Perform a grid dependency test for bevel gear simulation with different mesh sizes as follows ( 6,5, and 4 mm )
Solve for Equivalent Stress , Equivalent Strain and Total Deformation
Grid Dependency Test
The grid dependence test is used to see how the solution changes depending on the grid size by running the simulation with a revised mesh. The finer the mesh, the higher the accuracy of the result, but it comes at a cost in terms of computation time and processing power. Because solutions are interpolated at the nodes to obtain an approximation result, the greater the number of nodes and elements, the longer and more powerful the computation required to finish the simulation.
As a result, the grid dependency test aids in establishing the appropriate mesh size for obtaining accurate results while keeping time and power costs in mind. Because the results are approximate, more mesh refinement would result in a minuscule percent change in the result, but would simply raise the computing cost.
Case Setup and Execution
Below are the steps for the case setup.
Geometry
Import the geometry provided to you.
Open the geometry in spaceclaim
Remove out the material which is not required for the simulation.
Materials
Keep the material default ( Structural Steel ).
Connections
Contacts
Create the contact between all the teeth surfaces of both the gears.
Change the contact type to friction with a co-efficient of 0.2
Change the behavior to symmetric
Chagent the contact formulation to Augmented Lagrange.
Change the Interface treatment to Adjust to Touch.
Joints
Give body to ground joint to both the gears selecting the ID of the both gears.
Change the joing type to revolute.
Mesh
Select all the contact faces and give them sizing mesh.
Change the element size to 1.75 mm.
Chang the global element size according to the cases.
Case 1 - 6 mm.
Case 2 - 5 mm.
Case 3 - 4 mm.
Boundary Condition
Analysis Settings
Change the analysis settings to the following.
Total no. of Steps - 6
Auto time stepping - ON
Define by - Time
Initial Time Step - 0.2s.
Minimum Time Step - 0.1s.
Maximum Time Step - 1s.
Joint Load 1 - Big Gear
Type - Moment
Give the moment of -10000 N-mm to all the step 1 to step 6.
Joint Load 2 - Small Gear
Type - Rotation
Give the rotation of 20 deg in increment to the step wise.
Results of Case 1
Total Deformation
Maximum Deformation in Case 1 is
Minimum Deformation in Case 1 is
Equivalent Stress
Maximum Equivalent Stress in Case 1 is
Equivalent Strain
Maximum Equivalent Stress in Case 1 is
Results of Case 2
Total Deformation
Maximum Deformation in Case 2 is
Minimum Deformation in Case 2 is
Equivalent Stress
Maximum Equivalent Stress in Case 2 is
Equivalent Strain
Maximum Equivalent Strain in Case 2 is
Results of Case 3
Total Deformation
Maximum Deformation in Case 3 is
Minimum Deformation in Case 3 is
Equivalent Stress
Maximum Equivalent Stress in Case 3 is
Equivalent Strain
Maximum Equivalent Strain in Case 3 is
Comparing the results
Below is the tabular result shown in terms of parameter setup for all the three cases
Conclusion
We ran a grid dependency test on bevel gear, and based on the above table, we can deduce that by adjusting the global size of the mesh, we gain significantly greater accuracy of the outcome. We can see that as the mesh is refined from 5mm to 4mm, we get a better approximation of the result for equivalent elastic strain and equivalent stress. However, running the simulation with even more mesh refinement would result in a very close approximation of the result with very little change in the result and a significant increase in computational power and time.