Lesson finished
Unlock all 57 lessons of Medical Product Design & DevelopmentFull course ₹40,000 · paid
Benchmarking, Systems Engineering, Safety and Rapid Prototyping
A free lesson from Skill-Lync's Medical Product Design & Development course, on Grow by Skill-Lync · Last updated 16 Nov 2026 · Session: “Week 1 Session 3”
What will you learn in this free Medical Product Design & Development lesson?
The instructor covers benchmarking through vehicle teardown, system-based engineering, CAD and finite element analysis, and reliability tools such as FMEA. The lesson also explains passive and active car safety, manufacturing readiness levels, sustainability, and prototyping with 3D printing, injection molding, sheet metal and CNC machining.
- Benchmarking and system-based engineering design
- FMEA, risk register and root-cause analysis
- Manufacturing readiness levels 1 to 4
- 3D printing, injection molding and CNC machining
What comes after lesson 3?
Later in Skill-Lync's Medical Product Design & Development course (paid): lesson 4, Week 1 Session 4; lesson 5, Week 2 Session 1; lesson 6, Week 2 Session 2. The full course has 57 lessons (22 h 11 min of video); see the course overview or its price and syllabus.
Lesson transcript
Machine transcript of the lesson audio (lightly cleaned). Technical terms may contain errors; the video is the reference.
In this section, we'll be talking about product design and development techniques. The first technique a product designer usually uses is doing benchmarking. It means that the product team wants to compare the performance metrics to the industrial standards to make sure where they are in their design. Benchmarking involves identifying the baseline quality, time, and cost of the product so that they will only want to do better than the benchmarking baseline. The benefits of benchmarking is it can provide competitive analysis to identify the pros and cons of their design compared to their competitors in the market so that they can intentionally improve certain aspects of their design to make the product more competitive.
Benchmarking also can help doing planning and goal settings for their business plans. Since they will do surveys about the advantages and scale of their competitors' products, they can design their own business plans so that they can differentiate their features with others. They can also understand their advantages in their designs. The procedures of benchmarking will involve planning and collecting information. Usually, they can find reports in the public domains or consult a third-party company to do a product evaluation. There are many services in the industry that will do benchmarking for their customers.
For example, in the case of a car, they will tear down one of the competitor's car and then do analysis for each individual component. In the end, they will do analysis and write the reports of their benchmarking tests and then produce actionable items so that they can implement into their product design. Here's one example for full vehicle benchmarking. So there's many companies offer those services. So their business model is solely to provide their customers, including a car company and OEM companies to perfect their products. In these benchmarking studies, they will tear down the vehicle, in this case, electric vehicles.
They will analyze the chassis of the vehicle from a mechanical design perspective. They will also study the drivetrain design, including the electric motors, inverters, and batteries. They will do in-house testing for these components and see how their product will perform at different conditions, including very extreme operating scenarios. In the end, they will generate all testing data and then write the test reports. They will also sell the test reports as a package to their customers. Benchmarking is also something a big company can do on their own instead of asking outside companies to do for them.
By benchmarking, the company knows the strength and weakness of their designs so that they have more focus on the area they want to improve. So benchmarking is a powerful tool used in the current industry to stay competitive. Another very important design methodology is system-based engineering design. The system engineering is a very hot topic nowadays because the products are becoming increasingly complex. There are so many subsystems involved in the products. Each of those has special functions and design requirements. So the system-based design methodology helps to identify the procedures and the systematic approach to break the integrated product into subcomponents.
And then doing design and testing for each individual component before they integrate them together. So the system-based design engineering is very useful to manage complex systems over their lifecycle. This engineering design approach usually starts with the definition of the system and subsystem requirements and functions. Then they will design the subsystems individually to make sure they meet their target requirements. Because those subsystems are designed usually in parallel, they need to define the interfaces between those so that they will make the handshake eventually to work together in the integrated fashion.
The interface definition is very important. The interface definition is very important. Usually the design teams for both systems who are impacted by the interface will sit together to make sure they agree upon those interface specifications. And then they can design their own systems without the interactions between the other teams. And then in the end, once the subsystems are successfully designed and manufactured, they will do design verification and validation. Typically that involves testing and visual inspections or putting into the real test environment to check their performance.
Once those subsystem designs are validated, they will integrate those subsystems together into the final products and then perform integration tests and then final system tests. In the end, they will have working products so that they can ship to their customer. Another very important technique in the design stage is computer-aided design or CAT. CAT modeling is using a computer in the creation, analysis and optimization of the designs. Computer programming is relatively quick and simple compared to physical modeling. It can also reduce the development time and cost.
Design teams in different domains and different physical locations can collaborate with each other easily using CAT programs. Typical functions of CAT software will involve 3D modeling and joints. They will create realistic 3D models representing the real dimensions, the appearance and functions. And then they can also produce engineering joints in 2D so that they can share with manufacturing departments to manufacture. There are also CAT programs for electronic circuit designs. They are also doing finite element analysis in different physical domains such as electromagnetics, structural, thermal, and fluid.
The finite element analysis is using computer algorithms to solve physical equations. They can model very complex geometries such as a race car as you can show on the right. In this example, they use FEA software to solve air dynamic flow so that they can analyze the air dynamic drag. They can improve the designs based on the air flows and the stress and the air distributions around the vehicles. So those CAT programs are very important and efficient in the product design cycle. Using them together is what we call a virtual design studio where everything is computerized design before they finalize those designs and making the prototype and the final product.
So... Here are some examples of typical design software in the CAT domain. For 3D modeling and drawing creations, typical software are including NX from Siemens, SOLIDWORKS, where a lot of educational institutes provide a student license, and also CATIA, ProE, and AutoCAD. Each of these software have their unique features and functions, but they share similar fundamental capabilities. If a designer knows how to use one software, it will be relatively easy to migrate into other platforms. The 3D modeling and design software will also have more advanced capabilities, such as Pelican modeling and mesh modeling.
So those software are used in the design of more advanced products or animations in the product design and film industry. Those software will have more features to manipulate complex shapes and curvatures. For example, those software will have Blender, which is an open source software, Rhino, Model, and Strata Design 3D. In the case of finite elements analysis software, there's also many companies provide those capabilities. One of those is ANSYS, which now become one of the industrial standards for analyzing mechanical and thermal and fluid. Another very important subject in the product design is design for reliability.
Reliability is an engineering domain that includes the reliability analysis in the design process. There are many tools used in the reliability engineering. One of those is finite element analysis. For example, for a car, there are so many structure bodies. Finite element analysis in the structural domain is used to analyze the stress distribution and also to analyze how the vehicle will deform in a crash situation so that the engineer will have the information to modify the design so that the parts get easily crashed, will be using a high strength steel material.
And then the parts that have less impact can use light aluminum materials. Another one is a tolerant analysis. In the reliability engineering, if something is out of tolerance, that will have a potential higher failure rate. So early capture, those failure potentials will increase the reliability. There's also hazard and operability studies, failure mode effect analysis, and also design reviews. The failure mode effect analysis is a domain which analyzes the potential ways of failure in the components or as a whole products. They will identify the probability of those failures.
And then evaluate the severity of those failures. In the end, the design team will come up with mitigation plans to reduce those severity or probability of those failures. There's another very important topic is design for safety. Safety design is also a methodology to incorporate safety concepts into every design stages. For some products, safety is of primary importance, such as cars or airplanes, because any failure could lead to catastrophic consequences. There are many tools used in the safety engineering, such as requirement management, risk register and management, system safety hazard analysis, and so on.
For example, the goal of the risk register is to identify the potential risks and then document it in a systematic way. The risk register can be produced at different stages of the design. For example, in a preliminary design, once the architecture of the product was defined, the design engineer will work with other departments such as manufacturing and process development to identify the potential risks in terms of design, manufacturing and use cases. And then they will manage those risks by figuring out plans to reduce those risks and the executable action items.
Another technique is to use 4-2 analysis in safety engineering. 4-3 analysis is a method to identify the root cause of that failure. Typically, the designers will use a block diagram to identify the causes for the risk for different levels. Typically, the 4-3 will have at least four or five layers. The bottom layer will be the fundamental cause for that failure. So safety is a very important subject. In the later weeks, we'll have a specific section to talk about design for safety. Let's see an example of how safety engineering was implemented in the car design.
In this case, there are two kinds of safety systems, passive safety and active safety systems. In the passive safety systems, usually the design engineer designs the special mechanical components to improve the crash worthiness to protect the passenger. For example, in the front side of the car. For example, in the front side of the car, usually there's a crumple zone. In case the car crashes into other vehicles or roadsides, it will just deform the front side of the vehicle to absorb the kinetic energy so that the energy will not be passed on to the passenger compartments.
Also, seat belt is used to fix the passenger onto the seat in case of sudden deceleration. Airbags are the cushion zones that help to prevent damage in case the passengers fall out of the seat. Also, the headrest is a passive safety system to protect the net injury when the car suddenly accelerates. In terms of active safety systems, typically these are electronics and software systems. For example, the anti-lock braking system is an electronic protection system that prevents the wheel disc to be locked during braking. Because completely locking the disc of the car sometimes will lead to uncontrolled maneuvers and lead to a crash.
So by using anti-lock braking, the brake pad will break and release the pedals at a very high frequency so that it will still enable the driver to remain in control of the vehicle. The electronic stability control is another device that will remain in control of the vehicle even at extreme conditions such as a very slippery road. So the vehicle will always within stable control of the driver. The automatic emergency braking system is an active system where it will constantly monitor the distance between the vehicle and anything in front of it.
If it detects a very dramatic decrease in the distance, the system will engage the emergency brake so that the car will not crash into the front vehicle. There is also a lane departure warning system where if the vehicle is not operating in that lane, it will just send warning signals to the driver. Sometimes an even advanced feature will have auto lane departure correction so that it will help the driver auto correct the steering wheel to remain vehicle in the center line of the lane. Another very important subject in the product design is design for manufacturability.
A great product will not only be having great features and easy to use, but also easy to manufacture and have low cost during the manufacturing process. So design for manufacturability is an important subject to facilitate these requests. One important subject to observe, there is one important subject to evaluate. The manufacturing maturity level at the different stages, what we call manufacturing readiness level, or MRL. So this readiness level is used to quantify the maturity of manufacturability at each stages. This is a managerial methodology, so that it will provide information to identify any rigs that could happen in the manufacturing process, so that they can be prepared for prototyping and later mass production.
Let's take a look at what those numbers mean. The table on the right shows there's three phases of manufacturing readiness. Phase 1 is the technology assessment to prove the concept works. Phase 2 is the pre-production stage. Phase 3 is the production implementation stage. In phase 1, the manufacturing readiness level ranges from 1 to 4. Phase 1 means that the concept was proposed with scientific validation. Phase 2 means the application and vatility of concept are validated and demonstrated for the manufacture process. Phase 3 is experimental proof of concept are completed.
Phase 4 means production are validated in the lab environment. Phase 4 means that the maturity of the manufacturing process goes to the second phase, where the basic capabilities of manufacturing are demonstrated and the processes are optimized for the production equipment. Phase 4 means that the final phase will confirm the capability and the production rate, so that the full production process can be qualified. In the end, the full production process can be validated so that the parts can go into mass production. So the MRAO are very important tools to give leadership a guideline that was the maturity of the product design level so that they can use those numbers to work with the project management team so that they can identify any problems early in the program and then mitigate those problems so that they can stay within the product schedule.
So let's see one example for the car chassis design. The conventional design and manufacturing method is to design the individual pieces in a car body and then weld them together. This is a very complicated process because the body of the car and then weld them together. This is a very complicated process because the body of the car contains hundreds if not thousands of parts. Each of these parts are made of stamped aluminum sheets so that in the assembling line, the robots will weld those sheets together so that it will become a full car body.
However, this design and manufacturing process involves a lot of steps and a lot of robotic motion. It's complicated and time consuming. However, the latest innovation in automotive engineering proposed the casting of the car body instead of stamping and welding. So the casting process is a different manufacturing process. It uses melted metal that is injected into a mold so that the car body pieces can be casted in under a second, which is very fast. Each car casting pieces is almost identical to the other parts so that it can maintain the quality.
The single piece casting in the rear body and front body significantly reduces the production time and complexity. And then there's less room for error. By changing the manufacturing process, the time and cost of manufacturing the car chassis will be significantly reduced so that the overall car price can also be reduced. Another important concept is designed for environmental sustainability. Design products to have a minimal impact to the environment. You can see a picture on the right. This is a circular economy where the products are made from natural resources such as tree or wood.
And then during the material processing, those raw materials are made into the parts of the products. And then the parts are manufactured into the final products and being shipped to the customer. The customers use the products and after the end life cycle of the products, those devices will be either disposed or recycled. Then they will enter into the earth with a sustainable cycle or non-sustainable cycles. Some of the sustainable materials can be reused to produce other products so that it will have less waste to the world.
So the design concept in the design for environmental sustainability will include to have a minimum resource consumption in the product. If the raw material volume is less in the product, naturally it will have less impact to the extraction or processing stage of the process. And also select low impact resources and process. For example, extraction for the wood is relatively simple and less harmful to the environment compared to extracting some rare earth materials such as cobalt. Another concept is to extend the lifespan of the products so that the user will spend more time using the product without frequent replacements.
So that will have less environmental impact overall. For example, some of the light bulbs are made of adolescent light where the typical operating timeframe is about like a year or two. However, the latest light bulbs are made of LED technology where they can use much longer timeframe, sometimes in order for 10 years. So that one will significantly reduce the replacement frequency. And also the LED light bulb will have less energy consumption to produce the same looming compared to adolescent light. Another concept is to facilitate assembling and disassembling and recycle.
For by the end lifecycle of the products, some parts in the devices can be recycled, such as aluminum, if the designs make the disassembling easy and smooth. The disassembling process will require less effort. And also if those parts can be easily separated, the recycling process can also be easier. So these are the ways to make the product more environmentally friendly so that during the full economic cycle of the products, they can be reused to produce the next products without harming the environment. Another technique in the product design and development is the rapid prototyping.
Rapid prototyping refers to the design and manufacturing techniques that can quickly fabricate a product at a scale using a 3D computer design. Some of the rapid prototyping tools will include 3D printing, injection molding, sheet metal fabrication, CNC machining. This process will facilitate quick design iterations so that the design engineer will have mature designs in a shorter timeframe. Let's take a little bit of a close look at these tools. The 3D printing tools is getting popular nowadays. Because of its flexibility and decentralized printing capability. Another way to say 3D printing is additive manufacturing process.
This is in contrast to subtractive manufacturing process where the materials are taken away from the block. The 3D printing or additive manufacturing process is to produce the products layer by layer. There are many different technologies in 3D printing. One of the most common types is fused deposition modeling. There is a picture on the right showing that 3D printing. This is where the thermoplastic are extruded through a very hot nozzle so that it will be melted into droplets and will be deposited onto the bat. So that by using 3-axis motion, the components can be created layer by layer.
Another way to produce a polytap is to use injection molding. Usually, this is done for some plastic components. In order to make those components, first, they need to create the mold tools, which is typically made of metal. Then, the melted plastic are injected into the molding and then let it cool down to form into shape. Once it's completed, the mold can be opened and the parts can be taken out from the mold. The sheet metal fabrication is using sheet metal, but typically using different kinds of cutting machine to cut the metal into shape.
Those cutting methods involve laser cuttings, electric discharge machining, or water jets. Each of these types of cutting methods will have different properties in terms of heat affected zones, the scale of production, and the speed of production. So, depending on the use case, selecting a proper cutting method will be important. The CNC machining tool refers to computer numerical controlled machining. This is using computer programs to control the motion of that cutting machine. Usually, the conventional machines involve milling and turning. So, in the later weeks, we'll have dedicated sessions to talk about rapid prototyping, especially 3D printing.
Let's see one example for 3D printing. In this picture, you can see that the body of the car is actually 3D printed. You can see the hood, the bumpers are made of thermal plastic, and you can see the textures of the 3D printing. The 3D printing is widely used in the industry nowadays for composites or even metal materials printings. For metals, there's a 3D technology, which is called the director metal sintering process, where they use a powder metal that is heated to a higher temperature so that they can be melted and then formed together.
Usually, the 3D printed metal parts are stronger than the conventional methods, and many car companies using this technology to custom-made their car parts, which is difficult to make from a conventional machining perspective. There are also companies using 3D printing technology to rapidly create their parts. For example, a rocket engine, they can use the 3D metal printing technology to print a nozzle of the engine in just a few days instead of weeks from manufacturing process in the conventional domain. So, there's a really bright future of 3D printing that can be used in a variety of industries, not only for vehicle aerospace, but also for consumer products.
So, this is only the beginning of 3D printing. There's more technology that are being developed right now, so I encourage you to study more in your free time.