Cyclone Separator Challenge
AIM: To perform numerical analysis on cyclone seperator and calculate the seperation efficiency and pressure drop
Cyclone Seperator: Cyclone seperator are seperation devices that are used to filter out particulate matter from flue gases. Cyclone seperator uses principal of inertia and are generally suitable for heavier and larger particles. Cyclone seperator varies in sizes depending upon the seperation efficiency. A cyclone seperator works like a centrifuge, there is a continous feed of dirty gases inside the chamber. The inside wall of chamber produces a spiral vortex like a tornado. The lighter particles can easily follow the vortex but the heavier particles due to large inertia collides with the chamber wall and settle down at the bottom. These chambers are shaped like an upside-down cone to promote the collection of these particles at the bottom of the container. The cleaned flue gas escapes out the top of the chamber.
Source: https://energyeducation.ca/encyclopedia/Cyclone_separator
In this project 3D simulations are done in ANSYS Fluent to understand the effect of particle size and inlet velocity on collection efficiency of cyclone seperator.
Empirical models for cyclone efficiency
1. Iozia and Leith Model: This model is based on Force balance. It assumes that particle carried out by the vortex experiences two forces: Centifugal force and flow resistance
2. Li and Wang Model: This model includes particle bounce and re-entrainment. The assumption used in this model are (i) The radial particle velocity and radial concentration profile are not constant for uncollected particles inside the cyclone. (ii) Boundary condition are considered in accordance with turbulent diffusion and particle bounce entrainment. (iii) The tangential velocity is related to the radius of cyclone by: uR^n = Constant.
3. Koch and Licht Model: This model recognized the inherently turbulent nature of cyclone and distribution of gas residence times within cyclone. The additional assumption that this model used is that the tangential velocity of particle is equal to tangential velocity of gas flow i.e. there is no slip between gas and particles.
4. Lapple Model: This model is based on force balance without considering flow resistance. This model assumes that the particles are evenly distributed at inlet. The particle that travels from inlet half width to the wall in the cyclone is collected with 50% efficiency.
- Geometry
II. Mesh: Cutcell meshing was used to generate structural meshes and the total number of elements is 500k
III. Case 1
In the first case, simulation were run by varying the particle diameter from 1 `mu`m to 5 `mu`m. In all the cases the velocity of particles and air stream was set to 3 m/s. Anthracite particles were used and the different boundary conditions were:
Inlet = Reflect
Wall = Reflect
Outlet top = Escape
Outlet bottom = Trapped.
- Particle size = 1 `mu`m
| Tracked | Escaped | Trapped | Incomplete | Efficiency = (Trapped/Tracked) |
| 435 | 218 | 213 | 4 | 48.96 % |
2. Particle size = 2 `mu`m
| Tracked | Escaped | Trapped | Incomplete | Efficiency = (Trapped/Tracked) |
| 435 | 201 | 233 | 1 | 53.56 % |
3. Particle size = 3 `mu`m
| Tracked | Escaped | Trapped | Incomplete | Efficiency = (Trapped/Tracked) |
| 435 | 177 | 258 | 0 | 59.31 % |
4. Particle size = 4 `mu`m
| Tracked | Escaped | Trapped | Incomplete | Efficiency = (Trapped/Tracked) |
| 435 | 145 | 290 | 0 | 66.66 % |
5. Particle size = 5 `mu`m
| Tracked | Escaped | Trapped | Incomplete | Efficiency = (Trapped/Tracked) |
| 435 | 109 | 326 | 0 | 74.94 % |
Comparison
| Particle size | Efficiency |
| 1 `mu`m | 48.96 % |
| 2 `mu`m | 53.56 % |
| 3 `mu`m | 59.31 % |
| 4 `mu`m | 66.66 % |
| 5 `mu`m | 74.94 % |
From the table we can see that as the particle size increases the efficiency of cyclone also increases. As the size of the particle increases it becomes heavy and is unable to follow the path of vortex. The particles collide with the wall and settles down at the bottom.
IV. Case 2
In the second case the particle diameter was set to 5 `mu`m and the velocity of antracite particles and inlet velocity was varied from 1 m/s to 5 m/s. The effect of inlet velocity on efficiency of cyclone and pressure drop was studied.
1. Velocity = 1 m/s
| Tracked | Escaped | Trapped | Incomplete | Efficiency = (Trapped/Tracked) | Pressure Drop |
| 435 | 218 | 117 | 100 | 26.8 % | 1.138 Pa |
2. Velocity = 2 m/s
| Tracked | Escaped | Trapped | Incomplete | Efficiency = (Trapped/Tracked) | Pressure Drop |
| 435 | 162 | 273 | 0 | 62.75 % | 5.19 Pa |
3. Velocity = 3 m/s
| Tracked | Escaped | Trapped | Incomplete | Efficiency = (Trapped/Tracked) | Pressure Drop |
| 435 | 115 | 320 | 0 | 73.56 % | 12.575 Pa |
4. Velocity = 4 m/s
| Tracked | Escaped | Trapped | Incomplete | Efficiency = (Trapped/Tracked) | Pressure Drop |
| 435 | 73 | 362 | 0 | 83.22 % | 23.176 Pa |
5. Velocity = 5 m/s
| Tracked | Escaped | Trapped | Incomplete | Efficiency = (Trapped/Tracked) | Pressure Drop |
| 435 | 37 | 398 | 0 | 91.5 % | 37 Pa |
Comparison
| Velocity | Efficiency | Pressure Drop |
| 1 m/s | 26.8 % | 1.138 Pa |
| 2 m/s | 62.75 % | 5.19 Pa |
| 3 m/s | 73.56 % | 12.575 Pa |
| 4 m/s | 83.22 % | 23.176 Pa |
| 5 m/s | 91.5 % | 37 Pa |
From the table we can see that as the inlet velocity increases for both discrete phase and continous phase, both seperation efficiency and pressure drop increases.
Conclusion
Based on the two simulations performed we can see that the seperation efficiency is function of both inlet velocity and particle diameter. As the particle diameter increases, it is not able to follow the vortex path and gets settled down at the bottom. With increase in inlet velocity, particle cannot follow the vortex path and it collides with the cyclone wall due to inertia and gets settled down. Pressure drop accross cyclone also increases with increase in inlet velocity.