Lesson finished
Unlock all 25 lessons of Automotive BIW Design and Development Part 1 using NXCADFull course ₹40,000 · paid
Benchmarking Cars: Customer View and Design Engineer Case Studies
A free lesson from Skill-Lync's Automotive BIW Design and Development Part 1 using NXCAD course, on Grow by Skill-Lync · Last updated 16 Nov 2026 · Session: “Week 1 Session 3 Benchmarking”
What will you learn in this free Automotive BIW Design and Development Part 1 using NXCAD lesson?
The lesson defines benchmarking as a structured comparison of products, processes and services. One case compares five cheap Indian-market automatic cars by cost, mileage and pros and cons. A second compares two models by body weight, finding A pillar and B pillar differences, thickness values and 490 versus 436 parts.
- Definition of benchmarking across industries
- Comparing cars from the customer's point of view
- Comparing two bodies by weight and part count
- Reading pillar mass differences from thickness and parts
What comes after lesson 3?
Later in Skill-Lync's Automotive BIW Design and Development Part 1 using NXCAD course (paid): lesson 4, BIW components and materials; lesson 5, Week 02_Session 01 NXcad Basics-1; lesson 6, Week 02_Session 02 Curves and Surfaces. The full course has 25 lessons (8 h 30 min of video); see the course overview or its price and syllabus.
Lesson transcript
Machine transcript of the lesson audio (lightly cleaned). Technical terms may contain errors; the video is the reference.
Hey guys, in the previous video, you'd have learnt what the vehicle development process is and the various processes that are involved in the vehicle development process. One of which would have been benchmarking. Now, let us look at what benchmarking is and also various case studies. So, what exactly is benchmarking? Here, I have a definition and an example associated with it. I'm not going to read it, but I'll explain this definition here. So, let us look at what benchmarking process is. So, benchmarking is an industrial process. So, what does this mean?
Benchmarking is a process which is basically followed in every industry, be it a manufacturing or an automotive industry, or textile or a service-based or even a software industry. Be it a sales team or a design team, they're going to follow benchmarking. It is going to be in their process. So, benchmarking is an industrial process which involves structured comparison between similar products and processes and also the services. So, what does this mean? This is a simple comparison between two products, the processes associated with it, and the services provided for those products at the same level.
Meaning, let us say we have two cars that are of the same level, say two mid-class sedans in India, the products, their parts, the weight of the parts, their performances, and the services provided for them, the manufacturing processes, and the practices followed by the industries are going to be compared by either one of them. And also, they're going to be either done in specific for a particular purpose, or they're going to be done in general. Also, I mentioned the examples here. They're going to be done for two cars that are of the same class, but manufactured and sold by different companies.
So, the companies, either of them want to compare the performance, the features, the crash ratings, and also the assembly processes associated with each model. Now, first case study. Here, we are going to compare various vehicles in the Indian market to suggest the best or the most affordable automatic variant to a customer. So, we have the customer's point of view benchmarking. Here, I'm going to be comparing five models that are currently available in the Indian market that are relatively cheap and also have an automatic CVT variant with them.
Now, here we have the Suzuki A-star. For every car, I've mentioned the cool aspects, the bad aspects, the mileages, and also the cost. So, based on these criteria, in general, we're going to compare these five cars and make the best out of it and suggest the customer what would be his best choice. So, for the cool aspects, we have it has a Pepe engine. It's a relatively small car. So, it has a Pepe engine. That's one of my cool aspects. It is the cheapest of all the five variants that has been mentioned here. So, speaking about the cost, it's 4.37 lakhs.
Now, coming to the bad aspects. So, here we've talked about, we've already mentioned that this is a small car. So, here the legroom and the headroom is going to be small. So, if I'm a person who is on an average of 6 feet tall or 6.2, this is not going to be the right car for me. And also, the headroom is not going to be enough for a 6 foot or a 5.9 in case tall person. Also, we have the mileage here. Let us take only the ARAI values. That's 17 kilometers per liter.
Now, moving on to the Hyundai i10. So, coming to Hyundai, Hyundai cars always have good ergonomics and they also have value for money. That was meaning they have a good resale value. This is basically called a tall boy car. So, this gives me what the A star couldn't. Here again, the mileage is going to be 17 and the bad aspects include inconsistent mileage. So, the 17 is going to be, is not going to be consistent. It is going to vary. And also, it has a high maintenance cost as compared to the Suzuki models because Suzuki models usually have lower cost in terms of maintenance and service.
Also, here the price is going to be between 5 lakhs and 6 lakhs. Also, the 6 lakh variant has sunroof, ABS and airbags variants. Now, the Skoda Fabia. The Skoda, it is on the luxury side of sedans. Now, it is expensive and also it has a high maintenance cost. Those are the bad aspects. Also, you have good luggage area. It has a really good ergonomic and best handling of all the 5 variants. And also, it has a good legroom. Because it is a sedan class, it is not a hatchback as compared to the previous models.
The mileage is going to be lower. It is going to be 14. But the cost, it is highly expensive. It is going to be somewhere between 8 and 9.5 lakhs. Now, the Hyundai i20. It is almost similar to the Hyundai i10 except that it also has a diesel version. Mileage is going to be the same and the cost is going to be on the upper side. It is going to be 7.59 to 8 lakhs. But also, for this cost, it has standard ABS and also the sunroof as an option.
Moving on to the Suzuki SX-4. The Suzuki, as already mentioned, it has a really good name for its serviceability and its lower maintenance cost. But since this is a sedan class, and for this particular model, we need an increased maintenance cost. This also has a diesel version, which is one of the cool aspects. The cost is again on the upper side because this is a sedan class. It is somewhere between 8.4 and 8.75 lakhs. The mileage is going to be the same, 17 for all the Suzuki cars.
It has ABS and airbags as standard. So, for this price, we get ABS and airbags as standard. That is one of the cool aspects. Now, based on these, you will be given an assignment. You will be given a different scenario and you will be asked to compare various models that are currently there in the Indian market. And you have to give or suggest the customer what is going to be the best option. And this is going to be one of your exercises for benchmarking. Now, let us look at the second case study.
This is one of the important case study where we are going to assume ourselves to be design engineers. And we are going to look at two different models, AX and Y. And we are going to understand what is the major difference in depth between both the models or both cars even. So, now let us compare two models, AX and Y, based on their wheelbase, track width, their height, the total metal weight of all the BIW parts, the number of parts and all, and also the surface area for ED coating.
Now, as you can see, the overall length, the overall height, the width, the wheelbase, all these have major or minor differences in the range of 5mm, 6mm, and 100mm. So, these are not going to affect the entire performance in all. But, coming to the metal weight and the number of stamping parts, here we have a major difference of 15kgs and also number of stamping parts has been increased to 54. So, from this table, what I infer is the major difference is between the last but row and the row before that, that is the metal weight and the number of stamping parts.
So, what I will be doing is I will be taking these two into account and we will be further looking into them in depth. Now, so, what's our agenda here? It's going to be to compare the body and weight mass of both the vehicles X and Y. So, this will be our benchmarking here. Now, as you can see here, X and Y have their weights and increments listed. So, it's going to be the EN components, the floor, the body, and the cover. So, you can see 63 and 64 doesn't make a huge difference. 96 and 101, it's just 5kgs.
But, here, have 127 and 53. That is almost 26kgs difference. So, from this, I infer that the body of X is much heavier than the body of Y. That is, by difference of 26kgs. So, now that I have eliminated all these three, I will consider the bodies of both the cars and study that in depth. So, here we have the body of the car. This is the general body of a car. So, studying in depth body of both the vehicles, here we see that two parts, mainly the A pillar or the front pillar and the B pillar or the center pillar have a major mass difference.
So, here you have 9kgs and 7kg difference. So, here now, I will study in depth both the designs right now to understand why there is a huge mass difference and understand why the two companies had various thoughts on what the mass of the front and the center pillars are going to be. So, here we have the front pillar or the A pillar comparison for X and Y. As you can see, the total weight is around 16kgs and here it is less than 7kgs. So, that is a huge difference of 9kgs.
Yes. What do we understand here? As you can see, the parts inside this yellow boundary, there are a lot of parts. So, this means they have a lot of embosses. So, why did the company X or the model X go for this and increase the weight? So, here, I understand that these parts were introduced here to give more reinforcements and increase the strength of the front pillar to get a better crash rating. So, what did the company Y do? The company Y reduced the parts ultimately to get a lower weight and to increase the mileage of the car.
So, which of it is wrong? Coming to that point, neither of them are wrong. So, one company compared to other variants and other models and they wanted to sell their car from a point of view that it is more safer. This company that is Y, the model Y wanted to go for a much lower weight and so they reduced the weight wherever possible. So, they are still able to achieve the required crash rating that they wanted. Either can be followed from their parent cars or also by comparing with models from other companies.
So, this is what benchmarking is for the front pillar. Now, let us move on to the center pillar or the B pillar comparison. Again, you can see there is a 7 or 8 kg difference here. But here, as you can see, the number of parts are the same. So, what is the major difference? So, in the previous slide, we saw that there are a lot of parts here for the front pillar in addition when compared to this. So, what is the difference here? So, here if you can see after the part name, you have a thickness value.
That is T2.03 and T1.4. So, the thickness here is more for every cross section or every part when compared to this. So, here the thickness is 2.3 for this part. And here it is just 1 mm. So this contributes to the higher weight of X when compared to Y. Again, it is going to be for increased strength in the center pillar to gain more crashworthiness test analysis and better RACI results. So we as design engineers now come to a conclusion based on the comparison between the models X and Y based on their weights and the number of parts.
Here you can see that X has 54 parts more than that of Y. So it's 490 and 436 here. So from this what we infer, due to the more number of parts here, the more number of parts in subassemblies are going to be stamped and hence the cost is going to be increased with also an increase in weight. But this contributes to a better CAI result and more crash rating when compared to the model Y. So that's all about benchmarking guys. See you in another one. Until then, bye.