
Design for Manufacturing and Assembly
Cut a desk fan's parts and screws step by step, find a casting's hot spots, size a snap fit and see what a tolerance really costs
25 chapters, 25 interactives, few words. Every chapter is mapped to the Anna University, VTU, SPPU, Mumbai University and KTU units it covers: the DFMA method and its history, material selection, process capability and tolerance cost, assembly limits, design features for drilling and milling, machined area, set-ups and accessibility, turned and milled parts, machining cost, casting form design, parting lines and cores, injection moulding and die casting, welded members and forgings, the Boothroyd-Dewhurst DFA worksheet, handling and insertion times, snap fits and fasteners, automatic and robotic assembly, design for additive manufacturing, part consolidation, design for the environment and disassembly, value engineering, product development economics and reliability. One illustrative desk fan runs through the assembly chapters, so every saving is computed on the same product.
- AUCME391Design for Manufacturing
- VTUBME613DDesign for Manufacturing and Assembly
- SPPU402045AProduct Design and Development
- MUMELO8062Design for X
- KTUPEMET522Design for Manufacture and Assembly
By Skill-Lync · Updated 21 Nov 2026 · 25 chapters · 25 interactives · free, no sign-up
What DFMA is: history, the design process and the rules for economical production
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IVTU BME613D Module 1SPPU 402045A Unit 4MU MELO8062 Module 1KTU PEMET522 Module 1
Where did DFMA come from?
Designers collected assembly rules through the 1960s and 70s, but numbers came later. Hitachi's Assembly Evaluation Method was the first scoring system. From 1977 Geoffrey Boothroyd, with a US National Science Foundation grant at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, measured how long people take to grasp, orient and insert parts and turned it into time tables plus three questions that decide whether a part needs to exist. From 1981 he and Peter Dewhurst put the method into software. In 1988 Ford credited that software with savings approaching one billion US dollars.
What does DFMA do to a real product?
Take the book's desk-fan motor pod: 21 parts, 8 of them screws, and two turn-overs so the screws can be driven. The assembly worksheet gives 150.75 s of manual work, and only 8 parts pass the three questions, so the design efficiency is 15.9 %. Seven moves (snap fits, moulded ribs, slots, a cable labyrinth) bring it to 8 parts and 42.01 s, efficiency 57.1 %. At an assumed ₹250/h labour falls from ₹10.47 to ₹2.92 a fan.
How is DFMA applied, and what are the rules for economical production?
First DFA: simplify the structure and challenge every part with the three questions. Then DFM: pick the material and process for each part that remains and estimate its cost, and iterate while the design is still cheap to change, with manufacturing at the table (concurrent engineering). The rules: fewer parts, standard parts, the widest tolerance that works, features that suit the process, few set-ups, top-down assembly. In Boothroyd's power-saw study the redesign went from 41 to 29 parts (29 % fewer) and from 6.37 to 2.58 min of assembly (59 % less).
If it saves money, why do companies skip it?
The usual reasons: no time in the schedule, a belief that assembly is too small a share of cost to matter, designers measured on function rather than cost, and the analysis tools and training cost money. The belief misses where the money is. Daniel Whitney's MIT notes quote crude cost splits such as 90 % parts and 5 % labour for VCRs, so the prize is fewer parts to buy, stock and check, not faster hands. The same notes put assembly efficiency between 5 % for clumsy designs and 30 % for good ones.
Which single move saves the most assembly time on the fan?
Snap-fit housings remove 3 screws, their tool pick-up and both turn-overs: 30 s of 150.75 s. Moulded ribs save 22.06 s (a bracket and 2 screws); the D-flat blade saves 9.33 s. Screws cost far more than the parts they hold, because each one needs a tool and a careful start.
Worked examples
Where the original fan's assembly time goes · The original pod's worksheet: 21 parts, 150.75 s. Screws: handling code 11 (1.8 s), power-tool insertion code 30 (3.6 s), 2.9 s tool pick-up per row; turn-over 61 (4.5 s)
- Screws: 4 rows × 2.9 s + 8 screws × (1.8 + 3.6) s = 11.6 + 43.2 = 54.8 s
- Two turn-overs to reach the housing screws: 2 × 4.5 = 9 s
- Blade nut 9.63 s (with its tool) and guard clip ring 5.75 s
- Fastening total = 79.18 s, which is 52.5 % of 150.75 s
- None of these items passes the three questions: they only hold other parts
Answer: 79.2 s (53 %) is spent on fasteners and turn-overs
Efficiency and labour before and after · Original: TM = 150.75 s; redesign: TM = 42.01 s; Nmin = 8 in both; assumed labour ₹250/h; 1,00,000 fans a year
- E before = 3 × 8/150.75 = 15.9 %
- E after = 3 × 8/42.01 = 57.1 %
- Labour before = 150.75/3600 × 250 = ₹10.47; after = ₹2.92
- Saving per year = (10.47 − 2.92) × 1,00,000 = ₹7,55,139
Answer: E rises from 15.9 % to 57.1 %; labour saves about ₹7.55 lakh a year
Check move 1 by hand · Move 1 replaces the 3 housing screws with snap fits. The front housing's insertion changes from code 03 (5.2 s, held down, not easy to align) to code 05 (3.3 s, snap fit, not easy to align)
- Screw row removed: 2.9 + 3 × 5.4 = 19.1 s
- Turn-overs removed: 9 s
- Front housing: 5.2 − 3.3 = 1.9 s saved
- Total = 19.1 + 9 + 1.9 = 30 s, so TM goes from 150.75 to 120.75 s
- Parts 21 → 18; E = 3 × 8/120.75 = 19.9 %
Answer: 30 s saved; E 15.9 % → 19.9 %
Selecting materials for manufacture: criteria, the weighted property and digital logic methods
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IIVTU BME613D Module 1SPPU not in syllabusMU not in syllabusKTU PEMET522 Module 1
What decides the material of a part?
Four groups of questions. Function: strength, stiffness, mass, and service conditions such as corrosion and temperature. Processability: can it be cast, forged, machined or moulded at this volume and shape? Cost: the material plus the processing it forces. Availability: standard bar and sheet sizes, local supply, lead time. Screen first with go/no-go limits, then rank the survivors. The five metals in this chapter span 207 MPa (annealed 304 stainless) to 880 MPa (Ti-6Al-4V) in yield strength. Ashby property charts, in the Engineering Materials book, help with the screening.
How does the weighted property method rank candidates?
Scale each property 0-100 over the candidates: 100 × value/best for higher-is-better properties, 100 × best/value for density and cost. Multiply by the property's weight and add. For the bicycle crank, with weights from the digital logic table, 6061-T6 scores 72.7 and 7075-T6 68: a margin of only 4.6. Small margins are common, and they mean the weights decide the answer, so test them before you trust the winner.
How does the digital logic method set the weights?
Compare the properties two at a time and write 1 for the more important one, 0 for the other. Five properties give 10 decisions, and each weight is that property's 1s divided by 10. For the crank, density wins 4 comparisons (weight 0.4), strength 3, cost 2, stiffness 1 and corrosion none, so corrosion gets a weight of zero. That is the method's known flaw: last place counts as worthless. Counting a tie as half a point to each side is one simple fix.
Why compare cost per unit property, not per kilogram?
Because a part needs a stiffness or a strength, not a mass. A 1 m tie that may stretch only 0.5 mm under 10 kN needs an area of F·L/(E·δ): in steel 100 mm², 0.79 kg, ₹118 at the assumed price. Per kilogram titanium is 30 times dearer than steel; per unit of stiffness, 33 times; per unit of strength (a tie sized by yield) only 9.3 times. The right ratio depends on what limits the part.
In a digital logic table of five properties, one property loses all four of its comparisons. What weight does it get?
Its weight is its winning decisions divided by the 10 decisions, 0/10 = 0. The property then has no effect on the ranking at all, even if it still matters a little, which is why some designers count ties or use a finer score.
Worked examples
Weights for the pump shaft by digital logic · Properties: strength S, stiffness E, density ρ, cost C, corrosion K. Decisions (winner first): E over S; S over ρ, C; E over ρ, C, K; K over S, ρ, C; C over ρ
- 10 decisions in all (5 × 4/2)
- Wins: S 2, E 4, ρ 0, C 1, K 3; total 10
- Weights = wins/10: S 0.2, E 0.4, ρ 0, C 0.1, K 0.3
- Density gets zero: a pump shaft's mass hardly matters
Answer: α = 0.2, 0.4, 0, 0.1, 0.3; winner 304 stainless (γ 77)
Score 6061-T6 for the crank · Candidates' best values: yield 880 MPa (Ti), E 200 GPa (steel), density 2700 kg/m³ (6061), cost ₹945 per litre (6061: ₹350/kg × 2.7 kg/L), corrosion 5. 6061-T6: 270 MPa, 69 GPa, 2700, ₹945/L, 4. Weights 0.3, 0.1, 0.4, 0.2, 0
- β strength = 100 × 270/880 = 30.68
- β stiffness = 100 × 69/200 = 34.5
- β density = 100 × 2700/2700 = 100; β cost = 100 × 945/945 = 100; β corrosion = 100 × 4/5 = 80
- γ = 0.3 × 30.68 + 0.1 × 34.5 + 0.4 × 100 + 0.2 × 100 + 0 × 80 = 72.65
- 7075-T6 by the same steps scores 68.02
Answer: γ = 72.7, ahead of 7075-T6 by 4.6
Cheapest material for a stiff tie · A 1 m tension tie carries 10 kN and may stretch 0.5 mm. Assumed prices: steel ₹150/kg, 6061 ₹350/kg, Ti-6Al-4V ₹4,500/kg
- Required area A = F·L/(E·δ); mass = ρ·A·L; cost = mass × ₹/kg
- 4130 steel: A = 10,000 × 1/(200 × 10⁹ × 0.0005) = 100 mm²; mass 0.785 kg; ₹117.8
- 6061-T6: A = 289.9 mm²; mass 0.783 kg; ₹273.9
- Ti-6Al-4V: A = 192.3 mm²; mass 0.852 kg; ₹3834
- Stress check: steel 100 MPa, 6061 34 MPa, far below yield, so stiffness governs
Answer: Steel, at about ₹118; 6061 weighs about the same (0.78 kg) and costs ₹274
Process capability and the cost of a tolerance
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IVTU BME613D Module 1SPPU 402045A Unit 4MU MELO8062 Module 1KTU PEMET522 Module 1
What is an IT grade?
ISO 286 gives each size range a ladder of standard tolerances, IT01 (finest) to IT18. On a 25 mm diameter IT7 is 21 µm and IT11 is 130 µm; every five grades the tolerance grows tenfold. The table came from a formula: a tolerance unit i, which grows roughly with the cube root of size, times a multiplier, 16 for IT7. For the 18-30 mm range (geometric mean 23.24 mm) i = 1.307 µm and 16i = 20.9 µm, rounded to 21. A drawing tolerance can be read as a grade, and a grade tells you which processes can hold it.
Which process can hold a given tolerance?
Each process holds a band of grades under normal conditions: lapping and honing IT4-5, cylindrical grinding 5-7, reaming 6-10, turning 7-13, boring 8-13, milling and drilling 10-13 (Engineering ToolBox; Wevolver gives surface grinding 5-6 and broaching 5-7 where ToolBox says 5-8). A 25 µm tolerance on Ø25 is IT7: 7 of the 10 processes can hold it, and turning is the least precise one that still works. Castings and forgings are graded separately, by ISO 8062's CT1-CT16.
What do Cp and Cpk measure?
Cp = T/6σ compares the tolerance with the process spread; Cpk = (distance from the mean to the nearer limit)/3σ also counts centring. If turning at Ø25 has σ = 3.5 µm (an assumed spread) and the tolerance is 25 µm, Cp = Cpk = 1.19 and 355 parts per million fall outside. Shift the mean by 1.5σ and Cpk drops to 0.69: 19,160 ppm. Six Sigma's 3.4 per million is the tail beyond 4.5σ, a 6σ margin less a 1.5σ shift.
Why does a tighter tolerance cost more?
A tighter tolerance needs a finer process or more passes, slower feeds, better machines, more inspection and more scrap. Cost-tolerance curves are measured, not derived; this chapter uses an illustrative C = 1 + 20/T (T in µm), which shows the shape. Going from 40 µm to 10 µm doubles the relative cost, from 1.5 to 3, and at 2 µm it is 11. So the DFM rule is to give the widest tolerance the function allows and to put tight ones only where parts mate or seal.
A process has Cp = 1.5 but Cpk = 0.8. What should be fixed first?
Cp ignores where the mean sits, so a Cp of 1.5 says the spread fits the tolerance with room to spare. Cpk is much lower only because the mean sits near one limit. Re-centring (an offset on the machine) brings Cpk up to 1.5 without buying a better process.
Worked examples
Grade a bore tolerance and pick processes · A Ø60 bore with a total tolerance of 30 µm
- ISO 286, 50-80 mm: IT7 = 30 µm, IT8 = 46 µm, so 30 µm is IT7
- Formula check: Dm = √(50 × 80) = 63.25 mm, i = 0.45 × 3.984 + 0.001 × 63.25 = 1.856 µm, 16i = 29.7 µm
- Reaming (IT6-10) and turning (IT7-13) reach IT7; boring does not, its best grade IT8 is 46 µm, more than 30 µm
- Processes that hold it: Lapping, honing; Cylindrical grinding; Surface grinding; Diamond turning; Broaching; Reaming; Turning
Answer: IT7: 7 of the 10 processes; for a bore, reaming is the natural choice
Cp, Cpk and rejects on a ground shaft · Ø40 ± 0.008 mm (T = 16 µm); grinding σ = 2 µm; the mean sits 3 µm above nominal
- Cp = 16/(6 × 2) = 1.333
- Cpk = (8 − 3)/(3 × 2) = 0.833
- Above the upper limit: z = (8 − 3)/2 = 2.5, tail Φ(−2.5) = 0.00621
- Below the lower limit: z = (8 + 3)/2 = 5.5, tail 0.019 ppm
- Total = 6210 ppm; centred it would be 63.3 ppm
Answer: Cp 1.33, Cpk 0.83, about 6,210 ppm: re-centre before anything else
Relax, re-centre or regrind? · Turned Ø25, T = 25 µm, assumed σ = 3.5 µm, mean shifted 1.5σ; illustrative cost C = 1 + 20/T
- As found: Cpk = (12.5 − 5.25)/10.5 = 0.69, 19,160 ppm
- Re-centre on the lathe: Cpk = Cp = 1.19, 355 ppm
- Switch to cylindrical grinding (assumed σ = IT5/6 = 1.5 µm): Cp = 2.78, ppm effectively 0, at the cost of a second operation
- Or ask whether 25 µm is needed: at 40 µm the relative cost falls from 1.8 to 1.5
Answer: Re-centring alone cuts rejects from 19,160 to 355 ppm
Assembly limits and datum features: floating and fixed fasteners, concentric parts and stacks
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IVTU BME613D Module 3SPPU 402045A Unit 4MU MELO8062 Module 1KTU not in syllabus
What are assembly limits?
The tightest combination at which parts must still go together: the smallest hole, the largest bolt or shaft (maximum material condition, MMC) and every position error pushed the worst way. A clearance hole is drilled larger than the bolt to pay for those errors. ISO 273 lists three series: for an M10 bolt the hole is 10.5 mm fine, 11 mm medium and 12 mm coarse (tolerances H12, H13, H14). The difference H − F is the whole budget for misplaced holes; how it is shared depends on how the joint is built.
Why does a floating fastener allow twice the error of a fixed one?
With clearance holes in both plates (floating), the bolt can sit anywhere within (H − F)/2 of each hole centre, so the centres may be up to H − F apart: each part's positional tolerance can be the full H − F. If the bolt is screwed into one plate (fixed), its axis is pinned to the tapped hole and only the clearance hole gives, so each part gets (H − F)/2. For M10 in 11 mm holes: 1 mm floating, 0.5 mm fixed. The fixed rule also assumes the screw is square to the face.
What are datum features and the three-datum concept?
A position tolerance only means something relative to a frame. The three-datum concept builds that frame from the part itself: the primary datum face rests on 3 points, the secondary on 2 and the tertiary on 1, so the six points remove the six degrees of freedom. Choose as datums the faces that locate the part in its assembly, so the inspection frame matches how the part is really held. The Machine Drawing book shows how datums and feature control frames are drawn.
How do concentric parts and tolerance stacks fit in?
A stepped shaft in a stepped bore is a floating fit twice over: it assembles if the two parts' coaxiality tolerances add up to no more than the two step clearances, c1 + c2 (ignoring tilt over long steps). With 0.1 mm clearance at each step, each part may have 0.1 mm. Gaps set by a chain of parts are a tolerance stack: four parts at ±0.1 mm give ±0.4 mm worst case, or about ±0.2 mm by root-sum-square. The CAD/CAM book's stack-up interactive compares the two.
Two plates are joined with M10 bolts through 11 mm holes in both. One plate is now tapped M10 instead. The position tolerance each part may have...
The tapped hole fixes the bolt's axis, so only the clearance hole can absorb the error: (11 − 10)/2 = 0.5 mm per part instead of 1 mm. A 0.6 mm tolerance that was fine floating now fails.
Worked examples
Floating fastener check · Two brackets joined by M12 bolts in ISO 273 medium holes (13.5 mm); each part's hole positions toleranced at Ø1.2 mm
- Allowed per part: T = H − F = 13.5 − 12 = 1.5 mm
- Worst case: each hole 0.6 mm off true position, in opposite directions, so the centres are 1.2 mm apart
- The bolt clears both holes while the centres are no more than H − F = 1.5 mm apart
- Margin = 1.5 − 1.2 = 0.3 mm
Answer: Assembles at the worst case, with 0.3 mm to spare
Fixed fastener: choose the hole series · A cover held by M6 screws into tapped holes in a casting; both parts' hole positions need Ø0.25 mm
- Fine series hole 6.4 mm: T = (6.4 − 6)/2 = 0.2 mm per part, less than 0.25: fails
- Medium series hole 6.6 mm: T = (6.6 − 6)/2 = 0.3 mm per part: passes
- Check: worst centre offset 0.125 + 0.125 = 0.25 mm ≤ (6.6 − 6)/2 = 0.3 mm
- A larger hole costs nothing here; tightening the casting's hole positions would
Answer: Use the medium series (6.6 mm), allowing 0.3 mm per part
Stepped shaft in a stepped housing · Diametral clearance at MMC: 0.06 mm at step 1, 0.04 mm at step 2. Shaft coaxiality Ø0.03 mm, housing bore coaxiality Ø0.06 mm
- The shaft can shift up to 0.03 mm in step 1 and the step-2 axes may then differ by up to 0.02 mm
- So the two parts' coaxiality errors may add up to c1 + c2 = 0.1 mm
- Demand: 0.03 + 0.06 = 0.09 mm ≤ 0.1 mm
- Tilt is ignored: with long steps the angular error eats into the same budget
Answer: Assembles, with 0.01 mm to spare
Design features for drills, milling cutters, keyways, dowels and countersunk screws
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IIIVTU BME613D Module 2SPPU not in syllabusMU not in syllabusKTU PEMET522 Module 3
Why should a blind hole end in a cone, not a flat floor?
A twist drill has a pointed end, so the hole it leaves ends in a cone. With the common 118° point the cone is 0.30 D long: 3 mm for a Ø10 drill, 2.1 mm with a 135° point. Ask for a flat floor and the shop needs a second tool, an end mill or a flat-bottom drill, plus a tool change. So drawings show the cone, and design guides (eFunda) say not to specify flat-bottomed holes. Through holes are better still. Keep depth within about 3 to 4 diameters (eFunda says 3, Hubs 4) and drill blind holes deeper than the thread or pin needs, so chips have room.
What happens when a drill meets a slanted or curved surface?
The drill touches on one side first and is pushed sideways, so it walks off position. On a face tilted θ the one-sided cut lasts for D·tanθ of travel: 2.7 mm for a Ø10 drill at 15°. Sandvik Coromant allows solid carbide drills up to 10° of tilt with feed cut to 30 % until the full diameter is cutting. Above 10°, or on a convex boss with a radius under 4 D, mill a small flat or spot face first, or cast a pad square to the hole. Exits matter too: the burr is uneven where the drill breaks out of a sloping face.
How much room do taps and keyway cutters need beyond the feature itself?
A plug tap has about 4 tapered threads at its tip (Travers Tool), so a tapped blind hole must be drilled at least 4 pitches past the full thread: 5 mm more for M8. The Hubs guide is more generous and asks for 1.5 d. A keyway cut by a disc cutter of diameter Dc to depth t runs out over √(t(Dc − t)) at each end: 17.4 mm for a 4 mm deep slot with an 80 mm cutter. Near a shoulder, use a smaller cutter or an end-milled keyseat, which has no runout but cuts more slowly. A Woodruff key sits in a half-moon seat plunged by a cutter of the key's own diameter.
What should you check for countersunk screws and dowel holes?
An ISO 10642 countersunk screw has a 90° head. To sit flush, the countersink goes to the head's theoretical diameter: 13.44 mm for M6. Over a Ø6.6 clearance hole that cone is 3.42 mm deep, so a 5 mm plate keeps a 1.58 mm cylindrical land, while a 3 mm plate is countersunk right through to a knife edge. For dowels, use two pins as far apart as the part allows and no more than two. Give a blind dowel hole a relief hole or a vent flat so air can escape (Fictiv). Make the holes in both parts from the same datums.
A Ø12 hole needs 30 mm of full diameter. With a 118° drill, how deep is the tip of the cone?
The point adds (D/2)/tan 59° = 6/1.664 = 3.61 mm, about 0.30 D. So the tip reaches 33.6 mm. This matters when the floor is close to the other side of the part.
Worked examples
Blind hole in a pump cover · Ø14 hole, 35 mm of full diameter, in a 45 mm thick cast cover; twist drill with a 118° point (135° as the alternative)
- Point length = 7/tan 59° = 7/1.664 = 4.206 mm
- Depth to the tip = 35 + 4.206 = 39.21 mm; wall left under it = 45 − 39.21 = 5.79 mm
- Depth ÷ diameter = 35/14 = 2.5: within the 3 to 4 diameters design guides ask for
- A 135° point is only 7/tan 67.5° = 2.9 mm long, which leaves 7.1 mm
- A flat floor would need an end mill after the drill: one more tool and a tool change for every hole
Answer: Tip at 39.2 mm, wall 5.8 mm (118°) or 7.1 mm (135°); leave the conical floor on the drawing
A hole into a sloping casting face · Ø8 solid carbide drill entering a face inclined 12° to the plane square to the drill
- One-sided cut over D·tanθ = 8 × tan 12° = 8 × 0.2126 = 1.7 mm of travel
- 12° is above the 10° Sandvik limit for solid carbide drills, so the drill would walk
- Spot face Ø12 (1.5 D) square to the drill: depth at its high side = 12 × tan 12° = 2.55 mm
- Better still: cast a small pad square to the hole, so neither the spot face nor the extra tool is needed
Answer: 1.7 mm of one-sided cutting: spot face 2.6 mm deep first, or redesign with a square pad
A tapped hole and a keyway near a shoulder · M10 × 20 mm tapped blind hole (pitch 1.5 mm, tap drill Ø8.5); keyway 5 mm deep, 15 mm from a shoulder, side-and-face cutter Ø100
- Plug tap: drill full diameter to 20 + 4 × 1.5 = 26 mm, cone tip at 28.55 mm; the Hubs guide gives 20 + 1.5 × 10 = 35 mm
- Thread ÷ d = 20/10 = 2: between the 1.5 d minimum and 3 d recommended
- Cutter runout = √(5 × (100 − 5)) = √475 = 21.79 mm: more than the 15 mm gap, so the cutter hits the shoulder
- A Ø63 cutter still runs out 17.03 mm; the runout fits only if Dc ≤ 15²/5 + 5 = 50 mm
- So use an end-milled keyseat here, or move the keyway away from the shoulder
Answer: Drill 26 mm (plug tap); the Ø100 cutter needs 21.8 mm of runout against 15 mm available: end mill it
Less machining: reduced machined area, separation and amalgamation, clampability and accessibility
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IIIVTU BME613D Module 2SPPU not in syllabusMU not in syllabusKTU PEMET522 Module 3
Why machine pads and spot faces instead of whole faces?
Only the faces that locate, seal or carry a mating part need machining. Treat the book's bracket as a casting. Its whole underside is 156 cm², but two pads covering 40 % of it (62 cm²) seat it just as well, and a small pad is easier to make flat. Four Ø22 spot faces for the bolt heads come to 11.4 cm², against 137 cm² for the whole base top. A Ø70 ring around the bore (25.9 cm²) replaces the 107 cm² motor face. Less area means shorter cutting and less tool wear.
Why do features on many faces cost so much?
A 3-axis machine reaches one direction per clamping. Every extra direction means unclamping, turning the part, clamping it again and finding zero, and each re-clamp adds a small location error. The original bracket has faces underneath, on top, front, back and side: 5 set-ups. At an assumed ₹900/h and batches of 50 it takes 25.7 min, or ₹385 a part. Put everything on the underside and the front and it needs 2 set-ups, 11.2 min and ₹168. Guides (eFunda, Hubs) say the same thing: keep features on the principal directions, and on as few of them as you can.
When should one part be split into two, or two merged into one?
Split a part (separation) when one piece would need deep, hard-to-reach features or would turn most of its stock into chips. Machining the bracket from a solid block starts from 2.32 litres of steel. Cutting the base, upright and ribs from 12, 10 and 8 mm plate starts from 0.40 litres, though the pieces then have to be joined (chapter 12). Merge parts (amalgamation) when they would be machined in the same set-up anyway. That removes fasteners, a joint and the tolerance stack between them.
What makes a part easy to clamp and to reach?
Give it a flat face to sit on and a parallel face to clamp. Machined pads underneath also act as the datum for every later set-up. Clamp on solid sections, not thin walls. Leave room for the tool holder, since end mills only cut about 3 to 4 diameters deep (Hubs). A 4-axis horizontal machine with an indexing table reaches the four sides in one clamping. That cuts the original bracket from 5 set-ups to 3 and 25.7 to 18.1 min, but the fixture must leave those sides open.
The original bracket needs tool access from 5 directions. How many set-ups on a 4-axis horizontal machine that reaches all four sides in one clamping?
The front, back and side faces share one clamping on the indexing table. The top and the underside still need one each: 3 set-ups instead of 5, and 18.1 min a part instead of 25.7.
Worked examples
Pads instead of a full underside · Bracket underside 15,620 mm² (after the four Ø11 holes); face mill cutting 40 mm wide at 400 mm/min (assumed); 0.2 min approach and 0.1 min tool change per face; ₹900/h
- Area rate = 40 × 400 = 16,000 mm²/min
- Full face: 15,620/16,000 + 0.3 = 1.276 min
- Pads over 40 %: 6,248/16,000 + 0.3 = 0.69 min
- Saving = 0.586 min × ₹15/min = ₹8.79 a part, or ₹87,862 on 10,000 brackets
- Smaller pads are also easier to hold flat, because a casting rarely sits perfectly on a large face
Answer: 1.28 → 0.69 min: about ₹8.8 saved on every part
Counting the original bracket's set-ups · Underside (from below); 4 holes (top or bottom); base top and upright top (top); motor face (front); bore (front or back); back face (back); 2 × M6 on the side; 3-axis machine, batch 50
- The underside, top, front, back and side faces can each be reached only from their own direction: 5 directions
- The holes and the bore can be done in set-ups that already exist, so they add nothing
- Cutting time (all features) = 6.69 min; load and unload 5 × 3 = 15 min; set-up share 5 × 40/50 = 4 min
- Total = 25.69 min; cost = 25.69 × ₹15 = ₹385 a part
Answer: 5 set-ups, 25.7 min and ₹385 a part: handling is 58 % of the time
Redesigning for one side · Same bracket: pads 40 %, holes drilled from below, bolt seats left as cast, bore faced from the front only, M6 holes moved to the front face; batch 50, then 10
- Directions left: underside (pads, holes) and front (ring face, bore, M6): 2 set-ups
- Cutting 3.61 min + load 2 × 3 = 6 min + set-up share 2 × 40/50 = 1.6 min = 11.21 min
- Cost = 11.21 × ₹15 = ₹168 against ₹385 for the original
- At batches of 10: ₹264 against ₹625. Fewer set-ups matter more as batches get smaller
Answer: 2 set-ups and ₹168 a part, 56 % less than the original
Designing turned and milled parts: slenderness, internal corners and standard tools
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IIIVTU BME613D Module 2SPPU not in syllabusMU not in syllabusKTU PEMET522 Module 3
Why does a long, thin shaft come out tapered or barrel-shaped?
The cutting force pushes the work away from the tool. Where it bends by δ, the tool takes δ less and the diameter comes out 2δ oversize. Held only in a chuck, the work is a cantilever, and the bend under the tool is δ = Fa³/3EI at distance a from the jaws. That is why the error grows steeply toward the free end. A Ø20 × 100 mm steel shaft with 200 N of cutting force ends 84.9 µm oversize at the tip, against an assumed 20 µm tolerance. Supported between centres it is only 5.3 µm.
Chuck, centres or chuck with tailstock: what changes?
Take a Ø20 × 300 mm shaft (L/D 15) at 200 N. In a chuck alone the tip would bend 1.15 mm, so it cannot be turned that way. Between centres the worst bend is at mid-length, FL³/48EI = 72 µm. Chuck plus a tailstock centre gives 33.7 µm at 0.59 L. That is still a 67 µm diameter error, so it needs a steady rest, lighter cuts or a stiffer design. Published L/D limits vary between guides. The deflection against the tolerance is the real check.
Why can't a milled pocket have a sharp inside corner?
A rotating end mill leaves its own radius in every vertical inside corner. A smaller corner needs a thinner tool, and a thinner tool bends: tip deflection grows as H³/D⁴. In a 30 mm deep pocket, R5 allows a Ø10 carbide cutter that bends 6.7 µm at 200 N. R2 forces a Ø4 cutter that bends 260 µm, 39 times more. Hubs recommends corner radii of at least one third of the depth, a little above the tool radius. If a square part must fit, use a T-bone or dog-bone relief.
Why design around standard tools and depths?
Standard drills, end mills (2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 10, 12, 16, 20 mm) and inserts are in every tool crib. Odd sizes mean special tools or slow interpolation. End mills cut about 3 to 4 diameters deep, cavities should be no deeper than about 4 times their width, and anything past 6 tool diameters counts as deep milling and needs special tooling (Hubs). Doubling a depth makes a tool bend 8 times more, while halving its diameter makes it bend 16 times more. Floor corner radii of 0.5 mm, 1 mm or none match standard tool tips.
A 30 mm deep pocket's corner radius drops from 5 mm to 2.5 mm, so the cutter drops from Ø10 to Ø5. The tool bends about:
Stiffness of a round cantilever goes as D⁴, so half the diameter is 2⁴ = 16 times as flexible at the same stick-out and force. The corner radius sets the tool, and the tool sets the accuracy.
Worked examples
A pin turned in a chuck · Steel pin Ø20 × 80 mm (E = 200 GPa) held in a chuck; radial cutting force 150 N; diameter tolerance 20 µm (assumed)
- I = π × 20⁴/64 = 7854 mm⁴; EI = 200,000 × 7854 = 1.5708 × 10⁹ N·mm²
- δ at the tip = 150 × 80³/(3 × 1.5708 × 10⁹) = 16.3 µm, so the diameter is 32.6 µm oversize there: fails
- Add a tailstock centre (fixed-pinned): worst δ = 0.48 µm at 0.59 L, a diameter error of 0.96 µm: passes
Answer: 32.6 µm in the chuck alone; 0.96 µm with a tailstock centre
A long shaft between centres · Steel shaft Ø20 × 200 mm (L/D 10), 150 N, 20 µm tolerance on diameter
- Between centres the worst point is mid-length: δ = FL³/48EI = 150 × 200³/(48 × 1.5708 × 10⁹) = 15.92 µm
- Diameter error = 31.8 µm: a barrel shape that fails 20 µm
- Chuck plus centre: worst δ = 7.5 µm at 0.59 L, a diameter error of 15 µm: still fails
- Options: a steady rest at mid-length, a lighter finishing cut, or a larger diameter if the design allows it (δ ∝ 1/D⁴)
Answer: 31.8 µm between centres, 15 µm with chuck and centre: both need a steady rest or a lighter cut
Choosing a pocket corner radius · Pocket 24 mm deep, solid carbide end mill (E = 550 GPa), cutting force 200 N; corner radius R4 or R8
- R4: the largest standard cutter with radius ≤ 4 is Ø8; stick-out 24/8 = 3 D
- δ = 200 × 24³/(3 × 550,000 × π × 8⁴/64) = 8.33 µm
- R8: Ø16 cutter, stick-out 1.5 D, δ = 0.521 µm, (16/8)⁴ = 16 times stiffer
- Hubs: R ≥ H/3 = 8 mm, so R8 also meets the guide
Answer: R8 (Ø16 cutter, 0.52 µm) instead of R4 (Ø8, 8.3 µm)
Machinability and an early cost estimate for a machined part
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Units III, IVVTU BME613D Module 2SPPU 402045A Unit 5MU not in syllabusKTU PEMET522 Module 3
What does a machinability rating of 78 % mean?
The American Iron and Steel Institute rated free-machining B1112 steel (160 HB) at 100 % from turning tests at 180 surface feet a minute (Rolled Alloys). Other metals are rated against it, roughly by the cutting speed that gives the same tool life. Engineering ToolBox lists 1018 at 78 %, leaded 12L14 at 170 %, annealed 4140 at 66 %, annealed 304 stainless at 45 %, class 30 grey iron at 48 % and cold-drawn aluminium at 360 %. Tables disagree: Rolled Alloys gives 12L14 197 % and 304 55 %. Use one table at a time.
How do you estimate a machined part's cost before the drawing is finished?
Start with the stock block and its mass. Subtract the part to get the volume removed, and divide by a removal rate scaled by machinability. Add finishing time from the surface area, then set-ups and handling. Price the minutes at the machine rate. The book's bracket in 1018, from a 164 × 104 × 136 mm block, comes to 18.2 kg of steel (₹1,366). Roughing takes 51 min at 39 cm³/min and finishing 30 min, so about 93 min and ₹2,763 a part in batches of 50, at the book's assumed rates.
How do you spot an uneconomical design early?
The clearest sign is a part that is mostly air inside its envelope. Machined from solid, the bracket turns 86 % of the block into chips: it buys 18.2 kg to keep 2.54 kg, a buy-to-fly ratio of 7.2. A casting (chapter 9) or welded plates (chapter 12) start close to the final shape. Plate blanks weigh 3.13 kg. Other warning signs: tight tolerances on every face, features on many sides, deep narrow pockets and odd sizes that need special tools.
Which choices cut the machining bill most?
For the bracket in batches of 50: 12L14 cuts in 49 min against 93 min for 1018, so it costs ₹2,466 despite dearer steel. 304 stainless needs 153 min and costs ₹7,119, so specify it only where corrosion demands it. Set-ups are shared by the batch: 3 × 45 min is 135 min a part for a single bracket and 2.7 min in batches of 50. Smaller allowances and standard stock sizes also help. The biggest saving is a near-net-shape blank.
The 1018 bracket is made one at a time instead of in batches of 50. The set-up share per part goes from 2.7 min to:
Three set-ups of 45 min are 135 min for the batch. One part carries all of it, so its cost rises from ₹2,763 to ₹4,748 at the book's assumed rates.
Worked examples
The bracket in 1018 from solid · Block 164 × 104 × 136 mm (2 mm allowance a face); part 323,672 mm³, area 70,920 mm²; 1018 rated 78 %; assumed 50 cm³/min roughing and 30 cm²/min finishing for B1112; 3 set-ups × 45 min, 3 min handling each; batch 50; ₹75/kg, ₹900/h
- Stock = 2,319,616 mm³ = 2.32 L → 18.21 kg × ₹75 = ₹1,366
- Removed = 2,319,616 − 323,672 = 1,995,944 mm³ (86 % of the block)
- Roughing at 50 × 0.78 = 39 cm³/min: 1995.9/39 = 51.2 min
- Finishing at 30 × 0.78 = 23.4 cm²/min: 709.2/23.4 = 30.3 min
- Handling 3 × 3 = 9 min; set-up share 135/50 = 2.7 min; total 93.2 min × ₹15 = ₹1,398
- Cost = ₹1,366 + ₹1,398 = ₹2,763
Answer: About ₹2,763 a part, 93 min of machine time, buy-to-fly 7.17
Changing the material · The same bracket and rates in 12L14 (170 %, assumed ₹95/kg), aluminium bar (360 %, ₹320/kg) and 304 stainless (45 %, ₹260/kg, 8,000 kg/m³)
- 12L14: roughing 23.5 + finishing 13.9 + 11.7 = 49.1 min; steel ₹1,730; total ₹2,466
- Aluminium: 6.26 kg (₹2,004); 29.4 min; total ₹2,444
- 304: 18.56 kg (₹4,825); 152.9 min; total ₹7,119
- Machinability changes the time; density and price change the material cost. The cheapest choice depends on both
Answer: 12L14 ₹2,466, aluminium ₹2,444, 1018 ₹2,763, 304 ₹7,119
Batch size and the set-up share · The 1018 bracket of the first example made in batches of 1, 10 and 100
- Set-up share = 135/N min: 135, 13.5 and 1.35 min
- Batch 1: 225.5 min, ₹4,748
- Batch 10: 104 min, ₹2,925
- Batch 100: 91.8 min, ₹2,743
- Beyond about 50 the set-up hardly matters. The chips and material dominate, so the next saving is a better blank
Answer: ₹4,748 → ₹2,925 → ₹2,743 a part
Form design of castings: uniform walls, junctions and hot spots
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Units II, IVVTU BME613D Module 2SPPU not in syllabusMU not in syllabusKTU PEMET522 Module 4
Why does a casting want uniform walls?
Metal freezes from the mould wall inwards, and a thick section freezes last. Chvorinov's rule puts the freezing time proportional to the square of the modulus, volume over cooling area (the exponent is about 2, some texts say 1.5 to 2). A large plate's modulus is half its thickness, so a 24 mm plate takes 4 times as long as a 12 mm one (2.83 times with n = 1.5). The last metal to freeze shrinks with nothing left to feed it, which leaves a shrinkage cavity. Even the bracket's 12 mm base against its 10 mm upright freezes 1.44 times slower.
What is a hot spot, and how do you find one on a drawing?
Where walls meet, the metal is locally thicker than either wall. The Heuvers circle method draws the largest circle that fits in the section: if it is bigger than the circle that fits the walls, that spot freezes last. Where the bracket's 8 mm rib meets its 12 mm base with sharp corners the circle is 13.33 mm; adding the usual 2.5 mm root fillets makes it 14.49 mm, 1.21 times the base, so it freezes about 1.46 times slower. Good castings keep neighbouring circles in a ratio close to one, growing only towards the riser.
How big should a junction fillet be?
Big enough to avoid cavities and cracks at a sharp corner, small enough not to add metal. A foundry rule of thumb is a radius of a quarter to a third of the wall. The penalty grows quickly: a T of two 12 mm walls holds a 15 mm circle when sharp, 16.5 mm with 3 mm fillets and 18 mm with 6 mm fillets, the 1.5 times the wall that DuPont's moulding guide shows for a radius of half the wall. An X of 12 mm walls is worse: 16.97 mm sharp, 19.46 mm with 3 mm fillets.
How do designers fix L, T, X and V junctions?
Round the outside of an L as well as the inside, outer radius = inner radius + wall, so the wall stays uniform and the circle equals the wall. Keep ribs thinner than the wall they stiffen (about 0.8 times). Never let two walls cross: stagger them into two T's, which cuts a 10 mm X from a 14.14 mm circle to 12.5 mm. Avoid acute V junctions: the narrow angle traps more metal than a right-angled T, so bend the branch to meet at 90°. Run the interactive with the bracket's 12 and 8 mm walls and compare the four fixes.
A rib as thick as the wall it stands on gets fillets of half the wall thickness at both roots. What happens to the hot-spot circle?
The fillets add metal in the corners. With a sharp T the circle is 1.25 t (touching the bottom face and the two corners); fillets of 0.5 t move the touching points outward and the circle becomes 1.5 t (15 mm in a 10 mm wall). Fillets are still needed against cracking, which is why the rule asks for a quarter to a third of the wall, not more.
Worked examples
The hot spot where the bracket's rib meets its base · Grey-iron bracket: base 12 mm thick, rib 8 mm thick, root fillets r = 2.5 mm on both sides
- Put the circle on the rib's centre line at height y: it touches the bottom face (radius y) and both fillet circles, centred at (±(4 + 2.5), 12 + 2.5)
- (6.5)² + (14.5 − y)² = (y + 2.5)² → y = (6.5² + 14.5² − 2.5²)/(2 × 17) = 7.2426 mm
- D = 14.485 mm; with sharp corners y = (4² + 12²)/(2 × 12) = 6.6667 mm, D = 13.333 mm
- Ratio to the 12 mm base = 1.207 (sharp 1.111); Chvorinov with n = 2: freezing time × 1.457 (sharp × 1.235)
- The fillet rule (t/4 to t/3 of the 8 mm rib) gives 2 to 2.67 mm: 2.5 mm is inside it
Answer: D ≈ 14.5 mm, 1.21 × the base: the junction freezes about 46 % later; feed it or keep the rib thin
Crossing walls against staggered T's · Two 10 mm walls in a pump body cross at 90°, sharp corners; the alternative staggers them into two T junctions
- X: the circle sits at the crossing and touches the four corners (±5, ±5): D = √(10² + 10²) = 14.142 mm
- T: on the axis, touching the bottom face and the corners (±5, 10): y² = 5² + (10 − y)² → y = 125/20 = 6.25 mm, D = 12.5 mm
- Freezing time ratios (D/t)²: X 2, T 1.5625
- Staggering cuts the junction's freezing time by 21.88 %
Answer: 14.14 mm → 12.5 mm circle; freezing time 2 → 1.56 times the wall's
A lighter cast bracket · Redesign of the grey-iron bracket for uniform, thinner walls: base 10 mm, upright 8 mm, ribs 0.8 × 8 = 6.4 mm (if the stress check allows); an assumed 5,000 brackets a year at ₹140/kg
- Original volume: base 187438 + upright 107434 + ribs 28800 = 323672 mm³ → 2.33 kg at 7200 kg/m³
- Redesign: base 160 × 100 × 10 − 4 holes = 156199; upright 100 × 120 × 8 − bore = 85947; ribs 2 × ½ × 60² × 6.4 = 23040 mm³
- Total 265186 mm³ → 1.909 kg: 421 g (18.1 %) less
- At ₹140/kg: ₹59 a bracket, ₹294,772 a year for 5,000
- The new rib-to-base junction (10 mm base, 6.4 mm rib, r 2.5 mm) holds a 12.17 mm circle, 1.22 × the base
Answer: 1.91 kg instead of 2.33 kg, about ₹59 a part, with a similar junction ratio
Parting line, draft and cores: redesigning castings to avoid cores
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IVVTU BME613D Module 2SPPU not in syllabusMU not in syllabusKTU PEMET522 Module 4
How do you choose where a mould splits?
Every surface above the parting plane must be able to slide up out of the top half, every surface below must slide down out of the bottom half. Split a flanged hub at its base and the flange's underside, plus the hub wall below it, are trapped: 2 undercut faces. Move the plane into the flange (anywhere from 44 to 64 % of the height) and none are. The usual answer is the plane through the widest silhouette, kept flat so the pattern and die stay simple. Drag the plane in the interactive and watch the count.
Why does every face along the pull need draft?
A face exactly parallel to the pull scrapes the sand or the die as the pattern or part leaves. A sand-casting guide gives 2° as standard and about 1° as the minimum. The cost is metal or machining: the bracket's 132 mm tall outer face grows 4.61 mm at its foot at 2° (2.3 mm at 1°). Deep faces suffer most, which is one more reason to keep a casting shallow in the direction of pull.
What is a core, and when can a design avoid one?
A core is a separate sand shape (or a sliding die insert) that forms a feature the two halves cannot: an internal passage, a hole across the pull, a recess in a side wall. Each one needs a core box, core making, setting, venting and often chaplets to hold it against the metal's lift (the Manufacturing Processes book covers core buoyancy). A side pocket leaves 3 undercut faces wherever the plane goes; open the pocket to the top and it moulds with none. Turning the pull sideways or splitting the part are the other cures.
Cored hole or machined hole?
The bracket's four Ø11 holes are only 33 g of metal in all: coring them saves little, so they are cast solid and drilled. The Ø40 bore across the upright would need a side core if the mould is pulled vertically; cast solid, boring removes a 90.5 g slug, worth ₹13 of iron at ₹140/kg. An H7 fit is finished by machining either way, so a core only pays when it saves real machining time or metal, as in long or large passages.
A pulley with a V-groove round its rim is moulded with the pull along its axis. Where should the parting plane go to avoid a core?
Whatever the plane, one flank of the groove faces back towards the half it must leave with: at a split through the groove root, the upper flank faces downward but must rise with the top half, the lower flank faces upward but must drop. The interactive's pulley never gets below 2 undercut faces. Foundries use a ring core or a three-part flask, or turn the groove after casting.
Worked examples
Draft on the bracket's upright · The grey-iron bracket moulded with the pull vertical and the parting plane at the base underside; its outer upright face is 132 mm deep and 100 mm wide
- At the standard 2°: Δ = 132 × tan 2° = 132 × 0.03492 = 4.61 mm
- At the 1° minimum: Δ = 132 × tan 1° = 2.304 mm
- If the 2° draft is added as metal, the wedge is ½ × 132 × 4.61 × 100 = 30423 mm³
- Mass = 30423 × 10⁻⁹ × 7200 = 0.219 kg, ₹31 of iron a part at ₹140/kg
Answer: 4.61 mm at the foot, about 219 g per part; machining the face to square would remove it again
Finding the parting plane of a flanged hub · Hub: bore Ø30, outside Ø60, 70 mm long; flange Ø140 × 15 mm from 30 to 45 mm up; pull along the axis
- Plane at the base (0 %): the flange underside faces down but lies above the plane, and the hub wall under it cannot rise past the flange: 2 undercut faces
- Plane at mid-height (35 mm, 50 %): above it the flange top and hub top rise freely; below it the flange underside drops freely: 0 undercut faces
- Scanning 0 to 100 % in 2 % steps, the count is zero from 44 to 64 %: a plane through the flange
- The bore and the hub's outside face lie along the pull: draft them, and form the bore with a simple core or core print along the axis
Answer: Split through the flange (44-64 % of the height): 0 undercuts instead of 2
The bore: core it or bore it? · The bracket's Ø40 × 10 mm bore across the upright, and four Ø11 × 12 mm holes in the base; grey iron at ₹140/kg
- Bore slug if cast solid: π × 20² × 10 = 12566 mm³ → 90.5 g → ₹13 of iron
- Four holes: 4 × π × 5.5² × 12 = 4562 mm³ → 32.8 g
- Pulled vertically, the bore is across the pull: it needs a side core; pulled along the bore axis, the four base holes would need cores instead
- Both features need machining for size and position anyway (H7 bore, bolt-hole positions)
Answer: Cast both solid and machine: the metal saved by coring is only about 123 g a part
Design for injection moulding and die casting: walls, ribs, bosses and draft
Which syllabus covers thisAU not in syllabusVTU not in syllabusSPPU not in syllabusMU not in syllabusKTU PEMET522 Module 4
Why stiffen a moulded part with ribs instead of a thicker wall?
Bending stiffness grows with the cube of depth, so material placed far from the neutral axis does the work. A 100 mm wide strip of a 2.5 mm ABS panel with four 1.5 mm × 7.5 mm ribs is 9.94 times as stiff as the flat wall for only 18 % more plastic. A solid wall of the same stiffness would be 5.38 mm thick, 2.15 times the mass, and its centre would take about 55 s to cool instead of 11.9 s.
How long does a moulded wall take to cool?
Heat leaves through both faces, so the time grows with the square of the wall. The first-term solution of a cooling plate gives the time for the centre to fall from the melt to the ejection temperature. With illustrative ABS values (diffusivity 0.09 mm²/s, melt 230 °C, mould 60 °C, ejection 100 °C) a 2.5 mm wall needs 11.9 s, a 3.5 mm wall 23.3 s and a 5 mm wall 47.5 s. Moldflow's documentation notes cooling is usually about 80 % of the whole cycle, so the thickest wall sets the price.
What are the rib, boss and draft rules?
Ribs: half to two-thirds of the wall at the root (DuPont; other guides say 0.4 to 0.6), no taller than about 3 walls, at least 2 walls apart, with 1 to 1.5° of draft. A thicker rib leaves a sink mark on the show face because the junction shrinks more. Bosses: outside diameter 2 to 3 times the hole, joined to a wall by ribs rather than standing thick. Draft: Protolabs asks for 0.5° on vertical faces, 2° in most situations and 3° or more for textured faces; DuPont adds 1° per 0.025 mm of texture depth. Corners: at least 0.5 mm radius.
What changes for die casting?
The same logic applies to aluminium and zinc in steel dies: uniform walls, ribs on thin walls instead of thick sections, fillets at every intersection to help metal flow, and pockets (metal savers) cored out of heavy areas. Die-casting guides add an odd number of ribs to avoid thick crossings and the most draft on holes and windows, which shrink onto the die steel. The Manufacturing Processes book sizes the machines: die-casting locking force and the injection-moulding cycle.
A 2.5 mm moulded wall is made 5 mm thick to stiffen it. Roughly how long does it now take to cool?
Cooling time grows with the square of the wall: 11.9 s becomes 47.5 s. Stiffness grows with the cube (8 times) while the plastic doubles, but ribs reach the same stiffness with far less plastic and keep the thin wall's cycle time.
Worked examples
A ribbed ABS panel against a solid one · 100 mm wide strip, wall t = 2.5 mm, 4 ribs 1.5 mm thick (0.6 t) and 7.5 mm high
- Areas: plate 100 × 2.5 = 250 mm², ribs 4 × 1.5 × 7.5 = 45 mm²; total 295 mm² (1.18 × the plate)
- Neutral axis: ȳ = (250 × 1.25 + 45 × 6.25)/295 = 2.0127 mm
- I = 100 × 2.5³/12 + 250 × (1.25 − 2.013)² + 4[1.5 × 7.5³/12 + 11.25 × (6.25 − 2.013)²] = 1294.5 mm⁴
- Flat plate: 100 × 2.5³/12 = 130.21 mm⁴ → stiffness × 9.942
- Solid of the same I: t_e = (12 × 1294.5/100)^(1/3) = 5.376 mm, 2.15 × the plate's mass
Answer: 9.94 × stiffer for 1.18 × the plastic; the solid equivalent needs 2.15 ×
Cooling time of the ribbed and the solid panel · ABS, α = 0.09 mm²/s, melt 230 °C, mould 60 °C, ejection 100 °C (illustrative); walls 2.5 mm and the solid equivalent
- Log term: ln[(4/π) × (230 − 60)/(100 − 60)] = ln(5.4113) = 1.6885
- 2.5 mm: 2.5² × 1.6885/(π² × 0.09) = 11.88 s (the 1.5 mm ribs cool faster)
- Solid 5.38 mm: 5.376² × 1.6885/(π² × 0.09) = 54.9 s
- Ratio = (5.376/2.5)² = 4.62
Answer: 11.9 s against 55 s: the ribbed panel cools about 4.6 times faster
Sizing ribs and a boss for a 3 mm wall · An ABS housing with a 3 mm wall; ribs 9 mm tall with 1° draft per side; a boss for a 2.5 mm screw pilot hole
- Rib root: DuPont ½-⅔ × 3 = 1.5-2 mm; the 0.4-0.6 rule gives 1.2-1.8 mm; both hold 1.5-1.8 mm: choose 1.8 mm
- Height ≤ 2.5-3 walls = 7.5-9 mm: 9 mm is the limit; spacing ≥ 2 × 3 = 6 mm
- Draft 1° per side over 9 mm: the tip is 1.8 − 2 × 9 × tan 1° = 1.49 mm thick
- Boss: outside diameter 2-3 × 2.5 = 5-7.5 mm, tied to the nearest wall with a rib, not a solid lump
Answer: Ribs 1.8 mm at the root (1.49 mm at the tip), at most 9 mm tall, ≥ 6 mm apart; boss Ø5-7.5 mm
Form design of welded members and forgings
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IIVTU not in syllabusSPPU not in syllabusMU not in syllabusKTU not in syllabus
How is a fillet weld sized to its load?
A fillet weld fails across its throat, the smallest section, 0.7 times the leg for faces at 60-90° in IS 800. The code's shop-weld design strength is the ultimate stress over √3 and a partial safety factor of 1.25: 189.4 MPa for E250 steel (410 MPa). Two 100 mm side welds with 6 mm legs carry 159.1 kN, so a 150 kN factored load stresses the throat to 178.6 MPa: it passes, and the exact leg needed is 5.66 mm.
Why is an oversized weld so expensive?
Strength grows with the leg, but weld metal and arc time grow with its square. A metre of 6 mm fillet holds 141 g of metal, about 4.8 minutes of arc with 4 mm low-hydrogen electrodes at 1.77 kg/h; a 12 mm fillet holds 565 g and takes 19.2 minutes. IS 800 sets minimum sizes (5 mm when the thicker part is 10-20 mm) and allows intermittent welds of at least 4 legs and 40 mm with gaps up to 16 plate thicknesses in tension: on a 300 mm stiffener that saves 52 % of the metal.
Casting or weldment for the bracket?
As a grey-iron casting the bracket weighs 2.33 kg, ₹326 at an assumed ₹140/kg. Welded from steel plates it weighs 2.62 kg: plate blanks ₹201 at ₹75/kg plus 780 mm of 5 mm fillets (77 g, 2.6 minutes of arc, ₹61 with labour and rods), ₹261 in all. Cutting, fit-up and straightening are extra, and the casting needs a pattern first, so batch size decides: a weldment needs no tooling, while a casting spreads its pattern cost over every part it makes.
What are the form design rules for forgings?
Put the parting line in one plane square to the die motion, with surfaces meeting it at no more than about 75°, and no undercuts so the forging can leave the die. Give 5 to 7° of draft on steel and at least 3° on aluminium (precision forging gets down to 1-0°). Keep ribs low and wide, no more than 6 times as tall as thick and no thicker than the web, and use generous corner and fillet radii so metal flows and dies last. The Manufacturing Processes book computes the forging load.
A welded joint must now carry twice the load. Which change uses less weld metal: doubling the leg size or doubling the weld length?
Strength is proportional to leg × length, but metal is proportional to leg² × length. For the two 100 mm runs with 6 mm legs, 12 mm legs need 140 g of metal; 200 mm runs with 6 mm legs need 60 g. Lengthen first, enlarge last.
Worked examples
Sizing the side welds of a lap joint · A flat bar lapped onto a gusset with two side fillets of 100 mm effective length each; factored load 150 kN; E250 steel (f_u 410 MPa), shop weld γ_mw 1.25
- f_wd = 410/(√3 × 1.25) = 189.37 MPa
- Required throat area = 150,000/189.37 = 792.1 mm² over 2 × 100 mm, throat 3.96 mm
- Leg = throat/0.7 = 5.658 mm → use 6 mm (above the Table 21 minimum of 5 mm for a 12 mm part)
- Check: throat stress = 150,000/(2 × 0.7 × 6 × 100) = 178.6 MPa ≤ 189.4 MPa
- Actual weld length each side = 100 + 2 × 6 = 112 mm; metal = 6²/2 × 224 × 7850 × 10⁻⁹ = 31.7 g, arc 1.07 min
Answer: 6 mm fillets: 179 MPa against 189 MPa, 32 g of weld metal
Twice the load: bigger leg or longer weld? · The same joint at 300 kN: option A 12 mm legs × 100 mm, option B 6 mm legs × 200 mm (each of two runs); 4 mm E7018-1 rods at 1.77 kg/h, 62.5 % deposition efficiency
- Both carry 2 × 0.7 × s × L × 189.4: A = 318.1 kN, B = 318.1 kN
- A: 12²/2 × 2(100 + 24) × 7850 × 10⁻⁹ = 140.2 g; arc 4.75 min; rods 224 g
- B: 6²/2 × 2(200 + 12) × 7850 × 10⁻⁹ = 59.9 g; arc 2.03 min; rods 96 g
- A uses 2.34 times the metal of B for the same strength
Answer: Lengthen: 60 g against 140 g of weld metal
The bracket as a casting and as a weldment · THE BOOK'S BRACKET; grey iron ₹140/kg, steel plate ₹75/kg, labour ₹250/h, 30 % arc-on time, rods ₹200/kg (assumed); 5 mm fillets: upright to base both sides, each rib to base and upright both sides
- Casting: 323672 mm³ × 7200 × 10⁻⁹ = 2.33 kg → ₹326
- Plate blanks: 160 × 100 × 12 + 100 × 120 × 10 + one 60 × 60 × 8 square (two ribs) = 340800 mm³ → 2.675 kg → ₹201
- Weld runs: 2 × (100 + 10) + 8 × (60 + 10) = 780 mm; metal 5²/2 × 780 × 7850 × 10⁻⁹ = 76.5 g
- Arc 2.59 min → welder 8.6 min = ₹36; rods 122 g = ₹24
- Weldment ₹261 and 2.62 kg against casting ₹326 and 2.33 kg (boring the bore and cutting excluded)
Answer: Weldment about ₹261, casting about ₹326 before machining, at these assumed rates
Design for manual assembly: the DFA worksheet, minimum part count and design efficiency
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IIIVTU BME613D Module 4SPPU 402045A Unit 4MU MELO8062 Module 2KTU PEMET522 Module 2
What does a DFA worksheet record?
One row per part (or extra operation) in assembly order: how many identical items, a two-digit handling code and its time, a two-digit insertion code and its time, and the row time TA + RP × (TH + TI), where TA is 2.9 s to pick up a power screwdriver once per row. The book's desk fan needs 19 rows for 21 items and 2 turn-overs, and adds up to 150.75 s. The 3 housing screws alone take 2.9 + 3 × (1.8 + 3.6) = 19.1 s.
How do you decide which parts are theoretically necessary?
Ask three questions of each part against those already assembled. Does it move relative to them in use? Must it be a different material, or isolated from them? Must it be separate so the others can be assembled or taken apart? A yes to any makes it a theoretical part. Screws, nuts, clips, brackets and labels usually fail all three. In the fan only 8 of 21 items pass; the other 13 items and the two turn-overs cost 102.24 s of the 150.75 s.
What is design efficiency?
It compares the real assembly time with an ideal product in which every part is theoretical and takes 3 s to handle and insert. The fan scores 3 × 8 / 150.75 = 15.9 %. After the DFMA redesign the same 8 essential parts take 42.01 s, so the efficiency rises to 57.1 %. The worked controller in the Boothroyd-Dewhurst chapter, with 206.43 s and 5 theoretical parts, scores 7.3 %.
What does the worksheet leave out?
It prices assembly labour only. At an assumed ₹250 per hour the fan costs ₹10.47 to assemble, or ₹2.92 after redesign: ₹7,55,139 a year at 100,000 fans. That is a big cut (72 % of the time), but parts and tooling usually cost more than labour. The redesign needs dearer housing moulds with ribs, slots and hooks. So the worksheet points to where to look, and a cost estimate of each change then decides it.
One of the fan's 3 housing screws is removed, and nothing else changes. Roughly how much does the design efficiency rise?
One screw saves only its own handling and insertion, 1.8 + 3.6 = 5.4 s. The tool pickup and both turn-overs stay. TM falls to 145.35 s and E goes from 15.9 % to 16.5 %. Snapping the housing shut removes the screws and both turn-overs together, and saves 30 s.
Worked examples
Worksheet rows for the motor mounting · Fan rows: DC motor (handling 30, insertion 02), sheet-steel bracket (22, 03), 2 bracket screws (11, 30, power tool, TA 2.9 s). Redesign: motor pressed between moulded ribs (30, 04)
- Motor: 1.95 + 2.6 = 4.55 s; bracket: 2.36 + 5.2 = 7.56 s
- Screws: 2.9 + 2 × (1.8 + 3.6) = 13.7 s; total 25.81 s
- Three questions: the motor's shaft turns and it is a different material (theoretical); bracket and screws do not move, could be the housing's plastic and are not needed for access (not theoretical)
- Redesign row: 1.95 + 1.8 = 3.75 s, saving 22.06 s per fan
- At 100,000 fans: 612.8 h a year, ₹1,53,194 at an assumed ₹250/h
Answer: 25.81 s becomes 3.75 s; 3 of the 4 items go
Design efficiency before and after · Fan worksheet sums: original TM 150.75 s, redesign 42.01 s; 8 theoretical parts in both
- Original: E = 3 × 8 / 150.75 = 0.1592
- Redesign: E = 3 × 8 / 42.01 = 0.5713
- Items handled fall from 21 to 8; worksheet rows from 19 to 8
- The redesign still misses 100 % because the cable needs two hands (5.6 s) and the PCB is thin and has no symmetry (2.51 s)
Answer: 15.9 % rising to 57.1 %
What the screws and turn-overs cost in a year · Fan rows inserted by power tool (codes 30, 31): 9 items in 5 rows; 2 turn-overs at 4.5 s; 100,000 fans; assumed ₹250/h
- Threaded-fastener rows: 13.7 + 13.7 + 8.3 + 19.1 + 9.63 = 64.43 s
- Turn-overs: 2 × 4.5 = 9 s
- Together 73.43 s, 48.7 % of the 150.75 s
- Per year: 73.43 × 100,000 / 3600 = 2040 h, ₹5,09,931
Answer: About 49 % of the assembly time; ₹5,09,931 a year
Handling time: symmetry, size, thickness and weight
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IIIVTU BME613D Module 4SPPU not in syllabusMU MELO8062 Module 2KTU PEMET522 Module 2
What are alpha and beta symmetry?
Alpha is the angle you must turn a part, about an axis at right angles to its insertion axis, before it looks the same again. Beta is the same angle about the insertion axis itself. A plain pin goes in either end first and at any roll angle: α 180°, β 0°. Chamfer one end and α becomes 360°. The fan blade needs its hub face the right way (α 360°), and its three blades repeat every 120° (β 120°). Orienting time grows with α + β.
How does the handling chart turn a part into a time?
The first digit is the α + β band: below 360°, 360-540°, 540-720° or 720°. The second digit is the size and thickness class, plus whether the part nests or tangles. The selected chart in the Boothroyd-Dewhurst chapter, a reduced version of their commercial chart, runs from 1.13 s (code 00) to 3.34 s (code 35) for one-hand parts. Parts that need two hands, like the fan's USB cable, take 4.1-5.6 s.
Why do thin, small or heavy parts take longer?
Fingers struggle to pick up a thin part from a flat surface. Thickness is the shortest side, or the radius for a cylinder longer than its diameter, and above 2 mm it causes no grasping trouble. Size is the longest side. Parts under 15 mm need care, and below about 2 mm they need tweezers. Weight matters least: about 0.025 s per pound in the chapter's model, so a 250 g part costs only 0.014 s more.
How do you design a part to be handled quickly?
Make it symmetric, or clearly asymmetric so the right way is obvious at a glance. Avoid features that nest or tangle in a bin, and avoid parts that are flexible, slippery, sharp or tiny. On the fan, a wire guard that nests costs 2.25 s instead of 1.5 s. The 0.75 s difference adds up to ₹5,208 a year at 100,000 fans and an assumed ₹250/h.
A Ø6 × 30 mm pin is chamfered at one end only. Its designer adds the same chamfer to the other end. What happens to its handling time?
Both ends now lead, so α drops from 360° to 180° and α + β from 360° to 180°. The code moves from 10 (1.5 s) to 00 (1.13 s), saving 0.37 s (25 %). The second chamfer also helps insertion either way round.
Worked examples
Handling code of the fan's housing screw · M5 × 12 pan-head screw, about 15 mm long overall; it must go in point first and is round
- α = 360° (point first), β = 0° (any roll angle): α + β = 360°, so the first digit is 1
- Thickness: a cylinder longer than its diameter, so thickness = radius = 2.5 mm, which is above 2 mm
- Size 15 mm lies in the 6-15 mm class, so the second digit is 1
- Code 11: 1.8 s, the code the fan worksheet uses for every screw row
Answer: Code 11, 1.8 s
A reversible fan blade · PP blade, 90 mm across, hub 12 mm thick; α 360°, β 120° now. Option: a hub that fits either face first (α 180°). 100,000 fans, assumed ₹250/h
- Now: α + β = 480°, so row 1; size 90 > 15 mm and thickness 12 > 2 mm, so column 0. Code 10: 1.5 s
- Reversible: α + β = 300°, so row 0. Code 00: 1.13 s
- Saving 0.37 s per fan, 10.3 h a year
- ₹2,569 a year: small, but it costs nothing if the hub is designed that way from the start
Answer: 1.5 s falls to 1.13 s
A thin board that tangles · Speed-switch PCB 60 mm long, 1.6 mm thick, no symmetry (α 360°, β 360°). What if the boards come in a bin where their leads tangle?
- α + β = 720°, so row 3
- Thickness 1.6 mm ≤ 2 mm with size above 6 mm, so column 2
- Code 32: 2.51 s, as in the fan worksheet
- If they tangle: column 5, code 35, 3.34 s, 0.83 s more per board before any untangling
- Fix it in the supply chain: boards in trays, or leads trimmed before assembly
Answer: Code 32 (2.51 s); 35 (3.34 s) if it tangles
Insertion: chamfers, alignment, jamming and holding down
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IIIVTU BME613D Module 4SPPU not in syllabusMU MELO8062 Module 2KTU PEMET522 Module 2
What sets the insertion time?
Three things, in the selected Boothroyd-Dewhurst chart: whether the part is easy to align (chamfers or similar features), whether it must be held down until something secures it, and whether access or vision is blocked. A part simply placed with clear access takes 1.5 s (code 00). Holding down adds 1.1 s, a hard-to-align held part takes 5.2 s, and with blocked access and vision it reaches 9.6 s. A snap fit that is easy to align takes 1.8 s.
How much misalignment does a chamfer forgive?
The tip finds the hole if it is off the axis by less than half the clearance plus both chamfer widths. For a Ø10 mm hole and c = (D − d)/D = 0.01 that is only ±0.05 mm without chamfers, ±1.05 mm with a 1 mm hole chamfer and ±2.05 mm with chamfers on both. Boothroyd's experiments: widths beyond about 0.1D add little, a peg chamfer beats the same hole chamfer, and the angle hardly matters between 10° and 50°.
Why does a tilted peg sometimes wedge?
A tilted peg touches the hole at two points, the tip on one wall and the mouth on the other. Whitney's analysis shows it can wedge if the tilt exceeds c/µ. Then friction locks it whatever the push. Equivalently, it wedges when two-point contact happens shallower than µD. Gripped 20 mm up, 1.2 mm off the axis, the Ø10 peg (c 0.01) tilts 3.29° and touches at 2.03 mm, inside µD = 3 mm at µ 0.3: stuck. At 0.5 mm off it touches at 4.56 mm and goes in.
What is the difference between jamming and wedging?
Wedging is geometry plus friction: the contact forces squeeze the peg, and pushing harder only squeezes more. Jamming is a push in the wrong direction. If the push line sits well off the peg axis, friction at the two contacts can absorb it. With a vertical push 8 mm off the axis it jams while l < 2µ × 8 = 4.8 mm, so the peg 0.6 mm off (contact at 3.77 mm) sticks. Boothroyd shows that a push along the axis never jams.
You can afford one 45° chamfer of width 0.1D: on the peg or on the hole. Which saves more insertion time in Boothroyd's experiments?
In the empirical insertion-time equation a hole chamfer is worth −220 ms and a peg chamfer −250 ms, against −100 ms with no chamfer. Both together give −370 ms. For a Ø12 hole, Ø11.9 peg and 25 mm insertion: 337 ms bare, 217 ms (hole), 187 ms (peg), 67 ms (both).
Worked examples
Entry acceptance with and without chamfers · Ø10 mm hole, Ø9.9 mm peg; chamfers 45° × 1 mm (0.1D) where present
- c = (10 − 9.9)/10 = 0.01; half the diametral clearance = 0.05 mm
- No chamfer: ±0.05 mm, hopeless for a hand or a robot without compliance
- Hole chamfer only: 0.05 + 1 = ±1.05 mm
- Peg and hole chamfers: 0.05 + 1 + 1 = ±2.05 mm
- The chamfers multiply the entry window about 40 times without changing the fit once the peg is home
Answer: ±0.05 mm grows to ±2.05 mm
Insertion time from the empirical equation · Ø12 mm hole, Ø11.9 mm peg, 25 mm insertion; t = −70 ln c + f + 3.7L + 0.75d ms, or 1.4L + 15 ms if larger
- c = 0.1/12 = 0.00833; −70 ln c = 335.1 ms
- 3.7L + 0.75d = 92.5 + 8.925 = 101.425 ms; floor 1.4L + 15 = 50 ms
- No chamfer (f = −100): 336.5 ms
- Chamfers on both (f = −370): 66.5 ms
- Saving 270 ms per insertion: the pure insertion only; the chart's alignment codes add the hand's search time
Answer: 337 ms falls to 67 ms
Will the tilted peg wedge? · Ø10 hole, Ø9.9 peg (c 0.01), chamfers on both; hand 1.2 mm off the axis, grip 20 mm above the tip; µ 0.3, then 0.15
- After the chamfer the tip sits within the clearance (0.05 mm off), so tan θ = (1.2 − 0.05)/20: θ = 0.0574 rad = 3.29°
- Two-point contact where l sin θ + d cos θ = D: l = (10 − 9.9 cos θ)/sin θ = 2.026 mm
- Whitney's limit: θ = 0.0574 > c/µ = 0.0333, and l = 2.03 < µD = 3 mm: it wedges
- With µ 0.15 (lubricated, illustrative): µD = 1.5 mm < 2.03 mm, so it slides in
- Better still, hold the hand within 0.5 mm: contact at 4.56 mm, deep enough at either friction
Answer: Wedges at µ 0.3 (contact at 2.03 mm < 3 mm); slides at µ 0.15
Design for fastening: snap fits, screws and press fits
Which syllabus covers thisAU not in syllabusVTU not in syllabusSPPU not in syllabusMU MELO8062 Module 2KTU PEMET522 Module 2
Which fastening methods are cheapest to assemble?
Boothroyd and Dewhurst list them in order of increasing manual assembly cost: snap fitting, plastic bending, riveting, then screw fastening. Fastening the fan's front housing with 3 screws takes 35.25 s: placing the housing, turning the pod over and back, picking up the screwdriver, and driving the screws. Two moulded hooks take 5.25 s. The 30 s saved is worth ₹2,08,333 a year at 100,000 fans and an assumed ₹250/h.
How do you size a cantilever snap hook?
Bending the arm by the undercut y strains its root by ε = 1.5 h y / l² (constant rectangular section). That strain must stay below the material's permissible value for one assembly: 4 % for PC and 2.5 % for PC/ABS (Bayer guide), 6 % for POM and conditioned PA66 (DuPont). Use about 60 % of it if the joint will be opened often. The book's PC/ABS hook, 16 × 1.6 mm with a 1 mm undercut, strains 0.94 %.
How hard is the hook to push home?
The force to bend the arm is P = (b h²/6)(Es ε / l), with Es the secant modulus at that strain. The ramp then multiplies it by (µ + tan α)/(1 − µ tan α). For the 6 mm wide PC/ABS hook, Es ≈ 1978 MPa gives P = 2.97 N and, at a 30° lead with µ ≈ 0.69, W = 6.25 N. A lead angle above about 55° self-locks. A 90° return face makes the joint permanent.
When are screws or press fits still the right choice?
Screws suit parts that must open often for service, metal-to-metal joints and loads a plastic hook cannot carry. A snap fit needs a release slot or a return angle below 90°. Opening a POM hook over a 45° return face takes about 10.8 N. Press fits need no extra part but resist insertion, which the selected chart does not cover (the full chart does). The simple beam formula also overstates the root strain of short, stubby arms (BASF).
A snap hook's arm is made twice as long, with the same thickness and undercut. What happens to the root strain?
ε = 1.5 h y / l², so doubling l divides the strain by 4: 0.938 % becomes 0.234 %. The deflection force falls even more, roughly as 1/l³, from 2.97 N to 0.43 N. A longer arm is the easiest way to save a hook that strains too much.
Worked examples
Check the fan's housing hook · PC/ABS, constant rectangular arm l = 16 mm, h = 1.6 mm, b = 6 mm, undercut y = 1 mm, lead angle 30°; µ = 0.575 × 1.2 (like on like); secant modulus 2400 MPa at 0 % falling to 1950 MPa at 1 % (Bayer Fig. 16, read)
- ε = 1.5 × 1.6 × 1 / 16² = 0.009375 = 0.938 %, below 2.5 % (once) and 1.5 % (repeated)
- Es at 0.938 %: 2400 − 0.9375 × 450 = 1978.1 MPa
- P = (6 × 1.6²/6)(1978.1 × 0.009375/16) = 2.967 N
- Factor (0.69 + tan 30°)/(1 − 0.69 tan 30°) = 2.107; W = 6.25 N
- Two hooks: about 12.5 N to snap the housing shut, an easy thumb push
Answer: ε 0.94 %, P 2.97 N, W 6.25 N per hook
Largest undercut for a reusable PA66 hook · PA66 at 50 % RH (DuPont: 6 % once, 3 % frequently), l = 18 mm, h = 1.8 mm, b = 6 mm, E = 1550 MPa
- y = 0.67 ε l²/h; frequent use: (2/3) × 0.03 × 18²/1.8 = 3.6 mm
- One-time assembly would allow (2/3) × 0.06 × 18²/1.8 = 7.2 mm
- Deflection force at the frequent-use limit: P = (6 × 1.8²/6)(1550 × 0.03/18) = 8.37 N
- l/h = 10, the edge of where the beam formula holds; a shorter, stubbier arm would need a corrected method
Answer: y up to 3.6 mm for repeated opening (7.2 mm once)
Screws or snap hooks for the fan housing · Kernel worksheet rows: housing placed (30, 03), turned over and back (61, twice), 3 screws (11, 30, TA 2.9 s); or housing snapped on (30, 05). 100,000 fans, assumed ₹250/h
- Screwed: 7.15 + 2 × 4.5 + 2.9 + 3 × (1.8 + 3.6) = 35.25 s
- Snapped: 1.95 + 3.3 = 5.25 s
- Saved 30 s per fan; 833.3 h a year, ₹2,08,333
- Items handled fall from 4 to 1; the hooks add mould cost (side actions or a slot for each undercut)
Answer: 35.25 s becomes 5.25 s; ₹2,08,333 a year
Automatic assembly: transfer systems, indexing machines and part feeders
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IIIVTU BME613D Module 3SPPU not in syllabusMU MELO8062 Module 2KTU PEMET522 Module 2
How does work move between the stations of an assembly machine?
Three ways. Continuous transfer moves the work at a steady speed while the heads travel with it. Intermittent (synchronous, indexing) transfer moves every assembly one station at a time and then holds it still: an in-line chain or a rotary dial. Free transfer (power-and-free, asynchronous) lets each carrier wait at its station, so a slow or jammed station does not stop the others, and buffers can sit between them. A synchronous dial is only as fast as its slowest station: with 2 s of work and 8 stations it makes 1,125 assemblies an hour, and one jam stops all 8.
How does a Geneva drive index a dial, and what does indexing cost?
A pin on a constantly turning driver enters a slot of an n-slot wheel, turns it by 360°/n and leaves; between slots a locking arc holds the wheel still. Geometry fixes the split: the driver turns 180° − 360°/n while the wheel moves, so the indexing share of each cycle is (n − 2)/2n. That is 25 % for 4 slots, 37.5 % for 8 and 41.7 % for 12. If every station needs 2 s of still time, the cycle grows from 2.67 s to 3.43 s as slots are added. The pin enters tangentially, so the wheel starts from rest without a shock.
How does a bowl feeder deliver oriented parts, and how fast?
Vibration walks parts up a spiral track. Devices along it, such as a wiper blade, cutouts, steps and slots, send wrongly oriented parts back to the bowl or turn them over. The selector efficiency E is the fraction delivered in the wanted orientation. The book's cup (Ø20 × 16 mm) rests on its rim only about 15 % of the time (centroid solid-angle estimate). At 30 mm/s with a 20 mm pitch the track carries 90 cups a minute but delivers 13.6: too few for an 8-station dial needing 18.75. A turn-over step for rim-up cups raises E to 39 % and the feed to 34.7.
How should a part be designed so that it feeds itself?
Make it either symmetric, so every orientation is right, or clearly asymmetric, so a simple device can tell the orientations apart. Avoid shapes that tangle (open springs), shingle (thin discs climbing over each other) or wedge in the track. Give it a feature a device can use: the headed pin hangs by its head in a slotted track whichever end leads, so the slot keeps 95 % of pins against 47 % if tip-first pins were rejected. A small shape change that feeds well can save a whole feeder and its tooling.
The 8-station dial (2 s of work at each station) is rebuilt as a 4-station dial with a 4-slot Geneva. What happens to the cycle time?
The work time is the same 2 s, but a 4-slot Geneva spends only 25 % of its turn indexing against 37.5 % for 8 slots. Cycle = 2/(1 − share): 3.2 s becomes 2.67 s, 1,125 → 1,350 cycles an hour, although each cycle now does only half the operations.
Worked examples
Resting probabilities of a block · A 30 × 20 × 10 mm block; first estimate: the chance of resting on a face = the solid angle it subtends at the centroid / 4π (solid angle of an a × b rectangle at distance d on its axis: 4 asin(ab/√((a² + 4d²)(b² + 4d²))))
- Large faces 30 × 20 at d = 5 mm: 4 asin(600/√(1000 × 500)) = 4.0528 sr each; two faces: 0.645
- Long edges 30 × 10 at d = 10 mm: 1.5251 sr each; two: 0.2427
- Ends 20 × 10 at d = 15 mm: 0.7053 sr each; two: 0.1123
- Check: 0.645 + 0.2427 + 0.1123 = 1 (a seeded Monte Carlo of 200,000 directions agrees)
- If only flat, hole-up blocks are wanted: E = 0.645/2 = 0.3225
Answer: Flat 64.5 %, on edge 24.3 %, on end 11.2 %; E = 32.3 % without a turn-over step
Can the feeder keep up with the dial? · Cups Ø20 × 16 mm fed nose to tail at 30 mm/s; rim down 0.1515, rim up 0.2341, on side 0.6144; dial cycle 3.2 s, one cup per cycle
- Input rate Fi = v/L = 30/20 = 1.5 cups/s = 90 per minute
- Rejecting all but rim-down cups: Fo = 0.1515 × 90 = 13.64 per minute
- The dial needs 60/3.2 = 18.75 per minute: short by 5.11
- Turning rim-up cups over instead: E = 0.1515 + 0.2341 = 0.3856, Fo = 34.7 per minute
- Or speed the track up: rejecting only, it would need v = 30 × 18.75/13.64 = 41.2 mm/s
Answer: Rejecting only: 13.6 per minute, not enough; with a turn-over step 34.7 per minute, 1.85 times what the dial uses
A 6-station Geneva dial · 6 stations, a 6-slot Geneva, a constant-speed driver, 2 s of still time needed at every station
- Index angle of the driver = 180° − 360°/6 = 120°; dwell = 180° + 60° = 240°
- Index share = 120/360 = 0.3333, so the dwell is 0.6667 of the cycle
- Cycle = 2/0.6667 = 3 s; index time = 1 s
- Driver speed = one turn per cycle = 60/3 = 20 rev/min
- Output = 3600/3 = 1,200 assemblies an hour if nothing jams
Answer: Cycle 3 s, driver 20 rev/min, 1,200 assemblies an hour
Design for automatic and robotic assembly: defective parts, machine yield and cost
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IIIVTU BME613D Module 3SPPU not in syllabusMU MELO8062 Module 2KTU PEMET522 Module 2
What do defective parts do to an automatic assembly machine?
Two things. A bad part that jams a station stops the whole machine while someone clears it; a bad part that goes in spoils the assembly. With a defect rate q at each of n stations and a share m of defects jamming, the good fraction is (1 − (1 − m)q)^n and each cycle loses n·m·q·Td to jams (derived on this page, checked by simulation). Ten stations, q = 0.5 %, m = 0.6, Td = 60 s, Tc = 4 s: 98.02 % good, 5.8 s per assembly instead of 4, 608 good an hour instead of 900, and the machine is down 31 % of the time.
Why does part quality matter more to a machine than to a person?
A person drops a bad part in the bin and picks another in a second; a machine stops. Assembly Magazine's illustration: if 5 parts in 10,000 jam, the system stops about every 8 minutes, and with 2 minutes to restart it is down 20 % of the time. On the 10-station machine, cutting defects from 0.5 % to 0.05 % lifts good output from 608 to 860 an hour, and doubling them to 1 % drops it to 455. Cheap parts can be the most expensive choice for an automatic line; free-transfer machines with buffers soften the blow.
How do you design a product for automatic and robotic assembly?
Build it in layers from the top down on a base part that locates itself in a fixture, so a robot never has to turn it over. Give parts chamfers and lead-ins so they self-align, and features feeders can orient. Use snap fits or press fits instead of screws: the book's fan has 8 screws in four rows, each needing a feeder, a driver and a check. Avoid flexible parts: the USB cable (handling code 42, two hands) is the hardest part of the fan to automate. Whether a robot cell pays at all is the Robotics book's comparison of manual work, a robot cell and fixed automation against volume.
Can a DFA analysis predict assembly errors?
Roughly. Motorola's assembly-defect data, analysed by later researchers and reported in Boothroyd, Dewhurst and Knight's text, showed about 1 assembly error in 10,000 operations for every second an operation takes beyond the ideal 3 s, so the chance of a faulty product is 1 − [1 − 0.0001(t − 3)]^n. The book's fan takes 150.75 s over 23 operations (t = 6.55 s): about 0.81 % faulty. The redesign takes 42.01 s over 8 operations: 0.18 %. Fewer, easier operations mean fewer mistakes, whether a person or a machine does them.
A supplier offers cheaper parts with 1 % defective instead of 0.5 % (10 stations, m = 0.6, Td = 60 s, Tc = 4 s). Roughly what happens to good output per hour?
Jams per cycle double from 0.03 to 0.06, so each assembly takes 7.6 s instead of 5.8 s, and slightly more bad assemblies slip through. Good output falls from 608 to 455 an hour, 25 % less: the jam time, not the scrap, does the damage.
Worked examples
Output of a 10-station machine · 10 stations, defect rate q = 0.005 at each, m = 0.6 of defects jam, Td = 60 s to clear a jam, ideal cycle Tc = 4 s
- Good part added at a station: 1 − (1 − 0.6) × 0.005 = 0.998
- Good assemblies: 0.998^10 = 0.98018
- Jams per cycle F = 10 × 0.6 × 0.005 = 0.03; one jam every 33.3 cycles = 3.2 min
- Time per assembly Tp = 4 + 0.03 × 60 = 5.8 s; output 3600/5.8 = 620.7 an hour
- Good output = 0.98018 × 620.7 = 608.4 an hour; down-time 1.8/5.8 = 31 %
Answer: 608 good assemblies an hour, 98.02 % good, down 31 % of the time
Jam or let it through? · The same machine at q = 0.005; compare a feeder that refuses every bad part (m = 1) with one that lets every bad part in (m = 0)
- m = 1: good fraction 1; F = 10 × 0.005 = 0.05; Tp = 4 + 0.05 × 60 = 7 s; 514.3 good an hour
- m = 0: no jams, Tp = 4 s, 900 an hour, but only (0.995)^10 = 0.9511 good: 856 good and 44 faulty an hour
- The faulty ones must be found by inspection and stripped, or they reach the customer
- At m = 0.6 (example 1): 608.4 good an hour and 12.3 faulty
Answer: Refusing bad parts costs output (514 an hour); passing them costs quality (4.9 % faulty). Better parts beat both.
Machine cost per good assembly · The 10-station machine at an assumed ₹1,500 an hour (machine and operator); q = 0.5 % and q = 0.1 %
- q = 0.5 %: cost per assembly made = 1500 × 5.8/3600 = ₹2.417; per good one ₹2.417/0.9802 = ₹2.466
- q = 0.1 %: Tp = 4 + 10 × 0.6 × 0.001 × 60 = 4.36 s; good fraction 0.99601
- Cost per good one = 1500 × 4.36/3600/0.99601 = ₹1.824
- Saving ₹0.642 per assembly; at 1,00,000 assemblies a year = ₹64,159
Answer: ₹2.47 at 0.5 % defective, ₹1.82 at 0.1 %: about ₹64,159 a year for 1,00,000 assemblies
Design for additive manufacturing: orientation, supports, hollowing and markings
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit VVTU not in syllabusSPPU 402045A Unit 5MU not in syllabusKTU not in syllabus
What does additive manufacturing change for the designer?
There is no mould, die or fixture, so complexity costs almost nothing: internal channels, lattices, organic shapes from topology optimisation and several parts printed as one. What costs is volume, height and support. In the book's model, metal powder bed fusion scans about 10.8 cm³ an hour (assumed 0.03 mm layers, 0.1 mm hatch, 1 m/s), so the solid 60 × 40 × 40 mm block takes 12.2 h, and 1,334 layers of recoating alone take 3.7 h. Build orientation, supports, lattices and cost against moulding are worked in the Additive Manufacturing book's interactives.
Why hollow a printed part, and what does hollowing need?
Material and scan time cost money, so a thick part can be printed as a shell. The SLS block with a 2 mm shell drops from 92.4 g to 26.3 g, but its build time falls only from 2.94 h to 1.63 h because every layer still has to be spread. The cavity is full of unsintered powder (65.3 cm³): the University of Zurich SLS guide asks for escape holes of at least 4 mm, two of them on opposite sides. Resin printers need drain holes (3.5 mm in Formlabs' guide), and metal parts escape holes of 2 to 5 mm.
Why are horizontal holes printed as teardrops?
Each layer must rest on the one below. A downward-facing surface flatter than a limit needs support: AMFG gives 45° for metal powder bed fusion, and says round holes over 10 mm need support. The roof of a round hole is flat at the top, so a Ø12 bore would need supports inside it that are hard to remove. A teardrop replaces the roof arc with two faces at 45°: the apex rises to 8.49 mm above the centre and the hole gains only 7.73 mm² (6.8 %), while a pin still bears on the round lower part. In SLS the powder bed supports everything.
How should markings, undercuts and interlocking parts be designed for AM?
Text, part numbers and orientation arrows print free, which can replace a label like the book's fan nameplate. They must be big enough: the Zurich SLS guide asks for embossed text at least 0.5 mm high and a 14 pt font; Formlabs' resin guide gives 0.1 mm embossed and 0.4 mm engraved. Put markings on vertical or upward faces, never on a supported face. Undercuts cost nothing to print, and parts can even be printed inside each other, as chains or hinges, with about 0.5 mm clearance in SLS.
Hollowing the SLS block to a 2 mm shell removes about 71 % of its material. By roughly how much does its build time fall?
Scan time is proportional to the material sintered, but spreading each of the 400 powder layers takes the same time whether the layer is solid or hollow. With the book's assumed rates the build drops from 2.94 h to 1.63 h, 44 % less.
Worked examples
Hollowing a block for SLS · Block 60 × 40 × 40 mm with a Ø12 horizontal bore through its 40 mm depth; shell t = 2 mm all round, a 2 mm wall kept round the bore; PA12 at an assumed 1.01 g/cm³
- Solid volume = 60 × 40 × 40 − π × 6² × 40 = 91476 mm³ = 91.48 cm³
- Inner box = 56 × 36 × 36 = 72576 mm³; bore with its wall = circle of radius 8: π × 8² = 201.06 mm² over 36 mm
- Cavity = 72576 − 7238.2 = 65338 mm³ = 65.34 cm³ of trapped powder
- Material = 91.48 − 65.34 − two Ø4 escape holes through 2 mm (0.05 cm³) = 26.09 cm³
- Mass: 92.4 g solid, 26.3 g hollow
Answer: 26.3 g instead of 92.4 g (71 % lighter), with 65.3 cm³ of powder to get out through two 4 mm holes
A teardrop bore for metal PBF · A Ø12 horizontal bore in a 316L part; least self-supporting angle 45° from horizontal (AMFG guide)
- The roof arc where the surface is flatter than 45° spans ±45° about the top
- Tangents at ±45° meet on the axis at r/cos 45° = 6/0.7071 = 8.485 mm above the centre
- Extra area = r²(tan 45° − π/4) = 36 × 0.2146 = 7.726 mm²
- Round bore area 113.1 mm²: the teardrop is 6.8 % larger and needs no support
- For resin (19° from level) the bump is tiny: apex 6.35 mm, extra 0.46 mm²
Answer: Apex 8.49 mm above the centre, 7.73 mm² extra; the lower half still locates a Ø12 pin
What hollowing saves in metal · The same block in 316L (8.0 g/cm³) by metal PBF: assumed scan rate 10.8 cm³/h, 0.03 mm layers, 10 s per layer; 2 mm shell with two Ø5 escape holes (the top of AMFG's 2-5 mm range)
- Layers = 40/0.03 = 1,334 (rounded up); layer time = 1,334 × 10 s = 3.706 h
- Solid: 91.48 cm³/10.8 = 8.47 h of scanning; total 12.18 h; 732 g
- Hollow: 26.06 cm³/10.8 = 2.413 h; total 6.12 h; 208 g
- The powder left inside must come out through the escape holes, or the part keeps most of its weight
Answer: 12.2 h → 6.1 h and 732 g → 208 g
Part count reduction and computer tools for DFMA: consolidation, group technology and cost software
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Units IV, VVTU BME613D Module 2SPPU not in syllabusMU MELO8062 Module 2KTU not in syllabus
When does combining parts into one pay?
When the parts and assembly saved outweigh the dearer tool. Moulding the fan's motor ribs and cable labyrinth into the rear housing removes a bracket, a clamp and 3 screws, cuts the assembly of these rows from 55.66 s to 15.8 s and saves ₹9.93 a unit in parts and labour, but side actions add an assumed ₹3 lakh to the mould. Written off over 3 years, the one-piece wins above 6,040 fans a year. Below about 260 a year a printed one-piece is cheapest because it needs no tool at all.
When should parts stay separate?
Boothroyd's three questions say: when a part moves relative to the others, must be a different material, or must be separate so the rest can be assembled or serviced. The fan passes 8 of its 21 parts, so 8 is its theoretical minimum and the redesign reaches it (16 % → 57 % design efficiency). Beyond that, combining can cost more than it saves: a complex tool, a long cooling time, a whole housing scrapped for one broken rib, or a part that cannot be repaired.
What is group technology, and how does it help DFMA?
Group technology sorts parts into families that share a shape or a process route, then makes each family in its own cell with shared fixtures and tools. For the designer it means reusing a standard part or feature before inventing a new one. The book's fan uses 8 screws in 4 rows; one screw size for all would mean one feeder, one bit and one torque setting. Rank-order clustering, which finds such families from a machine-part chart, is an interactive in the CAD/CAM book.
What do computer tools for DFMA do?
They run the worksheets in this book on a whole product and add cost models. Boothroyd Dewhurst's DFMA software offers Product Simplification, to reduce part count and assembly complexity, and Should Costing, which builds manufacturing cost estimates from the ground up for each process. The value is speed and consistency at the concept stage: the same analysis that takes the book's fan from 150.75 s to 42.01 s of assembly can be repeated on every design option before any tool is cut.
At only 1,000 fans a year, which rear housing gives the lowest unit cost?
At 1,000 a year the tooling dominates: ₹267.8 for the original (₹7.2 lakh of tools), ₹317.9 for the moulded one-piece (₹9 lakh) and ₹953 printed. The extra parts and assembly of the original cost only ₹9.93 a unit, so they win until about 6,040 a year.
Worked examples
Assembly time saved by consolidation · Kernel DFA codes for the rear-housing rows of THE BOOK'S FAN; screws carry 2.9 s tool acquisition
- Original: housing 3.45 + motor 4.55 + bracket 7.56 + 2 bracket screws 13.7 + cable 10.8 + clamp 7.3 + clamp screw 8.3 = 55.66 s
- One-piece: housing 3.45 + motor pressed into ribs 3.75 + cable into the labyrinth 8.6 = 15.8 s
- Saved 39.86 s per fan = ₹2.768 at the assumed ₹250/h
- At 1,00,000 fans a year: 1,107 hours of assembly
Answer: 55.66 s → 15.8 s; 6 parts become 1
Unit cost at 1,00,000 fans a year · Assumed: ABS ₹160/kg, press ₹700/h, housing 60 g in 30 s (one-piece 66 g in 32 s), bracket 60 × 40 × 1 mm steel at ₹75/kg + ₹1.50 pressing, screws ₹1.20, clamp ₹2.00; tools ₹6 lakh mould + ₹1.2 lakh bracket tool vs ₹9 lakh one-piece mould; 3-year write-off
- Original parts: housing 15.433 + bracket 2.913 + 3 screws 3.6 + clamp 2 = ₹23.946; labour 55.66 s = ₹3.865
- Tooling share = 7,20,000/(3 × 1,00,000) = ₹2.4; unit cost ₹30.21
- One-piece: part 0.066 × 160 + 32/3600 × 700 = ₹16.782; labour ₹1.097; tooling 9,00,000/(3 × 1,00,000) = ₹3
- Unit cost ₹20.88; saving ₹9.33 a fan, ₹9,33,217 a year
Answer: ₹30.21 original, ₹20.88 moulded one-piece
Where the routes cross · The costs of example 2; printed one-piece by SLS at an assumed ₹15 per cm³ (66 g of ABS-sized part = 63.5 cm³), no tooling
- Variable cost: original ₹27.812, moulded ₹17.879, printed ₹953.02
- Original vs moulded: V* = (9,00,000 − 7,20,000)/3/(27.812 − 17.879) = 6,041 a year
- Printed vs original: V* = 7,20,000/3/(953.02 − 27.812) = 259 a year
- If the side actions cost more than ₹31,00,000, the one-piece no longer pays even at 1,00,000 a year (₹31 lakh)
Answer: Printed below about 260 a year, original up to about 6,040, moulded one-piece above
Design for the environment: life-cycle assessment and the weighted-sum method
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IVTU BME613D Module 5SPPU not in syllabusMU not in syllabusKTU PEMET522 Module 4
What does a life-cycle assessment count?
Every stage: extracting and making the material, manufacturing the part, using the product and its end of life. A cradle-to-gate number stops at the factory gate. The US DOE's 2023 report, using NREL data, gives 41.7 MJ per kg for primary steel but 7.9 MJ for steel remelted in an electric arc furnace. Aluminium goes from 136.5 MJ (primary) to 13.6 MJ (recycled). So the material's origin can matter as much as the choice of material.
When does a lighter car part pay back the extra energy used to make it?
When the fuel it saves equals its extra production energy. Take a 10 kg steel panel (illustrative) and a primary-aluminium panel of the same stiffness, which weighs 4.95 kg. Making it costs 258 MJ more. At the DOE's fuel reduction value of 0.20 L per 100 km per 100 kg and 32 MJ per litre, it saves 3.23 MJ every 1,000 km. It breaks even at 79,860 km, well inside the report's 244,840 km car life.
Why does the way the part is loaded change the answer?
For equal stiffness, a tie needs EA, a beam roughly E·a⁴ and a panel E·t³, so the mass ratio is (ρ/ρ₀)(E₀/E) raised to the power 1, 1/2 or 1/3. Aluminium, at 68.9 GPa against steel's 205 GPa, is no lighter as a tie (10.23 kg against 10 kg). As a beam it weighs 5.93 kg, and as a panel 4.95 kg. Low-density materials win most where bending stiffness sets the thickness.
How does the weighted-sum method compare two designs?
Score each design on each criterion out of 10, multiply by weights and divide by the sum of the weights. Our stamped steel bracket against a cast-aluminium bracket (beam loading) is scored on making energy, making CO₂, lifetime fuel and two judged scores, recyclability and ease of separation (illustrative). With equal weights steel scores 8.16 and aluminium 8.03. Raise the fuel weight to 1.5 and aluminium wins, 8.21 to 7.96. The weights decide the answer, so write them down before you score.
A magnesium panel with the same stiffness as the 10 kg steel one weighs 3.67 kg. Over a 244,840 km car life, does it save energy overall?
Pidgeon-process magnesium takes 393 MJ/kg (Argonne). The panel costs 1027 MJ more to make, and saving 4.05 MJ per 1,000 km it would need 2,53,699 km to pay back.
Worked examples
Break-even distance of a CFRP panel · 10 kg primary-steel panel (illustrative); CFRP E 152 GPa, ρ 1550 kg/m³, 254.8 MJ/kg; steel 205 GPa, 41.7 MJ/kg; FRV 0.20 L/(100 km·100 kg), 32 MJ/L
- Equal panel stiffness: m = 10 × (1550/7850) × (205/152)^(1/3) = 2.182 kg
- Making energy: 2.182 × 254.8 = 555.9 MJ against 10 × 41.7 = 417 MJ, so 138.9 MJ more
- Mass saved 7.818 kg; fuel saved = (7.818/100) × 0.20 L per 100 km = 0.1564 L per 1,000 km
- Energy saved per km = 0.005004 MJ (× 32 MJ/L)
- Break-even = 138.9 / 0.005004 = 27,751 km
Answer: About 27,800 km
Counting CO₂ instead of energy · Beam loading, primary aluminium (8.9 kg CO₂e/kg) against primary steel (6.7 kg CO₂e/kg), 10 kg steel beam, petrol 2.88 kg CO₂e/L, FRV 0.20, life 244,840 km
- Aluminium beam mass = 10 × (2700/7850) × (205/68.9)^(1/2) = 5.933 kg
- Making CO₂: steel 10 × 6.7 = 67 kg; aluminium 5.933 × 8.9 = 52.8 kg, already lower
- Use phase: 4.067 kg saved × 0.20/10⁴ L per km·kg × 244,840 km × 2.88 = 57.4 kg
- Life total saving = 14.2 + 57.4 = 71.6 kg CO₂e
Answer: Aluminium is ahead from the first km; 72 kg CO₂e saved over the life (on energy it needs 1,50,915 km)
Weighted sum with climate-first weights · Scores (steel, cast Al): making energy (10, 5.15), making CO₂ (7.88, 10), fuel in use (5.93, 10), recyclability (9, 7), separation (8, 8); weights 1, 3, 1, 1, 1
- Steel: (10 + 3 × 7.88 + 5.93 + 9 + 8)/7 = 8.082
- Cast Al: (5.15 + 3 × 10 + 10 + 7 + 8)/7 = 8.593
- Computed scores are 10 × (best value)/(this value), so the better design gets exactly 10
Answer: Cast aluminium 8.59 against steel 8.08: the weights, not the data, flipped the result
Design for disassembly, recyclability and remanufacture
Which syllabus covers thisAU CME391 Unit IVTU BME613D Module 5SPPU not in syllabusMU not in syllabusKTU PEMET522 Module 2
What makes a product quick to take apart?
Few fasteners, all reached from one direction, joints you can see, and as few separate materials as possible. Our removal times come from the book's assembly-time chart with stated factors: unscrewing takes as long as screwing, prying a snap open takes 1.5 times as long as pushing it in, and a part that lifts out takes half its insertion time. On those terms the original fan takes 102 s to strip in 13 steps, including 8 screws and one turn-over. The redesign takes 29 s in 7 steps.
When should a recycler stop taking a product apart?
When the next steps cost more labour than the extra value they free. Some steps free nothing on their own: turning the fan over and removing the 3 housing screws takes 21.2 s for ₹0.045 of screws, but it unlocks the motor and cable behind them. So you test every stopping point, not just the next step. At an assumed ₹250/h, stripping the original nets ₹14.01. At ₹1,500/h it is better to shred the original whole, yet the redesign still pays to strip (₹8.85).
What makes the material streams recyclable?
Each stream must be one material, or materials that can be recycled together. A paper nameplate glued to an ABS housing, a steel insert moulded into plastic or a PCB screwed to a bracket all contaminate a stream unless someone spends time separating them. The redesign has fewer materials: no steel bracket, nylon clamp, label or loose screws. Its two ABS housings carry moulded-in text instead of a label. In the model, 115 g of the redesign's 245 g is plastic, and all of it comes out as clean single-polymer parts.
What does remanufacture need from the design?
Remanufacture brings used products back to as-new condition, which only works if they come apart without damage. The fan's motor is worth far more as a working motor than as scrap. In this model the motor sells as scrap at an assumed ₹110/kg, so its 55 g fetches ₹6.05. The catch is that snap fits designed for fast assembly may be one-way hooks: our redesign's guard takes 5.95 s to unsnap against 2.5 s to lift off. Design snaps with a release slot, or they become permanent joints.
The recycler's labour cost rises from ₹250 to ₹1,500 an hour. What should they do with the original fan?
A full strip takes 102 s, ₹42.52 of labour, for ₹21.09 of sorted parts. Every stopping point does worse than the ₹2.09 from shredding it whole. The redesign still nets ₹8.85 when stripped.
Worked examples
Time for the screws behind the front housing · Original fan: turn over (kernel separate operation 4.5 s), 3 housing screws (power screwdriver 3.6 s each, tool pick-up 2.9 s), 1 s to bin each item
- Turn over: 4.5 s
- Pick up the screwdriver once: 2.9 s
- Each screw: 3.6 s to undo + 1 s to bin = 4.6 s; three of them = 13.8 s
- Step time = 4.5 + 2.9 + 13.8 = 21.2 s, for ₹0.045 of steel screws
Answer: 21.2 s: the slowest step of the strip, and it frees almost nothing on its own
Net value of stripping the original fan · Full strip 102.05 s at an assumed ₹250/h; sorted part value at the assumed scrap prices ₹21.093
- Labour = 102.05/3600 × 250 = ₹7.087
- Net = 21.093 − 7.087 = ₹14.006
- Shredding it whole instead: 261.2 g × ₹8/kg = ₹2.09
- Stripping beats shredding until labour costs ₹670/h for this design
Answer: ₹14.01 per fan, against ₹2.09 for shredding
The redesign at a high labour rate · Redesign: 7 steps, 29.05 s, sorted value ₹20.95; labour ₹1,500/h
- Labour = 29.05/3600 × 1500 = ₹12.1
- Net = 20.95 − 12.1 = ₹8.85
- Break-even labour rate for a full strip: ₹2,353/h, against ₹670/h for the original
Answer: Still worth stripping: ₹8.85 per fan
Value engineering: functions, FAST diagrams and the value index
Which syllabus covers thisAU not in syllabusVTU not in syllabusSPPU not in syllabusMU MELO8062 Module 3KTU not in syllabus
What does value mean in value engineering?
Value is the ratio of function to cost. You raise it by doing the same job for less money, or a better job for the same money, without losing the basic function. The method began at General Electric during the Second World War: materials and parts were short, and Lawrence Miles, Jerry Leftow and Harry Erlicher found that substitutes were often cheaper and sometimes better. The US Navy's Bureau of Ships made it a formal programme in 1957.
How do you read a FAST diagram?
Every function is written as an active verb and a measurable noun, as Miles insisted: "move air", not "fan". Charles Bytheway of Sperry Univac presented the Function Analysis System Technique to the Society of American Value Engineers in 1965. Read left to right and each box answers HOW the one before is done; read right to left and it answers WHY. For the fan, Move air is the basic function: it is done by Drive blade, which is done by Take power. Set speed, Guard user and Hold parts support that path.
How do you find the function with the worst value?
Share each part's cost, including its assembly labour, among the functions it serves. Then divide each function's worth (the cheapest way you believe it could be done) by its cost. In the original fan, Hold parts collects the bracket, 8 screws, the nut, the clip ring, the turn-overs and most of both housings: ₹25.19 for a worth of ₹6, so V = 0.24. The redesign brings it down to ₹13.14 (V = 0.46). Costs and worths are illustrative.
What steps does a value study follow, and where can it go wrong?
SAVE's job plan has six phases: information, function analysis, creative, evaluation, development and presentation. Function analysis comes before brainstorming, so ideas attack expensive functions instead of expensive parts. The danger is cutting cost at the expense of a function nobody wrote down. Wikipedia's article opens with the Grenfell Tower fire, where cheaper exterior cladding replaced better material. Write safety, compliance and service as functions with real worths, so they cannot quietly disappear.
In the original fan, Hold parts costs ₹25.19 for a worth of ₹6. Which change raises its value index the most?
Halving the screw price saves only 8 × ₹0.2 = ₹1.6, so V goes from 0.238 to 0.254. Most of the cost is assembly labour, so removing the parts gets Hold parts down to ₹13.14, V = 0.46.
Worked examples
Cost of the function Take power (original fan) · USB cable ₹12 + its assembly 10.8 s; PCB ₹14 + 7.71 s, 20 % to Take power; cable clamp ₹1 + 7.3 s, 50 % to Take power; labour at an assumed ₹250/h
- Cable: 12 + 10.8/3600 × 250 = ₹12.75 (100 %)
- PCB: 0.2 × (14 + 7.71/3600 × 250) = ₹2.907
- Clamp: 0.5 × (1 + 7.3/3600 × 250) = ₹0.753
- Take power = 12.75 + 2.907 + 0.753 = ₹16.41; worth ₹12 → V = 0.731
Answer: ₹16.41, V = 0.73
Value index of the whole fan, before and after · Sum of worths ₹77; original cost (parts ₹109.3 + labour ₹10.47); redesign (parts ₹102 + labour ₹2.92)
- Original: 77/119.77 = 0.643
- Redesign: 77/104.92 = 0.734
- Saving per fan = 119.77 − 104.92 = ₹14.85, of which labour ₹7.55
- The redesign's housings cost ₹2.5 more (more complex moulds): value engineering accepts a dearer part when it removes a function's cost elsewhere
Answer: V rises from 0.64 to 0.73; ₹14.85 saved per fan
Guard user after the redesign · Redesign: wire guard ₹9 snapped in (100 %), rear housing 30 % and front housing 40 % to Guard user, housings ₹10.5 and ₹9, labour at ₹250/h; worth ₹8
- Guard: 9 + 5.55/3600 × 250 = ₹9.385
- Rear housing share: 0.3 × 10.74 = ₹3.222
- Front housing share: 0.4 × 9.365 = ₹3.746
- Guard user = ₹16.35; V = 8/16.35 = 0.489
Answer: V = 0.49: the next target once Hold parts is fixed
Product development economics: cash flows, NPV and sensitivity
Which syllabus covers thisAU not in syllabusVTU not in syllabusSPPU 402045A Unit 5MU MELO8062 Module 4KTU not in syllabus
What goes into a development project's cash flow?
Money out before launch (engineering, prototypes, tooling), then money in or savings once production runs, all as dated amounts. Our fan redesign (illustrative) spends ₹12 lakh on development and ₹20 lakh on new moulds at year 0. It then saves ₹14.85 per fan, the chapter-23 cost difference, on 100,000 fans a year. Year 1 runs at 60 % while production ramps up, giving ₹8.91 lakh, then ₹14.85 lakh a year until the model is retired after year 5.
Why discount future cash, and what do NPV and IRR tell you?
A rupee next year is worth less than a rupee now, because today's rupee could earn a return meanwhile. NPV discounts every year's cash at the company's required rate and adds them up: at 12 % the redesign's NPV is ₹16.2 lakh, so it beats that return. The IRR is the rate that makes NPV zero: 29.4 %. Simple payback, which ignores discounting, comes after 2.55 years.
What does a tornado chart show?
It moves one input at a time, here by ±20 %, and draws the NPV range as a bar, biggest first. Saving per fan and volume tie at ±₹9.6 lakh each, because NPV depends on their product. Tooling moves NPV ±₹4 lakh. A 6-month launch delay costs ₹6.3 lakh. The chart tells you which estimates to firm up first: here, the saving per fan and the volume.
How do teams use these numbers for day-to-day trade-offs?
They turn the model into rules of thumb. For this project a month of launch delay costs about ₹1.06 lakh of NPV, so spending less than that to save a month is worth it. Volume could fall to 66,346 fans a year before NPV reaches zero. Qualitative factors still matter: easier servicing, what the team learns, risks to the brand. Here's the catch: every input is an estimate, which is why the tornado chart comes first.
Which hurts the redesign's NPV more: a 6-month launch delay, or tooling costing 20 % more than planned?
The tooling overrun is ₹4 lakh at year 0, so NPV falls by ₹4 lakh. The delay loses half a year of savings and pushes the rest later, so NPV falls by ₹6.35 lakh.
Worked examples
NPV of the fan redesign · Year 0: −₹32 lakh; saving ₹14.851 per fan, 100,000 fans a year, 60 % in year 1, end-of-year cash, 12 %
- Year 1: 0.6 × 1,00,000 × 14.851 = ₹8.911 lakh; years 2-5: ₹14.851 lakh each
- Discount factors 1/1.12^k: 0.8929, 0.7972, 0.7118, 0.6355, 0.5674
- Present values: 7.956, 11.839, 10.571, 9.438, 8.427 lakh
- NPV = −32 + 48.232 = ₹16.23 lakh
Answer: ₹16.2 lakh; IRR 29.4 %
Cost of a 3-month launch delay · Same project; sales start 0.25 years late, the model still retires at the end of year 5, the ramp-up year starts at launch
- Year 1 sales share: 0.6 × 0.75 = 0.45; year 2: 0.6 × 0.25 + 0.75 = 0.9; years 3-5: 1
- Cash: 6.683, 13.366, 14.851, 14.851, 14.851 lakh
- NPV = −32 + 45.059 = ₹13.06 lakh
- Loss against no delay = 16.23 − 13.06 = ₹3.17 lakh
Answer: ₹3.17 lakh, about ₹1.06 lakh a month
Payback year · Cash: −32, 8.911, 14.851, 14.851 … lakh (undiscounted)
- After year 1: −32 + 8.911 = −23.089 lakh
- After year 2: −8.238 lakh, still negative
- After year 3: 6.614 lakh, so payback falls in year 3
- Within year 3: 2 + 8.238/14.851 = 2.555 years
Answer: 2.55 years (discounting would push it later)
Design for reliability and maintainability: stress-strength interference, hazard rate and availability
Which syllabus covers thisAU not in syllabusVTU not in syllabusSPPU not in syllabusMU MELO8062 Modules 5, 6KTU PEMET522 Module 4
How can a part with a safety factor of 1.6 still fail?
Because both its strength and the stress on it vary from part to part and load to load. Failure happens wherever a weak part meets a high load, where the two distributions overlap. If both are normal, their difference is normal too. Take mean strength 400 MPa (CoV 8 %) against mean stress 250 MPa (CoV 15 %), both illustrative. The margin is z = 3.04, so R = 0.99883: 1,172 failures per million, despite a central safety factor of 1.6.
What do the Weibull shape and scale tell a designer?
R(t) = exp(−(t/η)^β). The scale η is the age by which 63.2 % have failed. The shape β tells you the failure mode: below 1 the hazard falls (early failures from defects), at 1 it is constant (random), above 1 it rises (wear-out). Together the three regions make the bathtub curve NIST describes. With β = 2 and η = 2,000 h, R(1,000 h) = 0.7788, the hazard is 0.5 per 1,000 h and MTTF = ηΓ(1.5) = 1,772 h.
Why do series systems need very reliable parts?
In series every part must survive, so reliabilities multiply. Three such parts at 1,000 h give 0.7788³ = 0.4724, and the system MTTF drops to 1,023 h. Two in parallel (either one is enough) give 1 − (1 − 0.7788)² = 0.9511, MTTF 2,292 h. Designing for reliability means fewer parts in series: the DFA habit of cutting part count helps here too. Use redundancy only where a failure would be expensive or dangerous.
How do availability and preventive maintenance fit together?
Availability is the fraction of time the product works: A = MTBF/(MTBF + MTTR). Take a part with β 2.5 and η 2,000 h, a 48 h repair after a failure and an 8 h planned replacement (illustrative). Run to failure gives A = 97.37 %. Replacing it every 900 h raises that to 98.51 %. Planned replacement only helps when β > 1: with random failures a new part is no better than the old one. Design for maintainability (quick access, few tools) shrinks MTTR.
A part fails at random (Weibull β = 1). Will replacing it every 500 h, before it fails, raise availability?
With β = 1, R(t) = exp(−t/η) has no memory. A(T) never beats run to failure (97.66 % here). At T = 500 h it is 96.33 %.
Worked examples
Interference reliability of a bracket · Strength 400 MPa mean, CoV 8 %; stress 250 MPa mean, CoV 15 %; both normal (illustrative)
- σ_S = 0.08 × 400 = 32 MPa; σ_s = 0.15 × 250 = 37.5 MPa
- z = (400 − 250)/√(32² + 37.5²) = 150/49.298 = 3.0427
- R = Φ(3.043) = 0.99883; failures = 1,172 per million
- Halving the strength scatter to CoV 4 %: z = 3.679, failures 117 per million
- Cutting the stress scatter to CoV 5 % instead: z = 4.366, failures 6.32 per million
Answer: R = 0.9988; controlling the load scatter helps far more than tightening the strength here
Weibull part and a 3-part series system · β = 2, η = 2,000 h, t = 1,000 h; three identical parts in series
- R(1000) = exp(−(1000/2000)²) = exp(−0.25) = 0.7788
- h(1000) = (2/2000)(1000/2000) = 0.5 per 1,000 h, rising: wear-out
- MTTF = 2000 × Γ(1.5) = 2000 × 0.8862 = 1772.5 h
- Series: R = 0.7788³ = 0.4724; MTTF = 2000 × 3^(−1/2) × Γ(1.5) = 1023.3 h
Answer: One part 0.779, system 0.472; MTTF 1,772 h against 1,023 h
Availability with a 1,000 h replacement interval · β = 2.5, η = 2,000 h; repair after failure 48 h, planned replacement 8 h, replace at age T = 1,000 h
- R(1000) = exp(−0.5^2.5) = 0.838: 16.2 % of cycles end in a failure
- Mean uptime per cycle = ∫₀^1000 R dt = 952 h (Simpson's rule)
- Mean downtime per cycle = 8 × 0.838 + 48 × 0.162 = 14.48 h
- A = 952/(952 + 14.48) = 98.5 %
- Run to failure: MTTF = 2000 Γ(1.4) = 1774.5 h, A = 97.37 %
Answer: 98.5 % against 97.37 %; the best interval, 900 h, gives 98.51 %
Keep going
- Manufacturing Processes interactive book
- Machine Drawing interactive book
- Additive Manufacturing interactive book
- Design for Manufacturability (DFM) course
- DFM checklist tool
- Free DFM course
- PG Program in Manufacturing Design
- All Skill-Lync interactive books
Recommended reading
- Product Design for Manufacture and Assembly, G. Boothroyd, P. Dewhurst and W. Knight
- Design for Manufacturability Handbook, J. G. Bralla
- Design for Manufacturing: A Structured Approach, C. Poli
- Design for Manufacturability and Concurrent Engineering, D. M. Anderson
- Engineering Design, G. E. Dieter and L. C. Schmidt
- Product Design and Development, K. T. Ulrich and S. D. Eppinger
How this book was made
Chapters follow the official syllabi listed above. Every interactive's formulas and every worked-example number were checked by script. Explanations, animations and examples are original to Skill-Lync.