Challenge

Rayleigh Taylor Instability by Gaurav Shrivastava

AIM : To perform rayleigh taylor instability simulation using air and water as materials for different mesh sizes.

Rayleigh Taylor instability : It is an instability of interface that happens between a low density and high density fluid. If the heavier fluid suspended above a lighter fluid the heavier fluid moves downward due to gravity and the lighter fluid moves upward creating plumes and spikes. Over time the heavier fluid settles downward. Some common examples of Rayleigh Taylor instability that can be seen are :

1. Water above Oil

2. Mushroom cloud of Volcanic eruption or Nuclear explosion

3. Supernova explosions

4. Plasma fusion reactors

In this project numerical simulation is done using ANSYS Fluent and using volume of fluid(vof) multiphase model to understand Rayleigh Taylor instability. Simulations are performed for air and water using different mesh sizes and one set of simulation was done for water and oil in a refined mesh.

CFD models for Rayleigh Taylor waves:

1. Buoyancy Drag model : Uses ordinary differential equations to evolve the width of the mixing layer. The bubble, or spike, amplitudes are described by balancing the inertia, buoyancy and drag forces. These models cannot model multiple mixing interfaces and not suitable for two or three dimensions.

2. Single Fluid models: They consist of evolution equations for the turbulence kinetic energy and its dissipation rate or equivalent turbulence length scale.

  1. K - L model : The starting point is buoyancy drag model with modifications in i) a transport equation for the total energy, instead of the internal energy (ii) the turbulent diffusion of specific enthalpy instead
    of internal energy (iii) the implementation of the
    source term (SK) based on the mean flow and turbulence timescales and (iv) the calculation of the local Atwood number based on higher-order numerical approximations.
  2. K-L-a model : Extension of two equation K-L model by including a third equation for the turbulent mass flux velocity.
  3. K-L-a-b model : Extension of K-L-a model by adding an evolution equation for density specific volume covariance.

3. Two Fluid model : This model consist of system of Navier Stokes equation for each phase. The equations are averaged over space and time. Due to averaging of equations additional terms which includes all interfacial forces appears in momentum equation. The two-fluid model is usually used for dispersed flow (bubbly or droplet) but can also be used for free surface flow.

Results:

Case 1: Water and Air

Geometry

2D Geometry with dimension 20 mm x 40 mm. The top half will be occupied by water and bottom half will be occupied by air.

i) Baseline Mesh ( Element size = 0.5 mm)

No. of elements = 3200

Contours of Air volume fraction

ii) Refined Mesh ( Element size = 0.25 mm)

No. of elements = 12800

Contours of Air volume fraction

iii) Refined Mesh ( Element size = 0.1 mm)

No. of elements = 80000

Contours of Air volume fraction

Case 2: Water and Oil

Oil properties

Density: 400 kg/m^3

Viscosity: 1.06 kg/m-s

Mesh : Refined mesh with element size 0.1 mm

Contours of Oil volume fraction

Atwood number and its significance

Atwood number is a dimensionless number that describes the density difference between two adjacent fluids with common interface and is used to study the hydrodynamic instabilities. Mathematically Atwood number is given as:

`A = (rho1-rho2)/(rho1+rho2)`

where `rho1` = density of heavier fluid

and `rho2`= density of lighter fluid

Atwood number is an important parameter in the study of Rayleigh Taylor instability. The penetration of heavier fluid is a function of Atwood number.

In case 1

`rho1` = 1000

`rho2`= 1.225

A = 0.997

In case 2

`rho1` = 1000

`rho2`= 400

A = 0.428

After comparing the two cases we can see that the penetration of heavier fluid i.e. water is maximum in case 1 and this can be used to validate the simulation.

Conclusion

Rayleigh Taylor instability with water and other fluid being air and oil in respective case is studied. It can be said that with increase in mesh size it takes longer time for the two fluids to reach a steady state. Also viscosity plays an important role as can be seen in case of oil the surface takes longer to deform.

References

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/330266850_Modeling_of_Rayleigh-Taylor_mixing_using_single-fluid_models

Your portfolio, next

Ship work like this
in your own course.

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.