Week 1 Stress Concentration on a Plate with hole

For the above challenge both Case 1 & case 2 performed.

Steps followed:

1.Static structural seleted in Anys Workbench & renamed to respective case (Eg :Plate with hole)

2. Material Details added in Engineering Data

3. Sketch & 3D model created using Geometry Edit

4. Using Setup Edit - Material, Model Co-ordinate system have been checked

5. Force has been applied with Free & Fixed edge

6. Mesh have been provided

7. Stress & Deformation have been assinged & Result has been generated

Comparing the deformation and maximum stress developed on a structural steel model for the 2 cases:

Case 1 : Von-Mises Stress (Min - 0.015129 & Max - 1.2132) & Deformation (Min - 0 & Max - 0.00054984 )

Case 2: Von-Mises Stress (Min - 0.00053948 & Max - 0.58103) & Deformation (Min - 0 & Max - 0.00029727 )

Both From an analysis standpoint & manufacturing standpoint , I would select case 2 since the result of stress & deformation are less compared to case 1 value.

Please review & provide your feedback on the above. Thanks