Challenge

Project 1_Comparative study of different storey buildings for Seismic forces

Procedure:

  •          Open ETABS software.
  •          Click new model.
  •          Give model initialization setting as follow
  •          Click ok
  •          In the new model quick template dialog box , select custom grid spacing and click Edit grid data
  •          Give the following settings in grid system data dialog box.
  •          Click ok.
  •         Select custom story data under story dimension and click edit story data.
  •          Give the story data for first- three story as follow having story 1 as master story.
  •          Write click on the first column and select add story and click keep existing story heights.
  •          Give number of added story as 22.
  •      Click ok
  •          The following page opens 
  •          Click Define--> Material properties
  •          Click Add new material for assigning concrete
  •          Click Add new material for assigning Rebars
  • Click ok, Again add new and add Concrete of M30 Grade
  •          Click Define--> Section properties--> Frame sections.
  •          Select Add new property in the dialog box.
  •          Select the concrete shape as rectangular and give the following settings for the Beam
  •      Beam property is added.
  •          Again, click Add new property for creating property for column.
  •          Column property is added.
  •          Click--> Section properties--> Slab section
  •          Select Add new property and give the following settings.
  •          Clickà Define--> Load pattern
  •          Define load patterns by its name
  •         Click Define--> Mass source
  •          Check load cases by click Define-->Load cases.
  •          Create load combinations, Define--> Load combinations
  •          Create Columns by Quick draw column.
  • Select quick draw beams.
  • Select the first horizontal and vertical beams and go to edit and select replicate  <!--[endif]-->Select first floor in plan view
  • Draw slab using quick slab by having similar stories in the status
  • Select all the beams from select tab
  • Assign frame loads as distributed from assign tab.
  • Select the slabs
  • Assign shell loads as uniform
  • Select the slabs from select tab and assign as diaphragm from assign tab.
  • Click run analysis in the panel after saving the file.

Result-

Results-

Criteria

Model

Result

Conclusion

Effect of Stiffness on time period

Building E ( 10 story with varying column size)

1.73 Sec

Here, if the stories are less then change in Column size does not effect on result.

 

Building F (10 Story with Uniform column size )

1.73 Sec

 

Effect of Stiffness on time period

Building G ( 25 story with varying column size)

4.17 Sec

Here, we can conclude if the stories are high and change in Column size does effect on result.

 

Building H (25 Story with Uniform column size )

4.41 Sec

 

Effect of Mass on time period

Building H (25 Story with 3 kN/SqM Imposed Load)

4.41 Sec

We provided uniform load but not so significant. Mass is directly proportional to the Displacement.

 

 

Building J (25 Story with 3.3 kN/SqM Imposed Load)

4.42 Sec

 

 

Building K (25 Story with 3.6 kN/SqM Imposed Load)

4.43 Sec

 

Effect of Building Height on time period

Building A

0.5 Sec

We know Height of building is directly proportional to the time period, so as height increases defiantly Time will increases.  

 

Building B

1.03 Sec

 

 

Building F

1.73 Sec

 

 

Building H

4.41 Sec

 

Effect of Column Orientation on time period

Building B

1.02 Sec

Column Orientation are create effect on flexible behavior of the Building.

Building C

1.145 Sec

Building D

1.12 Sec

Criteria

Model

Case

Analysis Result

Conclusion

Effect of Flexural Stiffness of structural elements on mode Shapes.

Building B

Flexural Stiffness of beams close to nil.

2.62 Sec

If we don’t consider stiffness property of beam it increases time period (almost double).

Full Flexural Stiffness of beams.

1.02 Sec

Effect of Axial Stiffness of Vertical Members on mode shapes  

Building H

Axial Cross Section for columns is close to nil.

5.99 Sec

Axial Cross section of the columns plays vital load in time period.

 

Full axial cross section

4.41 Sec

Effect of Degree of fixity at column base on mode shape.

Building B

Column Support Pinned

1.02 Sec

More the fixity of the column lesser the time period.

Column Support Fixed

0.941 Sec

Your portfolio, next

Ship work like this
in your own course.

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.