Project

STEADY AND TRANSIENT ANALYSIS OF FLOW OVER A CYLINDER FOR LOW REYNOLDS NUMBER AND CAPTURING THE KARMAN VORTEX STREET USING ANSYS FLUENT.

PROJECT TITLE: STEADY AND TRANSIENT ANALYSIS OF FLOW OVER A CYLINDER FOR LOW REYNOLDS NUMBER AND CAPTURING THE KARMAN VORTEX STREET USING ANSYS FLUENT.

OBJECTIVE:

For Re = 100, simulate the flow over a cylinder using steady and transient mode.

  • In both approaches, deduce that the flow has converged. That is, what quantities or plots need to be looked at, to determine that the flow has converged?
  • How Strouhal number can be calculated in the steady and transient simulations?

INTRODUCTION:

External flows past objects have been studied extensively because of their many practical applications. For example, airfoils are made into streamline shapes in order to increase the lifts, and at the same time, reducing the aerodynamic drags exerted on the wings. On the other hand, flow past a blunt body, such as a circular cylinder, usually experiences boundary layer separation and very strong flow oscillations in the wake region behind the body. In certain Reynolds number range, a periodic flow motion will develop in the wake as a result of boundary layer vortices being shed alternatively from either side of the cylinder. This regular pattern of vortices in the wake is called a Karman vortex street. It creates an oscillating flow at a discrete frequency that is correlated to the Reynolds number of the flow. The periodic nature of the vortex shedding phenomenon can sometimes lead to unwanted structural vibrations, especially when the shedding frequency matches one of the resonant frequencies of the structure. One example is the famous Tacoma Narrow bridge incident and this topic has been discussed in great details in the Tacoma bridge link. In this project, I am going to investigate the flow past a circular cylinder and study the turbulent wake flow field using the FVM technique(CFD) adopted in ANSYS Fluent. A comprehensive discussion about many important flow concepts such as: boundary layer flow separation, wake flow, vortex shedding, vortex-induced oscillations, aerodynamic loading, momentum balance, and the lift and drag forces on an immerse body, will be given in the following section.

Flow Separation: The presence of the fluid viscosity slows down the fluid particles very close to the solid surface and forms a thin slow-moving fluid layer called a boundary layer. The flow velocity is zero at the surface to satisfy the no-slip boundary condition. Inside the boundary layer, flow momentum is quite low since it experiences a strong viscous flow resistance. Therefore, the boundary layer flow is sensitive to the external pressure gradient (as the form of a pressure force acting upon fluid particles). If the pressure decreases in the direction of the flow, the pressure gradient is said to be favourable. In this case, the pressure force can assist the fluid movement and there is no flow retardation. However, if the pressure is increasing in the direction of the flow, an adverse pressure gradient condition as so it is called exist. In addition to the presence of a strong viscous force, the fluid particles now have to move against the increasing pressure force. Therefore, the fluid particles could be stopped or reversed, causing the neighbouring particles to move away from the surface. This phenomenon is called the boundary layer separation.

Wake: Consider a fluid particle flows within the boundary layer around the circular cylinder. From the pressure distribution measured in an earlier experiment, the pressure is a maximum at the stagnation point and gradually decreases along the front half of the cylinder. The flow stays attached in this favourable pressure region as expected. However, the pressure starts to increase in the rear half of the cylinder and the particle now experiences an adverse pressure gradient. Consequently, the flow separates from the surface and creating a highly turbulent region behind the cylinder called the wake. The pressure inside the wake region remains low as the flow separates and a net pressure force (pressure drag) is produced.

Vortex Shedding: The boundary layer separates from the surface forms a free shear layer and is highly unstable. This shear layer will eventually roll into a discrete vortex and detach from the surface (a phenomenon called vortex shedding). Another type of flow instability emerges as the shear layer vortices shed from both the top and bottom surfaces interact with one another. They shed alternatively from the cylinder and generates a regular vortex pattern (the Karman vortex street) in the wake in above figure. The vortex shedding occurs at a discrete frequency and is a function of the Reynolds number. The dimensionless frequency of the vortex shedding, the shedding Strouhal number, St = f D/V, is approximately equal to 0.21 when the Reynolds number is greater than 1,000.

Vortex-Induced Vibrations: When vortices shed from the cylinder, uneven pressure distribution develops between the upper and lower surfaces of the cylinder, generating an oscillatory aerodynamic loading (lift) on the cylinder. This unsteady force can induce significant vibrations on a structure, especially if the "resonance" condition is met. The most famous example is the collapse of Tacoma Narrow bridge in 1940 under the action of wind-induced vibrations. It is believed that natural vortex shedding frequency behind the bridge matches one of the resonant modes of the bridge and eventually lead to a catastrophic vibration that destroys the bridge.

Aerodynamic Loading: According to the Newton's second law, time rate change of the linear momentum is equal to the sum of all external forces acting on a system. Therefore, an integration of the linear momentum inside a control volume surrounding the circular cylinder can provide information of the aerodynamic forces (lift and drag) acting on the cylinder. As shown in above figure, there are alternative upward and downward flows in the wake as the result of vortex shedding. Consequently, there must be also an oscillatory up and down force acting periodically on the cylinder. This periodic forcing exerting on the cylinder body is responsible for the vortex-induced vibrations as described earlier.

Momentum Balance: As stated earlier, the external force acting on an object can be determined using the momentum balance concept. In general, there is a momentum deficit in the wake profile along the streamwise direction as relative to the incoming momentum upstream of the object. Therefore, a simple balance of the momentum flow in and out of the control volume surrounding the object suggests that there is net force acting on the object. (note: the pressure is considered to be relatively constant if the momentum flow is measured far away from the object.) This net force along the flow direction is called the drag. Averaged velocity profiles of the flow past a circular cylinder is provided as a general representation of the wake flow field. Selected profiles at several representative regions is also presented for your reference. Near the cylinder, flow separates from the surface. Immediately behind the cylinder, a recirculation region exists with a strong reversing flow. The region between the cylinder and the end of the recirculation region is called the vortex formation region. The centreline velocity becomes zero at the end of the vortex formation region. Further downstream, the two separating shear layers merge and the velocity profile presents a typical wake profile. It is clear that there is a deficit in the center of the wake. This deficit in the momentum flow is the direct result of drag force acting on the cylinder.

In Meteorology:

The flow of atmospheric air over obstacles such as islands or isolated mountains sometimes gives birth to von Kármán vortex streets. When a cloud layer is present at the relevant altitude, the streets become visible. Such cloud layer vortex streets have been photographed from satellites. The vortex street can reach over 400 km from the obstacle and the diameter of the vortices are normally 20-40 km.

A look at the Kármán vortex street effect from ground level, as air flows quickly from the Pacific ocean eastward over Mojave desert mountains.

CFD INVESTIGATION:

Computational Domain:

CAD Model:

This is sketched in Space Claim. After sketching, it is transformed to surface with the help of 'Pull' option under Design and also the circle is deleted to create a circular void to make the cylinder wall. The entire green region is the entire computational domain. It is then opened for meshing in ANSYS Mesher.

Meshing:

Initially, the domain is meshed with quads by default. A 'Method' is selected under which the surface is filled with traids replacing all the quads. Now, in order to capture the Karman vortex street, we need to ensure that the mesh is pretty much refined, especially near the cylinder wall. Though ANSYS Mesher uses adaptive sizing,meaning it would make the mesh finer near curves or bends, a 'sizing' is adopted under which the cylinder periphery is selected and given a type of 'No. of divisions', 36 divisions are given to make the cylinder wall mesh look like a circle as depicted in the CAD model shown above. After this, inflation method is used to mesh the periphery or in other words provide a body fitted mesh to the boundary. The surface is selected as Geometry, the cylinder wall edge is selected as 'boundary'. Six layers are given as input with Inflation option as ' First Layer Thickness' with a thickness of 0.005m. After defining the mesh in such a way that it almost replicates the CAD model as shown above, the refinement is switched to 0.25m. The meshing along with element quality.

After this, naming is donw to easily implement the boundary conditions in Fluent. The left side is given inlet, the right side as the outlet, top and bottom as symmetric and the middle void as cylinder wall. This is now opened in ANSYS Fluent.

ANSYS Fluent is opened with ‘Contact Precision’ option checked in at the starting. Firstly, a mesh check is being conducted to see for any mesh quality abnormality. Once it’s done, the physics which governs the Flow Over the Cylinder simulation is checked in. Steady state approach and Transient Analysis is selected one at a time for a simulation to run. Pressure-based because the Mach No. for this problem is very less hence no negligible change in density. Velocity formulation is absolute. We also want to introduce the concept of viscosity into our problem. For this, additional equations will be solved, and viscosity will also influence the mixing of eddies region. Laminar viscous model is selected since the Re No. which we are trying to incorporate into our model is very low and also, experimantally it is proven that the Karman Street develops at low Re No.

For material selection, ‘Cell Zones’ is selected, and the volume is edited. There we will get the option of assigning the fluid or add and then assign. For this analysis, I have created a user defined material to make sure that the Re No. remains fixed and what we desire for, in this simulation. I had copied the characteristics of air and pasted it in user defined material and deleted 'air'. The density input is 1 kg/m^3 and kinematic viscosity as 0.02.

Now, assigning the boundary conditions, the outlet of the domain is a pressure B.C with gauge pressure as 0 Pascal. The inlet is given a velocity of 1m/s while the cylinder wall is given a No-slip boundary conditon.

Re = Velocity*Diameter/kinematic viscosity

= 1*2/0.02

= 100 , which is what I am running this simulation for.

At last, initialization is being done and the method used is Hybrid.

A monitor point is created in the wake of the flow so as to capture the vortex shedding. A Vertex averaging of velocity is done at the monitor point.

CASE I: Steady State Analysis

No. of iterations - 550

Velocity contour

Animation:

Velocity variation at monitor point

Residuals Plot

CASE II: Transient State Analysis

Time step size - 0.1s

No. of time steps - 1500

Time of run - 150s

The CFL criteria is kept in mind before putting the value for time step size.

Velocity contour

Animation:

Velocity variation at monitor point

Residuals Plot

DISCUSSION:

If we look at the velocity plot at the monitor point, for steady state, we can clearly see that after 400 iterations, the fluctuations in the velocity are following the same pattern. That is, we can deduce that the solution has converged after 400 iterations. This can also be validated with the residuals plot, in which all the three residuals are also converging after 400 iterations. For the transient analysis, we can see that after 25000 iterations the steady state is reached and there are no irregularities in the plot.Therefore, by examining these plots, we can say that the solution has converged.

The eddies or vortices that can be seen in the animation are what we call the Von-karman vortex shedding. This phenomenon is observed at low Reynolds Number. The fluctuations in the velocity plot and the animation show that the eddies are formed from both sides of the cylinder and are symmetric initially but as the flow progresses the eddies become asymmetric and alternatively causes the vortex shedding.

We cannot calculate the Strouhal Number(Sr) in steady state analysis because `Sr = (fL)/U` where, f = frequency of vortex shedding, L = characteristic length, U = flow velocity, but in steady state there is nothing as 'frequency' since the simulation is time indepenedent. In case of the transient analysis, we can calculate the Strouhal Number. I have calculated it manually by calculating the Time period for one fluctuation and determining the vortex shedding frequency from there.

I calculated the no. of iterations required for completion of one fluctuation. I started from the wave at 25000 iterations since from there onwards the irregularities seized out.

Iterations for one wave = (30000-25000)/4 = 5000/4 = 1250

30000 iterations are required for 150s. Therefore, 1250 iterations will require (150*1250)/30000 = 6.25 seconds.

Frequency = 1/Time period = 1/6.25 = 0.16 Hz.

Sr = fL/U = (0.16*2)/1 = 0.32.

METHODS FOR ENCOUNTERING THIS PROBLEM:

This phenomenon can happen anywhere anytime, but when the frequency of the fluctuating velocity mathces with the natural frequency of the object then it starts to oscillates at a high amplitude. This has caused destruction of many tall buildings and structures. To encounter this, few design modifications must be adopted.

1. Attaching a fin on the object in its downstream. The fin must be longer than the characteristic length of the object. This will forbade the eddies from meeting each other in the downstream and resulting in vortex shedding.

2. Making the cross section of the structure varying throughout its height. This will result in varying moment of inertia and hence varying natural frequency. This can be seen in the tallest building of the world, The Burj Khalifa. Its entire cross section is tapered.

3. Making swirl type design on the surface of the structure throughout its length as seen on some long chimneys.

Your portfolio, next

Ship work like this
in your own course.

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.