Lesson finished
Up next: Automotive Paint Shop Process from ED Coating to Inspection
Unlock all 24 lessons of Automotive Sheet Metal Design using CATIA V5Full course ₹40,000 · paid
Design Engineering Process and Benchmarking Case Studies
A free lesson from Skill-Lync's Automotive Sheet Metal Design using CATIA V5 course, on Grow by Skill-Lync · Last updated 16 Nov 2026 · Session: “Design Engineering Process Overview”
What will you learn in this free Automotive Sheet Metal Design using CATIA V5 lesson?
The instructor describes how CAD construction levels, CAE feedback on producibility and crash, blank release and supplier quotations lead to a frozen design. He then works through benchmarking examples, including underbody coating on two cars and a weight comparison of two body structures.
- CAD levels and CAE feedback on crash and producibility
- Blank release and why the design freezes
- Supplier RFQ and choosing between quotations
- Car-level and part-level benchmarking reports
What comes after lesson 2?
The next free lesson is lesson 3, “Automotive Paint Shop Process from ED Coating to Inspection” (5 min). Later in Skill-Lync's Automotive Sheet Metal Design using CATIA V5 course (paid): lesson 4, Surface Modeling Basics Using CATIA; lesson 5, Hood Design and Engineering; lesson 6, Hood Design Considerations. The full course has 24 lessons (7 h 40 min of video); see the course overview or its price and syllabus.
Lesson transcript
Machine transcript of the lesson audio (lightly cleaned). Technical terms may contain errors; the video is the reference.
There will be three level of CAT constructions. Level 1, Level 2 and Level 3. On all these three stages, on all these three stages, you will be designing the commodity what you are responsible of and you will be sending the data to a CAE team. CAE team is a team which will be analyzing your data on their computers by meshing them and doing their own activities to justify whether your design is right or not. And what will be the major activities what they do is to study whether the part is producible and the crash requirements.
These two are highly major activities which every new part you design will undergo. So, at this situation, you would have constructed your part and you will give this to your CAE team. When I give this to my CAE team, these guys will study and give me a feedback. Not all the design you draw will be correct. So, there might be some feedbacks what your CAE colleagues will give. And these feedbacks are the ones what you will have to implement on your Level 2. And once you implement the same on your CAD construction, you will again give the data to the CAE colleagues for them to validate whether this is right or not.
And when you do this, you have a final judgment like, okay, whatever I have done is right. And this, I have the report like, okay, CAE guys have told me like, I have got a green signal for the producibility. And I have got a green signal for the crash requirements. And after this, I will start preparing my data for my blank. What is this blank data? For every product you design, you will have to have a tool which is producing it. And how is your raw material going to be, how are you going to get the same on your final stage is what is the data you give as a blank release.
Once you have released this data, you cannot make any changes over the data as the design is getting freezed here. If your design is freezed, then that's it. And that is why there will always be Level 1, Level 2, Level 3, Level 4, these many levels of constructions to justify that there will no more be changes on my datas after I release it to the blank. When I release it to the blank, I will start coordinating with suppliers if needed. Not all the parts you produce it on your own plant.
There are some parts which will not debit the styling to the consumers, to the suppliers. And those parts, I normally give it to the suppliers. For example, I will not give a hood outer panel to a supplier. I will not give a side door outer panel to a supplier. Because that is actually depicting the look of the car. I will not give a body side outer to a supplier. I will do it by myself. So, which means most of the outer panels are made within the facility, within the OEM.
And the reinforcements inside, the inner panels inside are given to the suppliers with an agreement. And with respect to that, they will be quoting you the cost. We will give the part to the supplier and request them for quotation. That is RFQ. And this request, the suppliers will study and give them the cost what they will need to produce this part. And you discuss with your own purchase team and see whether this cost is sufficient or this cost is really okay for the OEM, for our company.
Whether this cost is falling under the budget which was given to you. And you say, okay, let us go ahead. And you do not give it to only one supplier and finalize him. We give it to three, four suppliers. And we finalize one supplier who is better in producibility and better in cost also. Sometimes, finalizing the supplier is not only based on the cost or reduced price what he quotes, but also by the perfect part he gives out. By the exact part output what he wants to give out.
So, sometimes I have given my quotation to three people or four peoples and one guy have given me less cost, but his facilities is not that good to produce a good tolerance or good finalized part. But another supplier who has given me an additional cost, an increased cost, but he has better facilities to produce more better part. In that situation, I as an engineer will choose the second guy because I can ensure the product output, product part quality. And this is what is design engineering and you will be a part of this phase in this course.
You will be asked to design a commodity. You will be given the input surfaces and you will be asked to prepare the internal geometry what has been there or what is available inside the commodity. Right. And this is what is design engineering phase. Once the supplier is also fixed and then we get into the development engineering and this is the place where you really develop the design what you made. Whatever you did in computer will now be done live. And this development phase is the one which is real critical and real important phase where whatever you did in computer, you will be doing it live.
Now, your supplier is finalized, your design is finalized, your market is also finalized. You have all the inputs now, you will have to just produce the part. And that is why design engineering phase is a very important phase because you can no more change the part and you have all the rights to change the nature of the part and no one else in the manufacturing team or the development engineering team has this opportunity. You will be the one who designs what your part is. You will be the one who decides how your part should behave.
And that is why design engineering phase is real critical phase. And this will take again 2 to 3 years. So, now we have already done with 3 years. Almost 3 years is done to start the development activity of the car what we are going to produce to the market. And now we get into the development engineering. And this development engineering is just the coordination with the plant colleagues and the suppliers. Because by this time they would have started producing the tools and these tools you will have to go and justify whether it is producing the part what you had as a design intention.
They will now produce proto parts 1, proto parts 2, proto parts 3, 4 etc. Most of the times it is up to proto 3. Proto 1 and 2 will be a physical where you will start receiving physical parts and you will check for the design intention. And when you check the design intention you will understand what the purpose is and what was your design intention and whether it is meeting or not. And this checking we do with various type of machines like CMM machines, sometimes Vernier calipers also from the basic and this will be PT1 build.
This will be a kind of live or a very practical or very normal kind of assembling the parts. And now you start developing your line where you will be assembling the part on live. That situations you might get some assembly constraints, assembly problems. And these problems you as an engineer will address and take countermeasures so that your part is properly built on the line which is there. Most of the time there is no new line developed for every individual car. The production assembly line will be one line where you adopt that line to the production of your part.
Right? Adopt where you change your situations easily and quickly so that there are 3-4 car lines which has been built on one single assembly line. Right? Whenever you see some videos, you do not see only one vehicle coming out of one line. Right? Or one model coming out of one line. We see 2-3 models which means that assembly line is capable of adopting these many variations within that situation. Right? And then you build the final vehicle where you start doing internal test, quality check will be there and then you give a go ahead so the start of production starts.
Start of production is the normal production line. What it happens regularly and from there the mass production starts. And once the mass production starts, once the customer starts buying your car, you start getting concerns from the market. And there is a team called JDP and these guys are the ones who are evaluating your car and they will be scoring your cars. More your score is, more your score is, more bad your car is. Less your score, more better your car is. So, it will be always like every OEM will be working on reducing the score of what JDP gives.
JDP is JDPower. That is an organization who does this analysis by meeting the consumers directly via all showrooms or all service centers. Right? And they will be scoring the cars. And your job after you develop the part and give it to the consumer is to address the concerns what you get from the market and reduce that concern by taking temporary and permanent countermeasure. This will also be one separate session where you will be learning more in detail like how the concerns might be and how we will be taking countermeasures.
And this slide is a very important slide for every engineer who wants to be inside an automotive industry. This is what is, I have made this individual. I have separated all these four stages individually and put it on different slides so that you don't forget any points now. Starting from concept preparation where you decide what your target segment is, target market is, what is your type of car and what is your volume you are expecting to produce the car. And benchmarking one is define who our competitors are, what their price is, specifications and features on the segment what you are going to give the car for.
Carry over study is, create a list of parts which falls under the scope for us to carry over and then we segregate what parts we are going to produce new and what parts we are going to carry over from the previous stage. And then the benchmarking two where you develop the part component wise comparison from the competitors vehicle to reduce the weight or to improve the performance of the car. Reducing weight itself is improving the performance and then the design engineering stage where you will have different levels of constructions and the first level we prepare this design concept sheet.
And the next level we establish internal loops with the CAE team and other plant production guys. And next we complete the CAD construction, we design release it to the suppliers and we also finalize who our supplier will be. And in the development engineering we coordinate with our suppliers, we get the tooling confirmation and then we start building the prototype one, proto two and final production. And on every line we do get some flaws and how do we address those flaws is also one of our important activity as a design engineer since only you know what the design intention is and what your car is going to perform and how your car is going to perform.
What was your design intention only you as a design engineer you will know and then the market survey where you start the sales and you start getting customer feedback and as I told you, you have this JDP test and you start reducing the score to improve the quality of the vehicle and this is what we call it as quality improvement area. So, to completely develop a car and sell it to the market, it normally takes 3 to 4 years. But still there are cars which has been developed on a very less number of years, say Datsun Go was developed and sold it to the car within 3 years.
There are still cars which are done less than 3 years also. But more time you spend on a car, more less you get concerns. For developing a facelift of Alto, you don't need 3 to 4 years. You will just need 2 years because there will be only very less number of new parts and you need only less number of time to develop them. So, when you are completely developing, completely producing a new car, you need this long time. Doing a facelift, you don't need 3 to 4 years.
Maybe the time will reduce by almost 50% and this is what is called as vehicle development process and this is very similar to all the automotive OEMs. This is not specific to any particular OEMs. This is similar to any automotive OEMs. Every industry will have a similar cycle to produce a car and this is a very critical and an important stage. And this we call as vehicle development process, what every automotive aspiring engineer should know. And this is where you as an engineer will start. And after this, like what I told, every stage will be now concentrated.
From benchmarking till start of production to sales, every stage will be now concentrated. So that you experience what is happening on each stage and how do I work as a design engineer on every stage. Like what we saw in our last classes, we understood the vehicle development process and to start developing a car, the first thing what we need is benchmarking. So now, like what I told you, we will be taking it as a progress from the initial level to the final level so that we understand all the different phases as a design engineer.
So that we also inculcate the development process and the design activities. We start with the benchmarking activity. And like I told you, benchmarking is a comparison between similar products or process or the services, right? So this we will be taking with respect to some case studies, right? So as I told you, benchmarking, there are two types, benchmarking one and benchmarking two. And this differentiations, we will be learning via a case study, okay? So now, I am going to be one of the OEM engineers, one of the design engineers and I am going to do certain benchmarking analysis.
I will be performing now both benchmarking one activity and benchmarking two activity. So now, when we see, this is going to be the case study one, where we are going to study the underbody coating differences between an etios and a figo. And for this, I am going to be one of the OEM engineers and for this, I am going to understand the material composition, I am using niton XLT, right? So this is going to be a kind of report or a case study, where I am going to differentiate the underbody coating between etios and figo.
Since we are all engineers now, this is going to be your first assignment, I am requesting you people, please prepare a one-pager report about what underbody coating is, right? This is going to be your first assignment. And yeah, I am going to use elcometer for measuring the thickness and I am going to use niton XLT to understand what composition does my underbody coating has. Now, this is going to be the Toyota etios' front side and the rear side and figo's front side and the rear side.
This is the exact bottom view. We were not able to get an exact bottom view of etios, so we have used a similar image. So we understand what is the front end and the rear end. And here, I am going to first mark what is going to be the underbody coating region or where all the underbody coating is being given on an etios and on a figo. If we see here, in etios, the region is comparatively very less. This one slide is giving us a lot of information, right or not?
Because from the etios side, we see like the region for the underbody coating is really less when compared to figo. This gives us a lot of information. What all information does it give me extra? This car is now produced only for Indian market and this car is produced for both India and European market. In European market, there are standards which defines what should be your underbody coating thickness. You cannot bypass that standard and if you bypass, you get problems from the government. And so, instead of differentiating or producing number of variants, figo has decided to give underbody coating on all areas and to all markets.
This might be one of the biggest reasons for figo to have underbody coating on all regions. Second reason is, now I am already spending a lot of money than etios to figo. When a consumer spends a lot of money on figo, he might expect more better feature in the car. And this will be one of the advertising tactics for the figo to sell the cars like I have a strong underbody coating. And this will be one of the selling factors for the figo than etios. And there are similar reasons.
One can identify or differentiate a lot of reasons by just looking at this image. And this is how, as an engineer, we will have to present ourselves. What is the average thickness of the materials found? Now, comparing the tired etios. Now, talking about the tired etios, the thickness on the front crossmember region was between 24 to 26 micrometers. And on the front crossmember extension, that is a little behind the front crossmember region, the thickness was almost 20 micrometers. And the same case for the figo, if you see, the front filler, the thickness is heavy.
It is almost between 120 micrometers to 600 micrometers. And this is covered on all regions. And this intensity also says us like, the underbody coating in figo is very heavy when compared with tired etios, which is for Indian roads, I would suggest to go for a figo than going to an etios. And this is the way, whenever we do a comparison, we give an output of what the product is. We need not even suggest what to be chosen. The output itself will give the suggestion. Similarly, on the rear area of tired etios, you find 30 to 32 microns.
Whereas, again in the rear area, the thickness is almost between 400 to 700 region. And this is the average thickness of the underbody coating, what has been given between Toyota ETS and Ford Figo. And when I do this, I now indicate what Figo's standard is and what etios' standard is with respect to the underbody coating criteria. If underbody coating is not my criteria, I will be talking about the features inside the car. When I do this Toyota ETS or Ford Figo comparison, I also, for justification side, maybe Ford Figo is a car which is exaggerating some values.
So, now I also talk about other cars like Indica, Vista and it will be... Astonishing for more peoples like the value of Indica Vista stands way ahead than what Fort Figo is, right? And all these area has underbody sealants for Tata Indica Vista. And if you see Hyundai i10, again when compared to Toyota ETS, it is little better. When compared to Figo, it is less. And in this case also, Indica Vista stays way ahead on the region at which it have attacked the underbody coating. And this kind of comparison, when I do, I will understand like, okay, these guys are my competitors.
Now I am going to make a car on the i10 segment. So I will see like, okay, thickness of underbody on i10 is between 1 to 6 millimeters. So I will also target around 6 millimeters so that I am not bad than my competitor. If I have a lot of budget, I will even target for 7 or 8 millimeters so that I am good than my competitor. The image what you create or the results what you generate during this stage will give the input for your design phase.
So you cannot just exaggerate values here. We love to be accurate on what value you present here because this is going to be the input for the design phase. And when this input is not right, your complete design phase is going to go wrong. And this is the case for all the comparisons. This is just one study about the underbody spray. But this is going to be the case for all the concerns, all the regions, right? So this kind of benchmarking is really important so that we give the exact or the required input for the design phase.
And this is A star which is, if you see, in this segment, A star is much better than the i10. It gives up to 7 millimeters area. And now when I am going to prepare a new car, I will be studying all my competitors like i10 is a competitor, A star is a competitor. And with respect to these values, I will be deciding what value I should have in my own car. And this is what is the input what you give to the design team. This is one type of benchmarking style.
And the other benchmarking way is, now I am going to prepare an automatic transmission vehicle in India. I wanted to see which are all the cars which is having automatic transmission. So I take some examples and I compare what the price is and what their segment is. So that, now in the first slide, I say like, okay, these are all the car which has the CVT variant in my country. And I am going to prepare an additional CVT car to my country. And what am I or how am I going to differentiate these cars?
How am I going to understand the features of the car? I start preparing from the aspects like, these are all every individual's tactics, okay? If you are going to do, instead of this variant or this box, you can give some other variant. You can use your own way to depict the nature of the car. But, I will give you only one slide where you can talk about Maruti Suzuki A-Star. And in this slide, I will have to talk about all the factors. What is good? What is bad?
What is needed as an Indian? Every Indian talks about mileage. So I prepare mileage as a separate factor. And I highlight the cost of the vehicle. For 4.5 lakhs, I get a CVT and the mileage is also almost 15 to 16 km per litre. And this looks cool for me. But, I do not suggest this. I do not recommend this because I have a very bad legroom and a headroom. Say, I am 6 feet tall. So, I have a very bad and rear legroom. So, I do not suggest this.
Apart from that, this 4.37 and 15 litre mileage and a CVT variant is really recommended for me. And so, next, when I look at I-10, this I will be recommended. I will take it as a recommendation because I am a tall guy. This seating arrangement is also a kind of tall boy car segment. And mileage is also similar. But, I spend only 50 or 60,000 extra to get this CVT. And, I go for I-20 now. I-20 price is little high. So, I do not recommend this.
Apart from that, all other features are quite satisfactory for me. But, I cannot afford to spend 8 lakhs for a small car. Because, that does not fall under my budget. So, I do not. This is what you prefer. This star rating, what you see here and above is what your preference is. There are some situations where people will ask your suggestions. There are some situations you do not have to give any suggestions at all. There are some situations where you give just your comparison. And, this is I-20.
And, now talking about the Skada Rapid. And, when I talk about Rapid, this is again a costly car. So, I do not recommend. Apart from that, all features are similar. And, when I talk about Skada Rapid, I wanted to tell you another important factor. Like, Rapid and Volkswagen Vento are same cars. It is just the cross badging. Volkswagen Vento was built. Design and development was sold to Rapid for a particular price. Where, they just changed their logos. Wherever you find VW inside a Vento car, it will be replaced by Skada symbol and the Skada.
Apart from that, it is both are exactly the same cars. And, this is a known agreement globally. And, this is very similar to what you see on Renault and Nissan. Renault Pulse is a very same car of Nissan Micra. Nissan Micra was developed first and then it was given Renault Pulse. Nissan Sunny was made first and then Renault Scala was made. It is again the cross badging. At least in Renault and Nissan Alliance, there were small changes on their hood and fenders. But, Skada Rapid and Volkswagen Vento are completely same car.
Exactly same car. Except for the logo. This is just an additional thing which you can have it in your mind. And, SX4. SX4 is again highly recommended because I get a bigger car, I get a sedan vehicle and I also get it for a lesser price. I mean, for a sedan vehicle, 8.5 lakhs is kind of less. So, I would also recommend this if you have a little more budget. This is what? This is what is another case study of what benchmarking is. And, when it comes to benchmarking, it does not have any defined format.
It is how well you express your benchmarking capability. How well you express the differences of the nature. And, this is what is really, really important. And, this is what is expected from the OEM. Because, this input what you give is the input what you take for the design. And, this is the first benchmarking level which is a very simple concept, very simple level. Very simple and does not have any big technical or critical things. And, now, when you get into the benchmarking two segment, DAR plays a bigger role as a BAW engineer.
Now, I am going to differentiate or study the difference in weight. Because, I am a BAW engineer, I normally study the difference of weight between Mazda CX5 and Nissan's Murano. When I do this study, I will be first talking about their length, height, width, wheelbase, total BAW area. What is the total metal weight? How many parts are being used to complete the BAW? And, what is the part surface area? Out of which, our critical region is last four points. If you see the first four points, you could understand like the vehicle dimensions are little, little similar.
The height, width, wheelbase, these are all kind of very close enough. When you see a metal weight, the weight difference is almost 15 kilograms. 15 kgs is a big difference, right? When you can reduce 15 kgs in your car, it is a kind of a big achievement what you can make. The direct reason you see here, for the BAW of Nissan Murano, you need only 436 parts. But, for the BAW of CX5, you need 490 parts. Which means, you have increased, Nissan Mazda CX5 has increased almost 54 parts.
So, and this 15 kgs difference, first answer what you get is this 54 parts extra. And, where these 54 parts are extra? And, why this 15 kg difference? Is what? The study, what? You will be doing. To do that, we will first define the complete body in weight as 4 different parts. When I differentiate or when I divide the complete BAW weight into 4 different parts, I see cover. Cover is the closer components like the side doors and the back door. Body is the structure and the roof.
Floor is the underbody. Ncon is the engine compartment region. When I do this study, the major difference falls on the body BAW. Where, we as a body engineer should concentrate a lot. And, I see almost 26 kg difference in the complete BAW. When I see this 26 kg difference, then I get in deep to it and see why is there 26 kg difference. And, this 26 kg difference, I again segregate my BAW into various category like body side outer, front pillar outer, center pillar outer, sill is this bottom area, pillar assembly front, pillar assembly center.
This, all the outer panels will have some inner structures, rear pillar, rear panel outer, inner. So, I differentiate all these commodity into different parts. Here, I see, again, the major differences on the front pillar outer and the center pillar outer. This difference is almost 9 kgs and 7 kgs. Now, I will be studying, why did Murano have intentionally 9 kgs more weight and 7 kgs more weight on the front pillar and the center pillar alone. There might be 2-3 reasons. The first reason is, because of side impact test.
To get a better star rating on your side collision, side impact test, your car should perform better. These kind of additions of reinforcement. or addition of parts will make your assembly stronger. So, these weights are intentionally added to make your car perform better on the crash requirements. Right or not? So, this might be one of the reasons. One of the reasons for Mazda reducing it is, their target region was not the 5 star rating, but they would have been happy for the 3 star rating. For 3 star rating, your intrusion can be more inside. For 5 star rating, your intrusion should be little more lesser. During a collision, the deepness of your intrusion gives you the star rating. The more deeper, the more worse your star rating is. Right? Logic.
So, Mazda would have concentrated on a 3 star rating, whereas Murano would have concentrated on a 5 star rating. Might be this reason. When I compare this, I understand like, okay, they have concentrated a lot on front pillar and center pillar outer to improve their performance on the star ratings. And how is this 9 kgs? And how is this 9 kgs? And also, when compared to the weight. So, here we see the number of parts, which is less than 100 grams in Mazda CXY, between 100 to 50 grams, 500 grams, 500 grams to 1000 grams and above 1000 grams. You see the difference.
So, Mazda CXY has concentrated a lot on the weight this time. And another point is, due to addition of parts in the sub-assemblies, the number of parts in the stamping have increased in Mazda CXY. So, since Nissan Murano has combined parts, their weight was less. Mazda CXY segregated every parts and given individual thickness and more thickness. So, the weight of CXY is more. And that is the reason there is a difference of total number of parts. And this is called detailed benchmarking. What? Every engineer should understand or what? Even if you don't perform a detailed benchmarking, you will have to try to understand what the output of the benchmarking result is.
And now, the second exercise for the week. First exercise was quite a small exercise. And now, you will have to prepare a benchmarking report. I will be giving you a case and I wanted you to suggest a result. Which means, you got to recommend me with one option. No, I am Pugadendi. I am married and I am living in Bangalore. A kind of crowded city. And my family has five members, including my wife, my five-year-old boy, my father and my mother. I visit to my native place Madurai, which is almost 500 kilometers away from Bangalore.
And I am using the car to go to my office also. My budget is between 8 to 10 lakhs. And I wanted you people to suggest me with options. I am little fond of some big cars. This is just a small note. You need not even follow this. If you follow, then it is okay. If you could suggest me a car which is big also between 8 to 10 lakhs, then it is well and good. And these two are the exercises what I request you people to complete it within a week so that the next class, you will start with your direct design commodities.