Unlock all 67 lessons of Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic LoadsFull course ₹40,000 · paid
Seismic vs Wind Design, Ductility and Structural Basics
A free lesson from Skill-Lync's Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic Loads course, on Grow by Skill-Lync · Last updated 16 Nov 2026 · Session: “Introduction to Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings Using ETABS and Foundation Design Using SAFE”
What will you learn in this free Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic Loads lesson?
The instructor outlines the course scope and the six steps a structural engineer follows, from identifying loads to checking slenderness. He then contrasts earthquake and wind loading, and explains why buildings are designed for a fraction of elastic force and must therefore be ductile.
- Six steps in a structural engineering project
- Load path from the structure to the foundation
- Earthquake versus wind force size and return period
- Why ductility is the cost of reduced design force
What comes after lesson 1?
The next free lesson is lesson 2, “Lessons From Earthquake Failures and Ductile Design” (17 min). Later in Skill-Lync's Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings using ETABS and Foundation Design using SAFE for Seismic Loads course (paid): lesson 4, Seismic Design and Strength Calculation in Structural Engineering; lesson 5, Challenge: Analysis and Design of High Rise Buildings; lesson 6, Analysis and Design of High-Rise Buildings Structural Dynamics and Earthquake Applications. The full course has 67 lessons (31 h 48 min of video); see the course overview or its price and syllabus.
Lesson transcript
Machine transcript of the lesson audio (lightly cleaned). Technical terms may contain errors; the video is the reference.
A very warm welcome all attending this course. This is the first lecture in a 12 lecture series on the topic Analysis and Design of High-Rise Buildings Using A-Tabs and Foundation Design Using SAFE for Seismic Forces. I will start with the course introduction. The objective of this course is to give students an understanding of the analysis and design of building structures under seismic forces. Students are expected to have a good understanding of subjects like structural analysis and reinforced concrete design. Since most buildings built in India are made of reinforced concrete, the dominant set of examples used here is of reinforced concrete buildings.
But with no loss of generality, the broad concepts discussed in this course are valid for both RC and steel buildings. Also, the discussion is limited to normal buildings without any special devices like base isolation and other energy-absorbing or dissipating devices. Also, specialized systems like post-tensioning slab system are not in focus. The focus will be on imparting job-oriented skills and knowledge rather than pure theory. Emphasis will be on designing code-compliant structures and use of commonly used softwares in consultancy offices. Moving on to the lecture content. The first lecture in this 12 lecture series is an overview of seismic design.
We will first discuss some basics on what is a structure, functions of a structure and the role of a structural engineer. Then we will go on to see the steps in any typical structural engineering projects. Then what is the fundamental difference between designing a structure for earthquakes as opposed to designing for wind loads, which are two of the most common lateral loads applied on structures. What we have learned from some of the past earthquakes will also be discussed in terms of the structural response and some common causes of failures.
Most of what we know about seismic design today is based on studies, on post-reconnaissance studies of some of the buildings that have collapsed in past earthquakes. So we will look at the role ductility plays in earthquake-resistant structures. How can we achieve ductile structures as opposed to brittle ones? This desire for ductility will require us to explore the capacity design philosophy, which in many ways has today become the bedrock on which seismic design codes are based. So to the most fundamental question, what is a structure? Now people are surrounded by natural and design structures.
They live in them, travel in them, eat with them, sleep on them. They contribute to almost every aspect of our lives. Indeed, humans, animals and plants are themselves structures. But few people give much thought to structures until they fail. Forks bend, classes break, cars are wrecked in crashes. Less often, buildings and bridges also collapse. These structural failures always cause inconveniences that may be minor, such as a broken glass or major, involving loss of life and large financial costs such as the collapse of a bridge. So what is the function of a structure?
Anything that transfers load from one place to another can be called a structure. A simple example illustrates this. If people want to cross a stream, then a plank could be used as a bridge. Whilst people are on the bridge, their weight is transferred from a point over the water to points on the banks. The purpose of the plank is to transfer the load to the support. The plank does this by acting as a structure. This load transferring function is the main purpose of all structures, whether it is a chair or a railway bridge.
Role of structural engineers The role of structural engineers can be categorized in six steps. These are the six steps that every structural engineer has to go through in any typical structural engineering project. The first step is identifying loads that a structure could be exposed to during its lifespan. According to convention, it is 50 years for buildings and about 100 years for bridges. The source of loads on building is a combination of dead or permanent loads. For instance, the self-weight of the materials used, like concrete, steel, bricks, etc.
Then there are the live loads, which are not always present, usually consist of people occupying it. And finally, the lateral loads, acting horizontally on the structure, like wind, earthquake, etc. The second step is carving out a load path. Each load on a building structure is eventually transferred to the foundation of the building and finally to the soil underneath the building. The sequence of structural elements that join a specific load to its foundations is called the load path. The engineer's job is to carve out the most cost-efficient load path while ensuring safety.
This is one of the most important steps in structural engineering when it comes to cost-efficiency and safety. This step can also be called finding order in chaos. The third step is calculating the approximate forces in each of the structural elements. Now, the structure transfers loads by forces that exist within each element in the load path and by forces between the elements, like the connections, where they meet. The force in an element can be considered to be a combination of a force along the element, axial force, a force across the element, the shear force, and a force bending the element, which is the bending moment, and sometimes the force twisting the element, which is torsion.
The modern approach using computer programs finds numerical values for these forces, which we call the structural analysis, and then checks if each element can support these forces, which we call the structural design, and so verify that a proposed structure is satisfactory. The fifth step is checking if the structure has overall stability. When people amuse themselves by building towers of children's bricks or playing cards, they build the towers higher and higher until it collapses, like a pack of cards. This loss of overall stability can occur in a number of ways in building structures, and clearly they must be avoided.
Finally, we need to check if any of the elements in the entire structure is too slender. If a column is short and fat, increasing the load on it will eventually cause it to squash. But if the column is long and thin, it will buckle at a load far lower than the squash load. For a structure to be satisfactory, slender elements must be identified in any load path to ensure that they will not buckle in some way. Now coming to the topic in hand, response of buildings when subjected to earthquakes.
This course will focus on earthquake-resistant design of reinforced concrete buildings. Earthquakes are caused by sudden internal movements within the earth's crust. This results in shaking the crust of the earth over a certain area. The earth's surface will both bounce up and down and move backwards and forwards. In general, the vertical movement is small compared with the horizontal movement. A building during an earthquake undergoes an experience similar to a person standing in a metrotame that accelerates and de-accelerates continuously. Again, it is not obvious where or what the load is, but the effect as far as the building or the person is concerned is the same as being pushed horizontally to and fro with the foundations or the feet in this case, kept still, the building undergoes a very similar experience when subjected to ground shaking.
One may ask how is seismic design different from wind design? There are several differences, but the most important is that there are two most important differences. Number one, that the magnitude of the two forces are considerably different. Wind forces are usually taken to be around 2-3% of the building weight applied laterally, whereas earthquake forces on the building can go up to 15-20%. The second very important difference that we need to note is the frequency of occurrence of the two events. The maximum probable earthquake that the structure is designed for is expected to occur once in 2,500 years, which is a very, very rare event, whereas the design wind conditions is a more frequent event, which is once in 50 years.
Now, these two differences has large implications in seismic design philosophy. We will see how. So, one of the most important difference in seismic design as compared to wind design is that due to the large magnitude of earthquake forces, if the structure is designed to behave elastically, just like under wind forces, it will lead to large member size, which will be impractical and uneconomical. It will lead to very large column sizes and beam sizes, which we will make it architecturally, the building will no longer be functional.
This requires us to tap into the inelastic zone. In simple language, we mean, this basically means the structure will undergo damage when subjected to earthquake. We'll see you next week. We want to tap into the unutilized, inelastic potential of the structure. Why do we allow damage in earthquake events? The answer lies in the second reason mentioned in the previous slide. Because earthquakes are a rare event, we do not want to design an expensive structure to behave elastically to an earthquake. That probably might never occur during the lifespan of the building, while at the same time neglect its risks completely.
We take a middle path. We allow for some damage, or what we call inelastic response, while ensuring that the building does not undergo total collapse. We can see it in the graph here, that for designing for wind, we restrict the response of the structure up to its elastic limit. But under earthquake events, we expect the structure to undergo damage. We expect the structure to undergo non-linear behavior, which is beyond the elastic range. Now, under earthquakes, design forces are generally too high to be resisted within the elastic range of material response.
Hence, it is common to design for strengths that are a fraction of, you know, as low as 20%. They are a fraction of the strengths corresponding to the elastic range. The idea is to shift focus from resisting large seismic forces to evasion of forces through maximum possible energy dissipation. Understanding this curve is critical to understanding the basics of seismic design, and how it differs from designing for other forces. In the first curve, the structure is responding to the earthquake force elastically. Basically, this force can go up to as high as the self-weight of the building.
Imagine applying force equal to our own weight laterally to push us over. It is massive for any building or any structure for that matter. Therefore, to resist these large forces, buildings will require very large column and beam sizes. That will be impractical. Hence, the alternative, a more viable alternative, is to utilize the untapped inelastic strength of the building, which will allow us to reduce the strength of the building and reduce its beam and column sizes. This can be seen in the second curve. What we have done here is we have designed the structure for a far less amount of earthquake force that the structure would have experienced if it was behaving elastically.
The structure is designed for a fraction of the strength corresponding to that of elastic range. The important thing to remember here is that this reduction in strength comes at a cost. That cost is ductility. It is important to ensure structure exhibits ductility under large earthquakes, which basically means it must be able to sustain large deformation without substantial reduction in its strength against vertical and horizontal loading. This can be seen in the curve here. We can see that although we have designed this structure for a far lesser amount of force, but this has come at a cost of high deformation in the building, high inelastic deformation as compared to the initial structure where the deformation was far less.
So, if this reduction in design force is taken advantage of, as designers, we also need to ensure that structure is able to withstand large deformation without undergoing substantial reduction in its strength. We can see here that the structure maintains its strength even after post yielding, post going into the inelastic zone. Now, there are three different structures with different modes of inelastic deformation in this diagram. Which one is desirable? I think the answer is quite obvious. Allowing structures to undergo inelastic deformation creates another issue for engineers.
The issue of brittle failure. Brittle failure implies near complete loss of resistance and the absence of adequate warning before collapse. We want to avoid such undesirable modes of failures and ensure ductile behavior of structures when subjected to earthquakes. The rest of the course will explain how that is to be done. In the diagram that we see here, we can see that the largest curve is the one which is the most desirable. Because here we can see that post it enters into the inelastic zone, post yielding of the structure, we see that the structure more or less maintains its strength while undergoing large deformation.
There is no sudden drop in its strength, which we see in this structure. There is a sudden drop in strength. This is undesirable and this is something which we have to prevent. It looks just like a bunch of hand in theон primate. That's all right. 나 this point.