← Previous lessonFree lesson 2 of 3 · lesson 2 of 67Next lesson →

Unlock all 67 lessons of Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic LoadsFull course ₹40,000 · paid

Price & syllabus
Free lesson · 17 min · no payment

Lessons From Earthquake Failures and Ductile Design

A free lesson from Skill-Lync's Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic Loads course, on Grow by Skill-Lync · Last updated 16 Nov 2026 · Session: “Seismic Design for Structural Engineers”

What will you learn in this free Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic Loads lesson?

This lesson lists lessons learned from past earthquakes and gives a three-step approach to achieving ductility. It then shows common failures, namely soft storey, column confinement, short column, beam-column joint and liquefaction, and compares ductile and shear behaviour using hysteresis loops.

  • Three steps to achieve ductile structures
  • Plastic hinges at beam ends and column bases
  • Soft storey and short column failure mechanisms
  • Hysteresis loops: flexure versus shear failure

What comes after lesson 2?

The next free lesson is lesson 3, “Seismic Limit States and Earthquake-Resistant Building Virtues” (24 min). Later in Skill-Lync's Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic Loads course (paid): lesson 4, Seismic Design and Strength Calculation in Structural Engineering; lesson 5, Challenge: Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings; lesson 6, Analysis and Design of High-Rise Buildings Structural Dynamics and Earthquake Applications. The full course has 67 lessons (31 h 48 min of video); see the course overview or its price and syllabus.

Lesson transcript

Machine transcript of the lesson audio (lightly cleaned). Technical terms may contain errors; the video is the reference.

The objective of seismic design is to enable structures to accommodate large deformations without significant loss in lateral strength. This can be easily explained from the graph shown earlier. As I already mentioned that this is what we desire in seismic design. We want structures to accommodate large deformations without substantial reduction of the overall resistance against horizontal and vertical loading. And this is how we define ductility. What are some of the lessons that we have learned from past earthquakes? The first lesson is that the lack of strength did not always result in failure.

And the second, which is related to the first, is that excessive strength is not essential or even necessarily desirable. Conservative design does not always work in seismic design. We need just the right amount of strength at the right locations. This is the very common myth that people have that to make structures earthquake resistant, you need to ensure adequate amount of strength in the structure. It is very much possible that the structure has a lot of strength. But if it has no ductility, if it is not able to withstand large deformations while ensuring sufficient strength without substantial reduction in the lateral strength, then it is of no ductility.

The third lesson that we have learned is that when inelastic deformation was accompanied by severe reduction in strength, severe damage or collapse was common. A common example is shear failure of reinforced concrete elements. That is an example, a classic example of an inelastic deformation. We will study more about this. We will look into more of this aspect in the later slides. The fourth lesson is that all modes of inelastic deformation are not equally viable. Some lead to failure and others provide ductility. A natural question one might ask, how do we achieve ductile structures?

There is a simple three-step process that we have to follow when we are talking about ductility in structures. By now, I hope everybody has well understood what ductility means. When we talk of ductility, we talk about accommodating large deformations in structures post-yielding without substantial reduction in the lateral strength. So the first step is selection of a suitable structural configuration for inelastic response. The third is we have to carefully choose location of plastic hinges where inelastic deformation shall be concentrated and then detailing these locations appropriately to meet the inelastic demands.

Now, this choice of location is something that we will look into in more detail. Finally, the locations, once we have decided where those plastic hinges or inelastic deformations will occur, we have to ensure that inelastic deformation does not occur at undesirable locations or by undesirable modes of deformation. This is done through the capacity design philosophy. Again, we will look into this in more detail in further slides. Now, to ensure a ductile response in probably the most simple structural system, which is the moment-resisting frame, composed of simple beams and columns, this design philosophy seeks to dissipate seismic energy primarily in well-confined beam plastic hinges and a column plastic hinge at the base of the column.

We can see here that the damage or the base of the column, we can see here that the damage or the plastic hinge formation occurs at the end of the beams and at the base of the column. The selection, this is step 2, what we mentioned in the earlier slides, the careful choice of location of plastic hinge. The selection of these plastic hinge locations will ensure that ductility is inelastic deformation, is well distributed throughout the height of the building. If we look at the base of the column, where large compressive strains exist due to combined effects of gravity and seismic loads, what is the rotational demand at its base?

It is delta or the total sway, the total sway of the building divided by the total height of the building. This is how we define the rotational ductility at the base of the column, which is shown here as theta. Now, if we compare this with the previous slide, where location of plastic hinge formation was assigned to the end of the beams. Here we have assigned to columns of a single story, as is common in soft story mechanism in ground floors. Now, again, let's look at the rotational demand at the base of the column.

Here, it is delta divided by the height of the single story. In the earlier slide, it was the height of the entire building. So, here, the concentration of deformation at the base of the column can be up to 5 to 6 times greater than when hinges form at the end of beams. One of the most common causes of failure in earthquakes is the soft story mechanism, where one level, typically the lowest, is weaker than upper levels. Since a column sway mechanism can develop with high local ductility demand, formation of plastic hinge at upper end of the ground story column leads to large concentration of deformation at few locations rather than its uniform distribution, like what we had seen in the earlier slide, where the damage or the inelastic deformation was distributed at the ends of the beam throughout the height of the building.

But if that damage occurs in the columns, like we have in the soft story mechanism, this damage is concentrated in few locations, leading to larger local ductility demand. This soft story, especially in tall buildings, this often results from a functional desire to open the lowest level to maximum extent for parking space or retail shops. Thus, the soft story mechanism can be prevented through appropriate structural configuration. This also violates the strong column weak beam design philosophy, like we can see in the diagram here. So, as engineers, whenever we come across a multi-story building by the architect, which has an open ground story, or for that matter, an open story at any level, we must design the structure such that it does not exhibit this soft story mechanism.

What we see here is a classic example of a soft story mechanism. The ground story has been kept open for functional purpose without considering the impact of this architectural feature on the story stiffness distribution along the height of the building. The lateral story stiffness of the ground floor is reduced in comparison to the upper floor. This has led to a formation of plastic hinge at upper end of ground story columns, leading to large concentration of deformations at few locations rather than its uniform distribution. The strong column weak beam design prevents this from happening.

What we see here is a weak column strong beam design. We need to ensure is a strong column weak beam design. We will learn more on how to prevent such soft story mechanism failures in upcoming lectures. This is another common failure that has been observed in past earthquakes. Confinement failure at the base of a ground story column of a 10-story building. The reason is inappropriate detailing of plastic hinge location. As we had discussed earlier, that along with the ends of the beams, large deformation also occurs at the base of the column.

So, it is extremely important that the base of the column is also appropriately detailed. What we see here is that under ductile response to earthquakes, high compression strains should be expected from combined effects of axial force and bending moment at the base of the column. Now, unless adequate, closely spaced, well-detailed transverse reinforcement is placed in the potential plastic hinge region, In the picture here, there is inadequate transverse reinforcement or what we call the shear link to confine the core concrete and restrain longitudinal reinforcement against buckling.

Again, it is to be noted that to allow weak beam and strong column design, plastic hinge must form at the base of ground story column. The result of this confinement failure is evident in the picture here. There is a complete disintegration of the core concrete within the shear link as well as we can see that the longitudinal steel here, the longitudinal steel also has buckled due to large compression forces. The spacing between the transverse reinforcements is too high to restrain this. Magnitudinal reinforcement from buckling. We will learn more about the nitty-gritties of detailing in ductile structures in the later lectures.

Another cause of failure in earthquakes, what we call the influence of partial height infill, increasing column shear force. This is called the short column effect. What we see here is consequence of ignoring the stiffening effects of so-called non-structural partial height masonry infill built hard up against the column in comparison to the other columns in the stream story. The shorter column attracts higher shear force, often with disastrous effect. In RC and masonry structures, inelastic shear deformation is accompanied with deterioration in both strength and stiffness, which could lead to failure.

In this diagram, we see that only a portion of the column has been left exposed. The designer, while designing the basement, has not taken into account that the masonry infill, which we call the non-structural walls, does not cover the full height of the basement story. We often see this in basement stories. A very small portion of the basement left open for ventilation. But what happens is that because the small story, the masonry infill wall does not extend the full height of the story, effective column height becomes very short.

And because of that, this short column attracts large shear forces and undergoes inelastic shear deformation. Flexural behavior is no longer governing this column response. It is being now governed by shear response. To explain this better, I have included this graph. Here, I have tried to illustrate why inelastic shear deformation is undesirable in reinforced concrete and masonry structures. When the structure is able to respond inelastically to the design-level earthquake without significant strength degradation, it is said to possess ductility, as we have already discussed. Perfect tactility is represented by the ideal elastic and perfectly plastic, often also called elastoplastic, shown here in terms of the lateral force and associated displacements, the extreme left diagram that we see.

The loading here is cyclical in nature, like we have in earthquakes. Diagram of this form is called the hysteresis loop. The ideal elastoplastic curve is an idealistic curve seldom achieved in reality. In reinforced concrete structures, behavior closest to this ideal situation is exhibited by formation of plastic hinge at the end of beams. As the area under the loop, which is a measure of energy dissipation, is almost 70-80% of an equivalent elastoplastic loop. However, in case of shear failure of same beam, excessive strength degradation is observed with successive loading cycle, what we see in the rightmost diagram here.

Such behavior is unsuitable for seismic resistance and must be inhibited or suppressed. What we see in this diagram, once the structure is loaded in the first cycle, the direction of the loading is reversed, and then in the second cycle, suddenly the strength and the stiffness of the structure has deteriorated considerably. This is what we see in shear deformation, as opposed to what we see in flexural deformation, like at the end of beams. What we see here is that the strength and the stiffness in successive loading cycles is maintained.

This does not disintegrate with every loading cycle. Another common cause of failure in earthquakes is the beam-column connection failure. This is a case of formation of plastic hinge at undesirable location. The joint is not supposed to become the weak link between the four components, the two beams and the two columns. Such elements are usually subjected to very high shear forces during seismic activity, and if inadequately reinforced, will result in loss in strength and stiffness, and even collapse. From the X-shaped diagonal cracks, which is a characteristic of shear failure, it is apparent that shear deformation governs in beam-column connection.

Formation of plastic hinge must occur at the end of beams, and not at the beam-column connections. Now, let us see an example of a classic brittle failure from the Mexico earthquake in 2017. Now, let's observe this building carefully. Just observe what happens in the ground story. And there it goes. Let's see this one more time. Just take note of the fact that the upper stories are intact. It is only the sudden failure of the ground story columns which leads to a complete pancake kind of failure of the entire building.

Another common cause of failure in earthquakes concerns with the geotechnical aspects, the failure in the soil. This is the bare capacity failure due to liquefaction, which was observed in the Hyogo-Ken-Nambu earthquake in 1995. Earthquakes will also often lead to damage to the foundation as a result of liquefaction of the underlying layers and the subsequent loss of bearing capacity. However, severe damage may also occur without liquefaction due to bearing capacity failure or excessive settlements. We will also look into aspects of foundation design in the last two lectures, where we will cover how to assess the liquefaction potential of underlying soil as well as its bearing capacity.

We will cover how to assess the soil. We will cover how to assess the soil. We will cover how to assess the soil. We will cover how to assess the soil. We will cover how to assess the soil. We will cover how to assess the soil.

Want the rest of Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic Loads?

Get the full course syllabus and fees.

The full course is paid (₹40,000). We'll send the syllabus and call you back within one working day.

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Full course · paid

Unlock the full Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic Loads course

The remaining 64 lessons, mentor-reviewed projects and a certificate come with the paid course (₹40,000). Leave your details: we'll send the syllabus and fees and call you back.

Get the syllabus and fees

A counsellor calls you back within one working day.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Grow by Skill-Lync · free lesson

Start watching

Free, no payment. Leave your details once and every free lesson on Grow plays straight away. A Skill-Lync counsellor may call you about the full Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic Loads course.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Talk to a career counsellor

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.