← Previous lessonFree lesson 3 of 3 · lesson 3 of 30

Unlock all 30 lessons of Design for Manufacturability (DFM)Full course ₹40,000 · paid

Price & syllabus
Free lesson · 17 min · no payment

Concurrent Engineering Versus the Over-the-Wall Design Process

A free lesson from Skill-Lync's Design for Manufacturability (DFM) course, on Grow by Skill-Lync · Last updated 16 Nov 2026 · Session: “Concurrent Engineering and Conventional Design Process”

What will you learn in this free Design for Manufacturability (DFM) lesson?

The instructor describes the conventional sequential design process, where marketing, design and production pass work between departments, and its drawbacks of time loss and personality conflict. The lesson then covers concurrent engineering, the specialists in the team, a multimeter redesigned with 76 components instead of 131, and the rule of 10 for fixing faults.

  • Why sequential design causes rework and conflict
  • Which specialists join a concurrent engineering team
  • The design engineer's role as a listener
  • Rule of 10 for the cost of late fixes

What comes after lesson 3?

Later in Skill-Lync's Design for Manufacturability (DFM) course (paid): lesson 4, Mechanical Design Process Overview; lesson 5, DF Analysis Worksheet: Theoretical Minimum Part Count; lesson 6, Determining Base Parts and Evaluating Assembly Movement. The full course has 30 lessons (11 h 8 min of video); see the course overview or its price and syllabus.

Lesson transcript

Machine transcript of the lesson audio (lightly cleaned). Technical terms may contain errors; the video is the reference.

Okay, so we reached concurrent engineering and I believe you are thinking a lot of DFMA as of now. But yes, let's come to the process orientation. So we have to understand when we have to use DFMA, how the DFMA will be implemented, what are the points of discussion, who are the owners of different fields who can take part in the DFMA discussion. And it's not just DFMA. Concurrent engineering is about everything. Concurrent engineering is about standardizing the process. Yeah, moving on to slide 24. So here, to understand concurrent engineering in a better way, we need to know what is a conventional design process and its drawbacks.

In the right side image, we are seeing a wall. In the left side, you have design team. In the right side, you have manufacturing team. So, design team, they are like idea generators. They generate concepts. They do the design. And then the manufacturing team, it brings that design from paper to the physical world. Now, we have a wall in between to separate these two design teams and manufacturing team. This process, this like the conventional design process is also called over the wall method. Why? Because each department completes its allotted task and passes it over an imagined cubical wall.

The method is also known as over the wall technique. There is no any relation between the design team and the manufacturing team here in the conventional design process. Moving on to slide 25. Now, here you can see what are the sequence in which the conventional or sequential design process is followed. So, the typical design process is sequential. First, the marketing department, they do the market survey. They bring the input to the design department. The design department creates a design based on the input from marketing team.

And then the design department throws everything to the next box. That is production department. Production department, whatever it understands, it manufactures or if it is not able to manufacture, it throws it back to the design department. Then again, design department will do some changes and throw it back to the production department. And finally, if the product is manufactured, it is thrown to the sales and service department. So, there is no any relation. There is no any particular relation between all these departments at a time together. So, it is just like throwing to another basket.

Moving to next slide 26. Now, marketing team. It does the market survey for finding customer requirements, handovers, product brief to the design department. Next, design team. It creates the design and tests the prototype, produces and assembles precise drawings that are given to the production department for approval. Next, production team sends the drawing back to the design department with suggested design reasons or design changes for production reasons. For example, if they are finding a design which is not feasible to be produced or machined or manufactured, then of course they will not be able to do it.

So, they have to return it back to the design team with the suggested changes to be done. And then again, if I will go back to slide 26, then again the design team produces and assembles precise drawings and again send it to production department for approval. Production department, they see that whatever they have suggested, not everything is updated or everything is updated, then they can produce it further. But if some percentage of it is not implemented, then they will again throw it back to the design team.

So, the sequence 2 and 3 keep repeating, this process of delivering drawings from the design team to the production team and vice versa continues until the design is finished. And this occurs due to the difference in the background of a design engineer and a manufacturing engineer. Why that difference is there because design engineer, they are considered as creative artists because it's just that they have to think it, they have to design it in the 3D model in the CAD software and they have to start creating the drawings.

But a manufacturing team, they are considered as realistic engineers and they know the reality, what is imagination and what can be brought into a physical product. So, they have the difference in the background of their thinking itself. So, that's why sequence 2 and 3 keeps repeating. Then comes to sales and service team, if suppose with all these repetition, the product is manufactured, then it comes to the sales team to sell the product and handle the aftermarket service or after sales service. Now, as we discussed the conventional design process, you must be getting to know what are the drawbacks in the conventional design process.

First thing is time loss. Second, personality conflict. First is very obvious, nothing to be explained in it. But second, personality conflict. This is a usual human nature. If a person is told to do something which he is not ready to do, then of course he or she will not be doing that particular task happily. And if a person does some work and another person always keep finding the mistakes in the work, then of course the first person will have a personality conflict with the second person that, hey, this person is always trying to blame me.

So, all these personality conflicts will result in laying blames and other heated arguments. So, these are the drawbacks in the conventional design process. Now, to overcome the shortcomings of the conventional or sequential design approach, it is necessary to combine design and manufacturing activities as one engineering discipline. Simultaneous or concurrent engineering is replacing conventional or sequential design process in recent years. Now, at this particular stage, when people understood that the conventional design process won't work for long, then they started thinking on the other way of bringing everyone together at one stage.

And that is called simultaneous or concurrent engineering. Moving on to slide 29. Concurrent engineering is the design method that combines the efforts of manufacturing and design engineers in the initial stage of the design process. It consists of a group of experts who look over the plan. Now, you must have understood what is concurrent engineering and why this came into picture. Next, what are the group of experts to be considered for concurrent engineering? That you need to know. Moving to next slide 30. Specialists expected to be a part of concurrent engineering are as follows.

As we can see in the right side image, you have one table and on that table, you have eight set of people sitting. All belong to different background and they are sitting together and discussing on the design. So, we have design engineer. We have manufacturing engineer. We have tools engineer. We have field personal or service engineer. We have one reliability engineer. We have one health and safety engineer. We have one purchase manager. Now, you must be surprised that why health and safety engineer is here. Of course, you need not to design a part which in the process of functioning of your design, a human.

So, there should always be health and safety consideration in every design. Till now, we have been discussing about design engineer and manufacturing engineer and the problems in between these two set of people in the conventional design process. But what about service engineer? Why we are not taking input from service engineer? How difficult it will be to replace a field component in the field? We need to know this. And if we can help the service engineer in doing the service at a later stage by implementing some design changes in the initial stage, then that will be saving our service time duration and the cost and the labor cost for service.

So, overall your product will be cut to cut edge with your competitor. If the people find your product easy to be serviced, easy to be maintained at lower cost, then of course the customers for your product will increase. So, yes, everyone is important here and we have some design engineers also. So, the role of design engineer here. So, the role of design engineer here. Should be more of a listener. Design engineer should always listen to everyone, take the input, note it down, see how much the design engineer can implement everything in the design and in case if the design engineer is not able to implement any particular point, then the design engineer should be expert enough to tell then and there in the same meeting that this is the reason and what is the alternate suggestion. So for such discussions only, concurrent engineering method is implemented in mechanical design process so that there should not be any time wastage in throwing of documents from one box to another.

So everything can be discussed at the same time in front of everyone and taking inputs from everyone at the same time. So the rework time duration for a design engineer can be decreased and at one particular time itself all the changes can be implemented and the drawing can move through for everyone's approval. So during this discussion, DFMA inputs will play a major role. We can get DFMA inputs from everyone. Moving to next slide 31. Example, concurrent engineering was used by Keith Lee Instruments, Solo, USA. This company makes measuring instruments. So they used concurrent engineering in the creation of a digital multimeter.

The new instrument had only 76 components instead of 131 and 8 assembly screws instead of 30. And the number of tools needed during the assembly was reduced by 35% and only one screwdriver was needed. So the impact of concurrent engineering can be seen here on the product design. I think this is one of the best example we have for DFMA and concurrent engineering. Moving to next slide 32. So we have some famous personalities. Dr. David Anderson, one of the foremost authorities on concurrent engineering and DFM argues that rule of 10 in DFM asserts that it costs 10 times more to rectify flaws at each subsequent level of assembly.

Therefore, if fixing a part fault costs N before assembly, it will cost 10 N during sub-assembly, 100 N during final assembly, 1000 N during the distributor stage, and 10,000 N if the protect has already been delivered to the customer. Now, to give one example, which we must have read that some automotive companies, they are calling back some cars from the customer back to the factory for changing of brake lining or for changing of some other component, because it is found that those components or design is failing for almost every next customer or every alternate customer or those are like the most known failures.

So this can come in the category of 10,000 N. So for that company to rectify that particular fault, once that car is sold to customer, it will cost almost 10,000 times of the cost which it would have costed when the car was at the company itself during design. Moving on to next slide 33. So this slide is basically what design engineering does and what are the inputs which we get from different team specialists. So the first one in the left side, you can see all concepts provided by the designer to the concurrent engineering team specialists.

What are those things? A design engineer can design a part based on design need. So from design need to the final product, the design engineer can follow several concepts. So in the image, you can see there are three lines moving here and there and then coming out at one end at another end. And in the top, you have design process knowledge. So design engineer will put all the design process knowledge into concept development. And then he can find that there are several paths for getting that design need done while doing that.

What are the things he would have thought of physics? He or she would have thought of material science. The design engineer, if belongs to electricals, then electric motors, engineering science, thermodynamics, manufacturing process, welding design, engineering economics, kinematics, pumps, everything, all the domain knowledge they would have implemented in the design process to get a concept created. But like we see here, there are three concepts created. All the three concepts cannot be produced or even if it is produced for testing purpose, but only one design will go ahead in the market.

Now, that particular one best design can be decided in the concurrent engineering with the inputs we get from other specialists in the concurrent engineering team. That is the product function, production system, sales forecast. So, all these people can give you input for materials and its availability, the manufacturing processes, whether they have that particular facility or not to produce such dimensional specs, what can be the maximum cost they can go for, they can afford, then what is the production planning, sourcing, target market, everything. Suppose you are designing a concept for China, but you belong to US, you cannot use every US produced items in China because China have some restriction.

They don't want to use US or any Europe part directly into China or they don't want to use it at all. You need to find an alternate. How you will get that input? That input can be provided by the production team or the sales forecast, the sourcing team, the commodity manager, that no, the global comp plans, they will tell no, Chinese assembly, they don't comp plan for US parts. You got the input. Now, you will change your design in the initial stage itself. So, finally, one best design will come in concurrent engineering.

Want the rest of Design for Manufacturability (DFM)?

Get the full course syllabus and fees.

The full course is paid (₹40,000). We'll send the syllabus and call you back within one working day.

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Full course · paid

Unlock the full Design for Manufacturability (DFM) course

The remaining 27 lessons, mentor-reviewed projects and a certificate come with the paid course (₹40,000). Leave your details: we'll send the syllabus and fees and call you back.

Get the syllabus and fees

A counsellor calls you back within one working day.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Grow by Skill-Lync · free lesson

Start watching

Free, no payment. Leave your details once and every free lesson on Grow plays straight away. A Skill-Lync counsellor may call you about the full Design for Manufacturability (DFM) course.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Talk to a career counsellor

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.