Project

Analysis of stress concentration on a Plate and design stability verification.

PROJECT TITLE: TO CARRY OUT A STATIC STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS ON A PLATE WITH HOLES USING ANSYS WORKBENCH.

OBJECTIVES: 1. To create the model of plate with holes in Space claim.

  1. To analyse the results properly and to give a verdict about which design to use and which not, from an engineering perspective.

INTRODUCTION- In many practical cases we might come across some issues related to design where we cannot decide which design is suited for the purpose. We might not have the freedom to test it because of cost issues. Since, our problem also cannot be left unsolved therefore we have to take the help of computation for finding the results. ANSYS provides us the tool for computation.

In this project, I am going to analyse two designs and comment on which one to use based on the results of the simulations.

I will be using a plate with holes in it. There will be two cases:

CASE 1- Plate with single hole in the middle.

CASE 2- Plate with multiple holes.

The material used is Structural Steel for both the cases. Properties are given below-

CASE 1:

3D Model-

Dimensions:

Length-300mm,

Width-120mm,

Thickness-30mm

Hole dia.-60mm

After this structural steel is assigned to it. Then Meshing is done with the following characteristics:

The elements are changed to tetrahedrons for accuracy of the results.

The mesh size is refined to 3.2mm.

Here is the screenshot of the element quality along with the meshed model-

Boundary Conditions:

The plate is fixed on the left side.

A force of 500N is given on the right side.

RESULTS:

Total Deformation comes out to be a maximum of 2.74e-4mm and avg. of 1.37e-4mm with right side having the max. deformation since the load was applied to that side.

Animation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5BcFeqztXGE

Equivalent (Von-Mises) Stress comes out to be a maximum of 0.6107 MPa around the hole periphery.

Here’s the plot-

Animation: https: //www.youtube.com/watch?v=r-vdFNEYApo

CASE 2-

3D Model-

Dimensions:

Length-300mm,

Width-120mm,

Thickness-30mm,

Big hole dia.-60mm,

Smaller hole dia.-30mm and are at 90mm from centre of the bigger hole, same material is used.

Meshing- Meshing is done in the similar way as CASE 1. Just the refinement was reduced to 3.4mm to ensure that my model is with the no. of nodes/elements limit which is 32k for academic version.

Similar Boundary conditions are imposed on this model.

RESULTS:

Total Deformation comes out to be a maximum of 2.97e-4mm and avg. of 1.45e-4mm with right side having the max. deformation since the load was applied on that side.

Animation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oUGTt3DOK6U

Equivalent (Von-Mises) Stress comes out to be a maximum of 0.58282 MPa around the hole periphery.

Here’s the plot-

Animation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F0QiklwfLuU

CONCLUSION:

First, I want to list down the results in a tabular manner-

Total Deformation

AVERAGE VALUE (mm)

MAXIMUM VALUE (mm)

CASE 1

1.37e-4

2.74e-4

CASE 2

1.45e-4

2.97e-4

Equivalent Stress

AVERAGE VALUE (MPa)

MAXIMUM VALUE (MPa)

CASE 1

0.169

0.610

CASE 2

0.169

0.582

Therefore, we can clearly see that the stress developed in the plate with single hole (CASE1) is greater than that developed in the plate with multiple holes (CASE2). This is so because the stress that is developed in the multiple holes plate gets distributed due to the presence of smaller holes in the same plate which is not in the case of single hole plate.

From an analysis standpoint, I will surely refer the plate with multiple holes since it is resulting in lesser stress generation.

From a manufacturing standpoint it depends upon the operation in which the plate’s going to be used, if it happens that the plates are to be carried along as in say Automobiles then I will recommend the multi hole plate since it will be lighter along with lesser stress generation.

But if the operation is static in its place then one can also use single hole plate as it will save material as well as cost for punching extra holes.

Your portfolio, next

Ship work like this
in your own course.

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Talk to a career counsellor

Free 20-minute call. We'll map the right course to where you want to work.

By submitting you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.