and the embracing technology. Then we understood the threshold levels for the tall buildings, the number of storey criteria and the building height criteria and how to calculate the building height based on the ground floor to the top architectural top.
Then we understood the further classification in super tall and mega tall. Again, the heights are the key area which is greater than 300. It considers as a super tall and for heights greater than 600 is considered as a mega tall. And then we looked at the further classification is in the building and the tower that 50% of the height is occupiable than its building. If that is not met, then it's a tower. And we also discussed about the mixed use occupancy versus single use occupancy where in the criteria of 85% or more of dedicated use was considered as a single use.
Whereas if there is lesser than 85% of one type of function, then that can be considered as a multiple use or multi use. Then we saw the top many structures across the world that includes both buildings and towers. And these are the top 10 tallest buildings in 2020. Again, we saw the Burj Khalifa and Shanghai considering themselves under mega tall buildings, whereas all the rest of them where it's greater than 300 but lesser than 600. So those are currently under super tall buildings. Then we saw how fast the pace of the construction can be and within the 15 to 20 years, we would be able to see not many tall structures.
The different materials being used, traditional concrete to steel and how we are using precast for the faster pace of construction, where we use composite and what's the purpose is the getting the best of what concrete is having in best of steel, combining that and using it effectively to reduce the loads, the sizes and the cost basically. So we saw about the different materials, then we also understood that which material is the key driver at present, which is the concrete. And as I said, composite is the next, which is growing very fast pace.
And as we move to the next decade, we will see many more composite, composite being getting bigger in that pie. And let's close to 38 percent at present. And we also saw how the evolution take took place basically from most of the structures on the tall buildings in North America. And slowly the Europe and then the Asia catching up. And then after the Asia, I think the Middle East was the one which was also catching up on that. So by the next decade, we will see majority of the structures would be there and tall structures would be there.
Mostly again those would be of composite. So composite is a critical thing which we should be looking and understanding. We understood the cost implications basically. How wind and earthquake generate a high premium for the buildings which are tall and how significant those can be. Like we gave an example from 10 to 50 storey, the premium gets double basically or the cost gets double. And similarly from 50 to 100, again the cost even gets further more than 100, 120, 150 percent. So that's a significant rise which we see in the construction of tall structures.
With this in background we understood more on the loads, the gravity loads in terms of dead, the permanent actions and the live loads which are the variable actions. Both of them being applied in the direction of gravity which is minus Z which are the dead loads which is the finishes and the self-weight of the structure. Whereas the live incorporates the load coming from the people, the building furniture which is temporary furniture and storage items. Then we also understood the environmental load which is the different loads which gets imposed on the structure by the environment.
Again those are when rain, earthquake, temperature change, all being one another way, lateral forces, both positive and negative in their directions. And their probabilities also are very different and that's why we consider them as a separate environmental load. Then we saw how the basic understanding of how the wind load gets applied on the structure. We understood that as we go high, the wind load increases. That again is not a linear increase but it's a parabolic increase in the 7th order term basically. And again the wind load is applied in the exterior phase of the structure.
So exterior facade is the one which resists the wind load. And depending on the location of the building, the wind speed, terrain, topography, the wind load keeps on changing. And to estimate the wind load correctly, we need to assess all these parameters before that. And we saw how that geography and exposed area like the drag force is one and a half rho is CD into V square. So basically CD is depending upon the profile of the facade basically. Is it a flat profile or a curved profile?
So based on that, the drag force is applied. Again, all the forces here are shown as a drag force basically. And as we all noted that the force is applied to the exterior frames. And through that exterior frames, it is transferred to the floor diaphragms. Which are the slabs in our case. This is how the wind takes place. And then we noted about the seismic forces. Basically due to the tectonic movements, there is a generation of an acceleration at the base of the ground. That ground acceleration results in some acceleration in the structure because of the inertia force.
And that force, inertial force is the earthquake force induced in the structure. And now we also discussed the different parameters which are involved in the calculation or the estimation of the seismic force. Those being the earthquake force, focus of the earthquake to the location of the structure distance. The shaking intensity, how heavy the intensity of shaking was. The ground condition means what type of underlying soil is. Is it a soft soil, a loose soil, a rock or a stiff soil basically. So depending on the soil, the force of the earthquake is different.
Then there is a difference due to the mass and the stiffness distribution. So if we have a heavy mass at the top, that will attract a lot of seismic forces. Considering a lot of inertia forces are there. And similarly, the stiffness is involved in the windings. So we understood the difference between both type of wind and seismic force as well. Wind being more like a direct force. Whereas seismic being an induced force. Wind increases with increase in the height. There is no such type of increase with increase in height in terms of seismic.
But seismic force is increased with increase in the weight of a structure, right? So those structures which are of less weight would attract less. Overall force would be less in those structures. Wherein the heavy structures attract large amount of earthquake forces. And the probability or the occurrence of wind is quite different. Because wind is continuous force, right? There will always be wind. Rather seismic is not an always force. Seismic force only occurs during the case where we have an earthquake. And that would be a random phenomenon, right?
Right? We don't have a fixed rate of a curl of a seismic force. But as and when there is an earthquake, there will be a base acceleration on the ground. And that's the reason why we have the seismic forces. So we understood both these lateral forces. And then we went on from external forces to the internal forces. How do building resist those external forces? We understood the compression, the tension force, the torque. Basically, the three actions involved. Then we classified that into axial force, which is acted along the axis of the member.
And those wherein the load is applied at certain distance from the axis of the member. So that's the bending force, right? So we classified the internal forces into the axial and the bending. Then we came to the connections part of it, wherein we spoke about how to connect to different members via pin joint, via fixed joint, via roller joint. And how like basically the pin joint uses a restraint in vertical and horizontal direction, which is the translation restraints. And it allows the rotation. So once it allows the rotation, there is no movement at the joint, because now the movement is the one which causes the rotation.
And if the rotation is free, there is no movement at the joint, right? Movement rest in the joint. So pin joint is that. Similar to the pin, we have roller, wherein roller, we allow the horizontal translation through the rollers. And that would in turn give translation, basically allow a translation in the horizontal direction. And no restraint is provided along that. Again, this ruler can allow rotation. So no movement would be there at the moment restraint would be there at the ruler. Whereas the third case is the fixed joint, wherein all degrees of freedom would be restrained.
There won't be a vertical translation or horizontal translation or a rotation possible in any direction. So that's a fixed joint, like fixing to with a perfect joint is a fixed joint connection.