Unlock all 25 lessons of Design loads considered on bridgesFull course ₹40,000 · paid
Moment Distribution Method with STAAD Pro Verification
A free lesson from Skill-Lync's Design loads considered on bridges course, on Grow by Skill-Lync · Last updated 16 Nov 2026 · Session: “Week 1 Session 2”
What will you learn in this free Design loads considered on bridges lesson?
Explains Hardy Cross's moment distribution method for indeterminate beams. Works a two-span box girder with a UDL through fixed end moments, balancing and carry-over moments, then compares the results with a STAAD Pro analysis.
- Fixed end moments and joint release steps
- Distribution factors, balancing and carry-over moments
- Two-span beam example with 90 kN/m UDL
- Comparing hand results with STAAD Pro output
What comes after lesson 2?
The next free lesson is lesson 3, “Bridge Live Loads: IRC Class A, 70R and Influence Lines” (34 min). Later in Skill-Lync's Design loads considered on bridges course (paid): lesson 4, Part 2; lesson 5, Part 3; lesson 6, Week 3 Session 1. The full course has 25 lessons (10 h 3 min of video); see the course overview or its price and syllabus.
Lesson transcript
Machine transcript of the lesson audio (lightly cleaned). Technical terms may contain errors; the video is the reference.
Hello and welcome to the next session and in this session we'll be talking about the movement distribution method and then we will do a stat demonstration of the movement distribution method. We'll compare the results obtained from movement distribution method with those obtained from this stat analysis and we'll see how those two analysis compare with each other. So let's get started first with the movement distribution method. So movement distribution method was created by Hardy Cross. He created the movement distribution method for structural analysis of statically indeterminate beams and frames.
To create the fixed end moments in this method, every joint of the structure which is being analyzed is first of all assumed to be fixed. Then one by one each fixed joint is released and the fixed end moments which are not in equilibrium at the time of release are transferred to the adjacent members until an equilibrium is reached in the structure. The movement distribution approach can be described mathematically as the process of solving a set of simultaneous equations by continuous iterative process. So let us look at it with the help of a design example. What you see here is a box girder beam and it is a two span beam with span lengths of 10 meter and 7 meters and a UDL of 90 kN per meter applied onto this beam.
Let's see how we do the analysis of this kind of indeterminate structures by a movement distribution method. So first and foremost, the movement distribution method of analysis for the calculated dead loads requires that we obtain the fixed end moments. So for an element which is fixed on both the ends and a UDL of W kN per meter is applied, the fixed end moments are given as WL square by 12 where L is the span of this element which is shown by this arrow. So here W is 90 kN per meter. For a span AB, the fixed end moment WL square by 12 comes out to be 90 multiplied by 10 multiplied by 10 divided by 12 because span AB is 10 meters in length.
So this value comes out to be 750 kN per meter. For a span BC which has a span of 7 meters, the corresponding fixed end moments is calculated as 367.5 kN per meter. Now once we have calculated the fixed end moments, the next step is to calculate the distribution factor. So this distribution factor is calculated at each of the joints and we calculate the stiffness of all the members which are connected to a particular joint. And then distribution factor of individual members which are connected on the joint are obtained as stiffness of that number divided by the total stiffness at that joint, which is the summation of stiffnesses of all the members which are connected at that joint.
So for joint A, we have only one member which is member AB. For that, we will say that we have number of connections as 1 and stiffness of member AB will be EI by L1. So L1 is the span of member AB which is 10 meters and the stiffness comes out to be EI by 10. Distribution factors for member AB comes out to be stiffness of member AB divided by total stiffness at joint A. Since there is only one member, therefore the total stiffness is equal to the stiffness of the member AB and therefore the distribution factor comes out to be 1.
For joint B, we have two members. We look at this figure. For joint B, we have two members which is member BA and member BC which are connected at this particular joint. So we will calculate the stiffnesses, the flexural stiffnesses of element BA and element BC and then we will calculate the distribution factors corresponding to element BA and element BC. So let us quickly look at that calculation. Stiffness of member BA is EI by L1 which is EI by 10 because length of BA is 10 meters and for stiffness of the other member, so the stiffness of member BC, we have EI by L2 and the length of BC is 7 meters.
Therefore, stiffness of member BC comes out to be EI by 7. So the total stiffness of both the members at this joint is the summation of stiffness of member BA and stiffness of member BC which is EI by 10 plus EI by 7 and the value comes out to be 17 by 70 E into I. Now, once we have obtained the individual stiffnesses, let us calculate the distribution factor for member BA which will be stiffness of member BA divided by total stiffness at joint B and which will be equal to EI by 10 divided by 17 by 70 EI and it comes out to be equal to 0.41.
Similarly, distribution factor for member BC comes out to be stiffness of member BC divided by total stiffness of joint B. Total stiffness of joint B, this C is incorrectly marked, it should be joint B. So distribution factor of member BC, stiffness of member BC divided by total stiffness at joint B which is equal to EI by 7 divided by 17 by 70 EI and it comes out to be 0.59. You will notice that the summation of distribution factors of individual members comes out to be equal to 1.41 plus 0.59 comes out to be equal to 1.
For joint C, let us calculate the distribution factor now. At joint C, we have only one member which is member CB and therefore the number of connections is only 1. Stiffness of member CB is EI by L2 where the length of member CB is L2 and it is 7 meters. The total stiffness comes out to be EI by 7. Distribution factor for member CB comes out to be stiffness of member CB divided by total stiffness at joint C which is EI by 7 divided by EI by 7 and it comes out to be equal to 1.
Now, once we have calculated the stiffness factors and corresponding distribution factors at the joints, we will formulate a table wherein we will put the joint numbers, the member numbers and the corresponding distribution factors DF and the fixed end moments FEM. And then these FEM will be distributed at between all the joints through the members to obtain a state of equilibrium. So, at joint A, we have only member AB. At joint B, we have member BA and BC. And at joint C, we have member CB, right?
And the distribution factors as we have seen at joint A for member AB, the distribution factor is 1. At joint B for member BA, the distribution factor is 0.41. For member BC, the distribution factor is 0.59 and for member CB, the distribution factor is. Now, the fixed end moments for element AB, we have seen it is equal to 750 kNm and for element BC, it is 367.5 kNm. One important thing to note here is that at element AB, we have put the value of FEM as minus 750 and at BA, we have put the value as plus 750.
So, here, if you see, if this fixed end moment is anticlockwise in nature, the sign is taken as negative. And if it is clockwise in nature, the sign is taken as positive. So, the same thing is reflected here in this table as well. Now, once we have put these values of fixed end moments, we will start distributing these moments. So, at joint A, since actually it is a simply supported joint, as you see in this figure, there will be no net moment at this joint. So, we will first and foremost release this joint A to its actual condition.
And the actual condition of release is that it cannot resist or accumulate any bending moment at this joint because it is a simply supported joint. And for that reason, we are releasing this fixed end moment of minus 750 by putting a value of plus 750 against this. Therefore, the sum of this minus 750 and 750 becomes 0 and this moment is completely balanced. But once we apply this balancing moment of 750, it has to be distributed also through the member AB onto the next joint, which is the joint B.
So, the moment that is carried forward from a member to another joint is equal to half of the releasing moment that is applied. So, since we are applying a balancing moment of 750 here, half of that value, which is 375, will be transferred over or carried over to the joint B through the member AB. And that has been put here and shown as an arrow. Similarly, you see here at joint C also, we have a clockwise fixed end moment of 367.5. And since joint C is also a simply supported joint, a balancing moment of minus 367.5 is put here.
And since we are putting a balancing moment of minus 365, half of this moment will be carried over from the element CB to the joint B. And that value will be minus 183.75, which is shown here. So, these are the carried over moments, which we are marking as CO. So, we have this carried over moment and this carried over moment here from joint A and joint C. Now, coming to joint B. At joint B, we have fixed end moments of plus 750 and minus 367.5. Plus 750 is for the member BA and minus 367.5 is for the member B.
If you take a sum of these values, we get a value of 382.5. 750 minus 367.5 is 382.5. Now, this is the unbalanced moment at joint B. To balance this moment, we will have to apply a negative moment of 382.5. And that negative moment applied at joint B will get distributed through the members AB and BC to the nearby joints A and joint C. Therefore, this 382.5 negative 382.5 moment that is applied as a balancing moment here, it will be distributed in the ratio of the distribution factors through these elements AB and BC.
So, if we multiply minus 382.5 by 0.41, we obtain a value of minus 156.825 which is distributed through the member BA onto the node A and 382.5 multiplied by 0.59 gives us a value of 225.675. And that negative moment is mentioned here as minus 225.675. Now, these two moments which are applied as balancing moments on joint B will get transferred to the nearby joints. The elements joints A and joint C. So half of these values will be transferred. So 156.825 half of minus 156.825 is minus 78.412 and half of 750 is 375. Similarly half of minus 367.5 is minus 183.75 and minus 225.67 is minus 112.837. So these are the carried over movements from these balancing movements which are obtained.
Now these carried over movements will have to be balanced again by the same iteration that we have performed to balance the fixed end movements and then we had carried over these movements. So these carried over movements now need to be balanced. So at joint A we have a carry over movement of minus 78.412 and that carried over movement will have to be balanced by applying a movement of 78.412. Since this moment is being applied half of that will be again carried over to the joint B and a similar process will follow a similar cycle of calculations will follow and we will obtain these values again.
We will again balance these carried over movements which are shown in the line below these values and we will again obtain some carry over movement. So this process is carried on till the time we have no balancing movements left or rather we don't have any carried forwarded movements which needs to be balanced further. So you see these values are now slowly decreasing as we move forward with our iterations at all these joints. So you see here these values are continuously decreasing and we can stop these iterations when these balancing movements become numerically insignificant.
So you see here these continuously we are performing these iterations and transferring these values and these values are shown for your understanding but these are all numerically insignificant now because these are very small values. And once we are getting the balancing movement as very very small we can decide to stop the iterations and then we will do a summation of all the movements in these columns. And then we do the summation we get the total as 0 which should have been the value at moment of value of moment at A because it is a simply supported joint.
Similarly at point C also we get a value of 0. Summing up all the values in the column BA we get a moment of 889.7 and in BC we get a moment of minus 889.7. So these are the moments at joint B which are obtained by the final analysis. So the total this row signifies the final values that we are getting from this moment distribution method. So I hope this method is clear to you. It is nothing but continuously carrying forward the unbalanced moments balancing them again and then doing it in a iterative manner till we obtain the final results and the balancing movements becomes numerically insignificant.
So we can stop the iterations there. Now this means that the final moments are as follows. Moment AB is 0. Moment BA is 889.7. Moment BC is minus 889.7. And moment adjoint C which is MCV is equal to 0. Let us now do this same analysis in StackPro and try to find out the results that we obtained from software for the same values of the loading for this beam. So let us create a new model StackPro and we can name it as model 1. So here we have the Stack software.
Let us quickly see how we can model this 2-span beam in this software. So in Stack we first of all need to define the nodes and once we have defined the nodes we can join those nodes by elements, numbers. We can assign some properties to those elements and then the loadings and the support conditions. So one by one first and foremost let us model the beam in the x direction. So the first node will be at 0, 0, 0 and the second node will be at 10 meters because the span AB is 10 meters and the third node will be at 17 meters from first node because the span BC is 7 meters.
Span AB is 10 meters so 10 plus 7 comes out to be equal to 17. So these are the three nodes that we create. In our model in our model in the x direction. Now let us join these members by adding the beams. So let us now add the beams between these nodes 1, 2 and 3. So we see here the three nodes and these three nodes are at distances of 10 meters and 17 meters. And now they have been connected by the beam elements. Once they are connected by the beam elements we can move ahead to assign simply supported properties to these three nodes.
Node number 1, node number 2 and node number 3. And after that we can apply the loading of 90 kilonewton per running meter on this beam. Once we have applied this loading of 90 kilonewton per meters on this beam. We are ready for the analysis of this beam. As far as the section properties are concerned we have assigned it a property of a rectangle 7.87 by 7.87 meters. This would have been some other property also as per the actual beam that we are analyzing. So now we have this model ready for the analysis we can go ahead with analysis of this model and once the analysis is complete we will have the results of this continuous beam type structure under a UDL of 90 kilonewton per meter.
So we will now run the analysis to obtain the results of this analysis we have only one load case and what we see here is the deflection what we want to see is the bending moment which we get in the Z direction. The bending moment along the Z axis is shown here. We can display the results by annotating the beam results at the ends and at the midpoints also. So when we do that we obtain the moment at point 1 and 2 as 0 because this is a simply supported joint with only one member.
And at the middle we obtain a moment of 888.401 kilonewton meters. Now this is the bending moment at the middle support which we obtain from this Z analysis. If we compare this value with the moment distribution results we realize that this value is in close agreement to the design moment value which we had obtained from the moment distribution method. In the moment distribution method we had obtained a value of approximately 889.7 and from this third analysis we are getting a value of 888. So these values of 888 kilonewton per meter and 889 kilonewton meters obtained from the two analysis are very closely matching.
Now one may ask why is there even a slight difference between these values. So we must remember that in the moment distribution method we had chosen to terminate the iterations when the balancing moment was still 0.005. So this moment of 0.005 even if numerically insignificant it has still not been balanced. So if we had continued these iterations we would have probably obtained the same results as the STAD analysis. But nevertheless these results are very very closely matching which proves the accuracy of the moment distribution method.
And it shows that it compares very well with our STAD analysis. So the STAD results are also comparable. So to summarize the moment distribution method gives us a way to calculate the design moments for external loadings in a indeterminate structure. We saw how we calculate the values, the steps of the moment distribution method, the carryover factors, the moment distribution factors at the joint, the balancing moments as well as the iterations in a moment distribution method to obtain at the final moments at all the joints of the moment.
Now we have taken a case of 2-span continuous beam. It could well have been a 3-span beam or a 4-span beam also. And the method would have worked fine for those indeterminate structures also such that the number of iterations would have increased if we choose to do the calculations by moment distribution method. So to save our time we are using analysis software STAAD.Pro to get quick results for this analysis. So as students of structural engineering who are trying to understand the design loads considered on bridges, it is important for us to know the design procedure in terms of calculating the moments, analyzing those moments by hand calculations, which is the moment distribution method, and then how those values compare with the software results.
We have seen both those values and with this discussion we are now ready to move ahead to discuss the next loads which are the Live loads on the bridges. We'll be taking up a discussion on the live loads of the bridges in our next session. I hope this discussion on dead loads of structural elements of the bridges has clarified your concepts of calculating these dead loads, the procedure for calculating these dead loads, and how to simulate the loadings in a software and obtain the final design moments.
So to summarize, in this week, we learned about the unit weight of materials, the self-weight of structural elements. We'll be looking at a solid example wherein we will calculate the self-weight of superstructure and the self-weight of substructure. We will be looking at moment distribution method, how to calculate the design moments on a beam with the moment distribution method, and we will also do a software demonstration on StatPro to verify the results obtained by the moment distribution method. Thank you.