Lesson finished
Unlock all 67 lessons of Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic LoadsFull course ₹40,000 · paid
Seismic Limit States and Earthquake-Resistant Building Virtues
A free lesson from Skill-Lync's Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic Loads course, on Grow by Skill-Lync · Last updated 16 Nov 2026 · Session: “Seismic Design Limit States in Building Structures”
What will you learn in this free Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic Loads lesson?
The instructor defines the serviceability and ultimate limit states and how building importance changes the design earthquake. He then presents the four virtues of earthquake-resistant buildings, discusses structural configuration, and explains ductility demand, force reduction in IS 1893 and capacity design.
- Serviceability versus ultimate limit state
- Higher design force for important buildings
- Configuration, stiffness, strength and ductility
- Ductility demand, supply and capacity design
What comes after lesson 3?
Later in Skill-Lync's Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic Loads course (paid): lesson 4, Seismic Design and Strength Calculation in Structural Engineering; lesson 5, Challenge: Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings; lesson 6, Analysis and Design of High-Rise Buildings Structural Dynamics and Earthquake Applications. The full course has 67 lessons (31 h 48 min of video); see the course overview or its price and syllabus.
Lesson transcript
Machine transcript of the lesson audio (lightly cleaned). Technical terms may contain errors; the video is the reference.
The next topic that we will be covering are the Seismic Design Limit States. The engineer must consider two levels of protection while designing a building structure, which broadly relates to 1. Preservation of Functionality and 2. Prevention of Loss of Life. Let us look into each of the two levels of protection. The first is the Serviceability Limit State. The five features of the Serviceability Limit State are mentioned here. It concerns with frequent earthquakes of moderate intensity. Here we are trying to deal with those earthquakes which are frequent in their occurrence and are of moderate intensity.
So the earthquake forces are lower in Serviceability Limit State. In such earthquakes, we want the buildings to continue operating normally. The normal operations of the buildings must continue. Structurally speaking, we want no damage needing repair. At most, we would want minor cracks in the building. We cannot afford more severity. Essentially, it means that we want the buildings to remain elastic. We do not want it to enter into the inelastic zone. The structure, to be able to do that, to be able to meet the Serviceability Limit State, the structure must have adequate strength and stiffness.
Now, one may ask, what about ductility? Ductility in the Serviceability Limit State does not play a role. Here we are talking purely in terms of strength and stiffness. We want displacements to be under control so that damage to the non-structural components like the brick walls, the glass panels, the glass panels can be minimized. So, considerable cracking in Serviceability Limit State may occur, but no significant yielding of reinforcement nor crushing of concrete. Also, the design earthquake considered to meet SLS or the Serviceability Limit State will vary depending on the importance of the building.
This is an important point. So, for office buildings, the Serviceability Limit State may be chosen corresponding to an earthquake with a return period of 50 years, while for a hospital building, a higher degree of protection will be required. To preserve functionality, so an earthquake with higher return period will be considered. So, in hospital buildings, to ensure building continues to remain functional even under frequent earthquakes of moderate intensity, we increase the earthquake forces by 50% in comparison to a residential building. Because in buildings of more importance, like in the case of hospitals, during earthquakes, especially earthquakes of frequent occurrence and of moderate intensity, it will be serving as a lifeline to nearby areas.
So, we cannot afford such important buildings to undergo damage which will hinder its functionality. So, we increase earthquake forces by 50% in case of, you know, more important buildings like earthquakes. The next is the Ultimate Limit State. In modern seismic design codes, very strong emphasis is placed on criteria that collapse and loss of life must be prevented, even during the strongest ground shaking feasible for the site. Under such circumstances, structure can be designed to have large lateral strength and behave rather elastically, but that will lead to significant cost.
Hence, inelastic deformations during large seismic events is to be expected. So, under the maximum probable earthquake, the Ultimate Limit State, buildings must not collapse. That is the performance objective that we have set for the building. However, extensive damage to both building structure and its contents is to be expected. This is very important. Extensive damage will happen in the building to an extent where abandoning the building completely, even demolishing it and rebuilding it later on might be required. The repair work may not be economically feasible. So, structure must be able to accommodate large inelastic displacements without loss of lateral strength and integrity of structure to support gravity load is maintained.
This is what we refer to as ductility. So, ductility plays an important role here in the Ultimate Limit State under maximum probable earthquake that we are designing the building for. At any cost, we have to prevent complete collapse and protect life. So, here we allow extensive damage to happen. So, the next topic we touch upon are the four virtues of earthquake-resistant buildings. Along with the seismic design limit states, specific structural properties need to be considered. In addition to other aspects like form, aesthetics, functionality and comfort of building, which come under the domain of an architect.
There are four other aspects of buildings that architects and design engineers work with to create the earthquake-resistant design of a building, namely structural configuration, lateral stiffness, lateral strength and ductility. All these features can be ensured by strictly following the design codes like the IS-13920 and IS-1893. We will be discussing its provisions in detail in forthcoming lectures. So, the first virtue that we talk about here is the structural configuration. By structural configuration, we simply mean the positioning of the vertical elements of the structure like the columns and the shear walls, whether they are placed towards the center, whether they are placed in the periphery, how symmetrically or asymmetrically it is distributed in plan and in elevation, where we have placed the lift core, the staircase, which are the stiff elements of the building, where have we placed these, what is the height of the floor, all these play a very important role in ensuring good earthquake performance.
And we must take note that all these features, they are also within the domain of an architect. Even an architect plays an important role in determining a good structural configuration. This is important, the more complex a structural configuration becomes, it adds further complexities in the building behavior. Number 2 is the minimum lateral stiffness in each of its plane directions. Uniformly distributed in both planned directions of the buildings, so that there is no discomfort to occupants of the building and no damage to contents of the building.
Here we are referring again to the serviceability limit state. The third point, the third virtue here is the minimum lateral strength in each of its planned directions. Again, uniformly distributed in both planned directions of the building. To resist low intensity ground shaking with no damage and not too strong to keep the cost of construction in check. And finally, a good overall ductility to accommodate the imposed lateral deformation well distributed along with the desired mode of deformation at the ultimate limit state. This ductility plays a very important role as I have already mentioned when it comes to the maximum probable earthquake that we are designing the building for.
Behavior of buildings during earthquakes depend critically on these four virtues. For no other external loadings, do all these four qualities play such an important role as in seismic design. So, in most other types of loading like wind, strength and stiffness, these two qualities, these two structural properties play a very important role. But stiffness, strength, ductility as well as structural configuration, all these four properties do not play as important a role as it plays in seismic design. So, let's look at the first virtue that we discussed, the seismic structural configuration in some more detail.
Seismic structural configuration entails three main aspects. The overall geometry of the building. By overall geometry, we mean the topology. Topology is how the structural elements are connected to one another. The shape and the size. All these three together constitutes the overall geometry of the building. The second is the location and size of the structural elements. As I have already mentioned, where we place the columns and the shear walls, how far do we place it from each other and where in plan are they located? How uniformly are they distributed in plan?
All these play a very important role in the seismic structural configuration. The third point is the location and size of significant non-structural elements. This is a misnomer actually, non-structural, when we call brick walls non-structural elements because brick walls also play a significant role in contributing to the lateral stiffness of the building. So, even its location and size play an important role in the structural configuration. This is a famous quote by a noted earthquake engineer from US, Henry Degenkolb. And he summarizes the immense importance of structural configuration in these words.
If we have a poor configuration to start with, all the engineer can do is to provide a band-aid, improve a basically poor solution as best as he can. Conversely, if we start off with a good configuration and a reasonable framing system, even a poor engineer can do it. Can't harm its ultimate performance too much. So that's why we will be dedicating two lectures purely to the conceptual design or the structural configuration of a building. And this is where collaboration between architects and engineers play a very important role. The final configuration of a building should be arrived at after mutual agreement between them.
The architect brings in perspective related to form, functionality, aesthetics, and contents, while the engineer brings the perspective of safety and desired earthquake performance during an expected earthquake. In most projects, these decisions regarding the structural configuration, unfortunately, is within the domain of an architect. This is far from an ideal arrangement and leads to technical and financial issues, especially in large projects. So this is something that as structural engineers, we must keep note of when we are working in any construction project. The inputs from a structural engineer must be taken before the shape, the overall geometry of the building is finalized. Because the shape of the floor plan, how the building is shaped, its topology, the size, the location of the staircase, the lift core, all these plays a significant role when it comes to seismic response of buildings.
To elaborate a little more on seismic structural configurations. Influence of the geometry of a building on its earthquake performance is best understood from the basic geometries of convex and concave lenses. The line joining any two points within area of the convex lens lies completely within the lens. But the same is not true for the concave lens. A part of the line may lie outside the area of concave lens, as we can see here in the bottom right diagram. Structures with convex-like geometries are preferred to those with concave-like geometries, as the former demonstrate superior earthquake performance.
In the convex-like buildings have direct load paths for transferring earthquake-induced inertia forces to their bases for any direction of ground shaking, while concave-like buildings necessitate bending of load path for shaking of the ground along certain directions that result in stress concentration at all points where the load parts bend. As we can see in the bottom left diagram that for the load to transfer from one point to another, it has to bend. It cannot find a straight and direct load path from one point to another in concave-like shapes.
This is in sharp contrast to the convex-like shapes where direct load path can be defined from one point to another. So buildings with rectangular plans and straight elevations, or regular shapes for that matter, stand the best chance of doing well during an earthquake. Because inertia forces are transferred without having to bend due to the geometry of the building, but buildings with setbacks and central openings offer geometric constraint to the flow of inertia forces. These inertia force paths have to bend before reaching the ground. Having said that, this does not mean that buildings with complex structural configurations cannot be done, but the complexity of analysis and design for such buildings requires engineers to go beyond codal provisions.
We will be discussing this aspect in more detail in forthcoming lectures. The next three virtues of an earthquake-resistant building, namely lateral stiffness, lateral strength, and ductility are shown here through the lateral deformation curve of the building. Lateral stiffness refers to the initial stiffness of the building, even though we can see here in graph A that the initial slope of the building is what we define as the stiffness. But we must note here that stiffness of the building reduces with increasing damage. So an early task in the design process will be the checking of interstory deflections, using realistic stiffness values, accounting for the cracking, to satisfy the serviceability limit state requirements of functionality.
Lateral strength refers to the maximum resistance. The graph B here, it refers to the maximum resistance that the building offers during its entire history of resistance to the relative deformation. Strength and stiffness, it must be noted, are related to each other but are not the same. Stiffness refers to change in deflection with change in lateral force, represented by the slope in the graph. Whereas strength is simply the maximum force that the structure withstands during its load deformation history. Finally, ductility can be seen here towards the lateral deformation.
It refers to the ratio of the maximum deformation and the idealized yield deformation. Out of the three properties, if there is one property that has proven to protect buildings from collapsing, it is ductility. So that is something that we must ensure. And it also must be noted the stiffness and strength are two properties that are well understood and relatively straightforward to ensure. But ductility is something that is a little more tricky. We will be spending a large proportion of our time in the course dealing with this aspect.
So here ductility, as you can see, is the ratio of the maximum deformation that the structure withstands divided by the deformation at yield. As I already mentioned, it is defined as the ratio of the total imposed deformation at any instant to that at the onset of yield. There are other ways also to define it. Number one is its ability to sustain high proportion of its initial strength when a major earthquake imposes large deformation well beyond its elastic limit. Another way of defining it is the capacity to dissipate maximum energy imparted through ground shaking.
Even that can be defined as ductility. How do we know the maximum energy imparted through ground shaking? It is basically the area of the graph defined by the lateral force on the y-axis and lateral deformation in the x-axis. So the area under the graph is essentially the maximum energy that the structure is able to dissipate under ground shaking. So this is another term that we must be aware of when designing for earthquake, the ductility demand. So as already discussed under earthquakes, design forces are generally too high to be resisted within the elastic range of material response.
Hence, it is common to design for strengths that are a fraction as low as 10-20% of strengths corresponding to elastic range. This reduction in design force comes at a cost of high ductility, which is ensured by special reinforcement detailing in certain predetermined locations. The more the design forces are reduced, the higher is the deformation demand on the structure. So on one end, there is an option of an elastically responding structure with no special detailing required and high costs. And on the other end, the option is reduced forces with special detailing required and lower costs.
IS 13920 deals specifically on ductile detailing of RC structures. The natural question one would ask is by how much can these forces be reduced? This depends as already mentioned on the material used whether we are using masonry, reinforced concrete or steel. It also depends on the structural system. Are we using flat slabs, shear walls or a basic moment resisting frame? Now IS 1893 elaborates further on the factor by which elastic design forces can be reduced for different structural systems that are commonly used. The reduction factor selected essentially sets the ductility demand on the structure.
Now the job of the engineer is to ensure that the ductility supply exceeds the ductility demand. The ductility demand that we place on the structure is directly related to how much we are reducing this force by. The higher this force is reduced, the higher is the ductility that we have to ensure. So moving on to ductility supply. So how do we ensure ductility supply exceeds ductility demand? What are the sources of ductility? These are some natural questions one might ask. So to ensure, as we had already discussed in the previous slide, to ensure sufficient ductility in a structure, we have.
wass an education sorority. Not to ensure that with the ductility of ductility. We undergo three steps which are mentioned here. Selection of a suitable structural configuration for inelastic response. We will be discussing this aspect also called the conceptual design of structures in more detail in the fourth and fifth lecture. The second step is a careful choice of location of plastic hinges where inelastic deformation shall be concentrated. And these locations have to be detailed appropriately to meet those large inelastic deformation demands. And finally, the third step, ensuring that inelastic deformation does not occur at the undesirable locations or undesirable modes of deformations are inhibited. This is done via capacity design philosophy which is basically an insurance policy. I will be elaborating more on this in the last slide.
So, the other thing that we need to keep in mind. What are those factors or properties in a structure which give rise to ductility? So, ductility is achieved firstly if the constituent materials are itself ductile. It is easy to achieve it for steel intention. So, steel intention is displaced sufficient ductility. But under compression, but under compression, but under compression, steel exhibits premature buckling. And we have to ensure that this does not interfere with achieving desired response. Similarly, for concrete, it is inherently brittle, unlike steel. Steel, as I just mentioned, steel displays ductility and tension. But concrete is inherently brittle. In isolation, it is brittle. Its tensile strength is almost negligible.
And under compression. And under compression, special precautions need to be taken to ensure it can accommodate large compressive strain. So, the good performance of steel in tension can be combined very conveniently with the good performance of concrete in compression. So, concrete and steel. So, concrete and steel are to be combined in such a way that the composite material complements each other. This art of reinforcement detailing will be considered in greater detail in the later lectures of this course. Now, besides the material itself, what are the other considerations to ensure ductility?
As I just mentioned, the structural form that are more likely to possess ductility than those that are not. We need to encourage such structural forms. And the second step that I just mentioned, the careful choice of the location of plastic hinges where inelastic deformation shall be concentrated. And then detailing these locations appropriately. And the last, the third step is also plays a very important role in ensuring ductility. where we prevent failure through undesirable modes of deformation, like the shear failure of reinforced concrete beams and columns.
And ensuring ductile response with maximum energy dissipation. This basically protects the building structure from the uncertainties of seismic activity, which is its magnitude and the duration of earthquakes. That is something which is very uncertain. So, we need some sort of an insurance policy that can protect us from these uncertainties of earthquake. And capacity design is that insurance policy.